The Midnight Film Society

150 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Movie talk with sharp edges and watchlist stamina.

The gist

The Midnight Film Society follows Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff through current movie news, recent watches, awards-season arguments, and assigned viewing. The tone is casual and opinionated, with room for folk horror symbolism, franchise anxiety, bad blockbuster frustration, and yearly top-ten ritual.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About The Midnight Film Society

The Midnight Film Society is a long-running movie conversation built around new releases, recent watches, awards season, and the small rituals of film fandom. Damian Sherman leads the show, with Derek McDuff joining him regularly. The format is steady without feeling rigid. Episodes open with check-ins and movie or TV news, then move through what the pair has been watching before arriving at the main titles and Letterboxd assignments. That structure gives the show room to roam. One episode can frame Project Hail Mary as the start of summer movie season, then turn toward Picnic at Hanging Rock and its unresolved, dreamlike mystery. Another can use the 98th Academy Awards to talk through upsets, favorite moments, Oscar trivia, and the strange endurance test of awards buildup. The show is comfortable with both enthusiasm and annoyance. It can celebrate a strange animated action film for its visual play, group dynamics, and emotional arc, then hammer a weak franchise movie for treating recognizable characters as future corporate plumbing. The criticism is casual, but it is not empty. Damian and Derek often return to whether a movie works on basic terms: jokes, action, symbolism, pacing, performances, and the feeling left behind days later. Their references move easily across eras and platforms. Erin Brockovich, sex, lies, and videotape, The Wicker Man, Industry, Batman v. Superman, Wonder Man, and Super Mario Galaxy can all become part of the same conversational weather. Awards talk is a major part of the show’s identity. So are watchlist catch-ups, local theater experiences, convention chatter, and the ongoing pressure of seeing enough movies to have an opinion worth defending. The tone is blunt, playful, sometimes messy, and clearly driven by people who watch a lot. It is not a pristine review desk. It is a living record of movie habits, arguments, disappointments, blind spots, and discoveries. Listeners who like tidy capsules may find it too digressive. Listeners who enjoy hearing taste develop aloud will feel at home. The best moments come when a throwaway complaint turns into a larger point about franchise filmmaking, ambiguity, genre pleasure, or why a supposedly disposable movie still deserves to be good.

Made for: For film fans who keep up with new releases, awards races, Letterboxd lists, and older blind spots. It especially suits listeners who like casual criticism with strong opinions and digressions left in.

What sets it apart: The show pairs awards-season tracking and release-week reactions with the feel of an ongoing private film club. Its range is the hook: Oscar stat talk, folk horror readings, franchise frustration, animation praise, and personal viewing projects all sit in the same conversation.

In their own words

What is The Midnight Film Society? It's a truly new, revolutionary and visionary podcast. It's two dudes talking about pop culture, movies and videos games. Follow me @Bisickle on Twitter, [email protected]

As heard by us

Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Seasonal previews, Letterboxd assignments and candid disagreement connect its film criticism to the habits of active moviegoing.

Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff turn the moviegoing calendar into a running conversation, pairing major releases with awards talk, seasonal previews and their own recent viewing.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

This is where your movie-night group chat gets Oscar snubs, Letterboxd homework, and gloriously blunt verdicts.

Press play if you want

  • Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff to argue past the polite consensus on new releases
  • awards-season predictions alongside candid post-screening reactions
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
movie and TV newsnew-release reviewsOscar nominations and ceremony recapsLetterboxd assignmentsrecent watches and blind spotsfranchise filmmaking complaintsfolk horror and ambiguous symbolismyear-end top ten lists

Talks about

Podcasts like The Midnight Film Society

Episodes

  1. 1

    #201 - Y2K/September 5/War Of The Rohirrim

    ·1h 30m
  2. 2

    #227 - 98th Academy Awards/The Bride!/Hoppers

    ·1h 29m
  3. 3

    #186 - Challengers Review

    ·1h 54m
  4. 4

    Interview With Anthony Gallegos

    ·1h 8m
  5. 5

    #185 - Civil War Review

    ·1h 34m
  6. 6

    #184 - 3 Body Problem, Godzilla🐲 X Kong🦍: The New Empire, Top 5 Movie-Going Experiences

    ·2h 6m
  7. 7

    #183 - Shōgun/Drive Away Dolls/Loves Lies Bleeding

    ·1h 22m
  8. 8

    The 2024 Oscars Reaction Show!

    ·1h 23m
  9. 9

    #182 - Dune: Part Two Review

    ·2h 6m
  10. 10

    #226 - The Testament Of Ann Lee/Send Help/Nirvana The Band The Show The Movie

    ·1h 36m
  11. 11

    #225 - Splitsville/Send Help/Iron Lung

    ·1h 6m
  12. 12

    #224 - Wonder Man/Erin Brockovich/F1

    ·1h 10m
  13. 13

    #223 - Most Anticipated Movies Of 2026/The Secret Agent/28 Years Later: The Bone Temple

    ·1h 58m
  14. 14

    #222 - Top Ten Movies Of 2025

    ·1h 59m
  15. 15

    #222 - The Best Movies Of 2025

    ·1h 59m
  16. 16

    #221 - Hamnet/Sentimental Value/If I Had Legs I’d Kick You

    ·1h 36m
  17. 17

    #220 - The Running Man/Wicked For Good/Keeper

    ·1h 15m
  18. 18

    #219 - The Mastermind/Die My Love/Train Dreams

    ·1h 4m
  19. 19

    #218 - Shelby Oaks/Black Phone 2/Roofman/Top 5 Post-2000s Horror

    ·1h 48m
  20. 20

    #217 - TRON: Ares/Misery/Hooptober Picks

    ·54m
  21. 21

    #216 - One Battle After Another/Caught Stealing/Alien Earth

    ·1h 19m
  22. 22

    #215 - 2025 Fall Movie Preview/Eyes Of Wakanda/I'm Still Here/

    ·1h 24m
  23. 23

    Interview w/ Documentary Filmmaker Ashley Sabin

    ·32m
  24. 24

    #214 - Weapons/Kpop Demon Hunters/Together

    ·1h
  25. 25

    #213 - FF4: First Steps/Sorry, Baby/Eddington

    ·1h 16m
  26. 26

    #212 - Superman/28 Years Later/Elio

    ·1h 20m
  27. 27

    #211 - The Phoenician Scheme/Bring Her Back/The Ballad Of Wallis Island

    ·1h 20m
  28. 28

    #210 - Top 5 Movies Of 2025 So Far

    ·1h 39m
  29. 29

    #209 - Thunderbolts/Andor/Final Destination:Bloodlines

    ·1h 31m
  30. 30

    #208 - Summer Movie Wager 2025

    ·1h 24m
  31. 31

    #206 - Captain America 4/Black Bag/Severance

    ·1h 44m
  32. 32

    The 2025 Oscar Show Special

    ·50m
  33. 33

    #204 - The Brutalist/Companion/Presence

    ·1h 21m
  34. 34

    #203 - RIP David Lynch/10 Most Anticipated Films Of 2025

    ·1h 41m
  35. 35

    Underrated - The Wolfman

    ·40m
  36. 36

    Top Ten Movies Of 2024

    ·2h 1m
  37. 37

    #288 - Project Hail Mary/Picnic at Hanging Rock/Ready or Not 2: Here I Come

    ·1h 7m
  38. 38

    #200 - Blitz/A Real Pain/Snack Shack

    ·1h 30m
  39. 39

    #199 - Anora/Conclave/Smile 2

    ·1h 17m
  40. 40

    #198 - The Apprentice/Boy's Don't Cry/Strangers On A Train

    ·1h 9m
  41. 41

    #197 - Megalopolis/Terrifier 3/VHS Beyond

    ·1h
  42. 42

    #196 - The Substance/Over The Garden Wall/My Old Ass

    ·1h 24m
  43. 43

    #195 - 2024 Fall Movie Preview

    ·1h 22m
  44. 44

    #194 - Cuckoo, Strange Darling, Borderlands

    ·1h 6m
  45. 45

    Special Edition - Alien Romulus

    ·42m
  46. 46

    #193 - Trap/It Ends With Us/Alien: Romulus

    ·1h 35m
  47. 47

    Comic Con 2024 Special Edition!

    ·1h 34m
  48. 48

    #192 - The Boys/The Bear/Longlegs/Twisters

    ·1h 21m
  49. 49

    #191 - Janet Planet/Firebrand/A Quiet Place: Day One

    ·1h 19m
  50. 50

    #190 - Inside Out 2/The Bikeriders/Top Ten Movies Of 2024 (So Far)

    ·1h 42m
  51. 51

    #189 - In A Violent Nature/Hacks/Station Eleven

    ·1h 42m
  52. 52

    Top 10 Films Of 1999

    ·1h 48m
  53. 53

    #188 - Furiosa/I Saw The TV Glow/Poolman

    ·2h 20m
  54. 54

    #188 - I Saw The TV Glow/Furiosa/Canne Finale

    ·2h 23m
  55. 55

    #187 - The Kingdom Of The Planet Of The Aps

    ·1h 50m
  56. 56

    Summer Movie Wager 2024

    ·1h 12m
  57. 57

    #181 - Lisa Frankenstein/Madame Web/Out of Darkness

    ·1h 21m
  58. 58

    #180 - All Of Us Strangers/American Fiction/The Zone Of Interest

    ·1h 44m
  59. 59

    2024 Oscars Nominations Reaction Show!!!

    ·1h 8m
  60. 60

    #179 - Humanist Vampire.../The Snowman/Top 10 Most Anticipated 2024 Films

    ·2h 15m
  61. 61

    Top 10 Films Of 2023

    ·2h 49m
  62. 62

    Underrated Spider-Man 3 Discussion

    ·1h 34m
  63. 63

    #178 - Eileen/Aquaman: The Lost Kingdom/Top 5 Best Christmas Movies

    ·1h 43m
  64. 64

    #177 - Godzilla Minus 1/Blue Eye Samurai/May December

    ·1h 42m
  65. 65

    #176 - The Killer/The Holdovers/The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes

    ·1h 46m
  66. 66

    #175 - Top 5 2023 Movies To Catch Up On/Loki S2/The Marvels

    ·1h 41m
  67. 67

    #174 - Killers Of The Flower Moon Review

    ·1h 30m
  68. 68

    #173 - The Fall Of The House Of Usher/Totally Killer/Top 5 Most Influential Horror Movies

    ·1h 40m
  69. 69

    #172 - No One Will Save You/Saw X/Top 5 Martin Scorsese Movies

    ·1h 41m
  70. 70

    #171 - Theater Camp/The Flash/The Haunting In Venice

    ·1h 29m
  71. 71

    #170 - Grand Turismo/Top 5 Everything Of 2023 Pt2

    ·2h 13m
  72. 72

    #169 - BarbenHiemer: Review - Pt2

    ·1h 33m
  73. 73

    #168 - BarbieHeimer Is Here!

    ·1h 58m
  74. 74

    #167 - Indiana Jones And The Dial Of Destiny Review

    ·1h 35m
  75. 75

    The Bear And Barry Review

    ·58m
  76. 76

    #166 - Asteroid City/Past Lives/Top 5 Characters That Formed US

    ·1h 49m
  77. 77

    #165 - SpiderMan: Across The Spider-Verse Review

    ·1h 6m
  78. 78

    *Bonus* Succession Finale Special

    ·1h 1m
  79. 79

    #164 - Top 5 Movies Of 2023 (So Far)

    ·1h 35m
  80. 80

    *Bonus* Succession - S4E9 'Church And State' Recap

    ·1h 10m
  81. 81

    #163 - Guardians Of The Galaxy 3 Review/Top GotG Moments

    ·2h 30m
  82. 82

    #162 - Evil Dead Rise/Mandalorian Finale/Jury Duty Reviews

    ·1h 56m
  83. 83

    #161 - Succession S4E3/Air/Super Mario Bros Reviews

    ·2h
  84. 84

    #160 - John Wick 4/Succession/Yellow Jackets Reviews

    ·1h 23m
  85. 85

    #159 - 2023 Oscar Results/TLOU Finale/Poker Face Finale/Ted Lasso Premiere Reviews

    ·1h 47m
  86. 86

    #158 - Oscar Predictions/Women Talking/The Whale/Creed 3 Reviews

    ·2h 2m
  87. 87

    #157 - Antman And The Wasp: Quantumania/Top 5 Antman MCU Moments

    ·1h 58m
  88. 88

    #156 - M3gan/Knock At The Cabin/Women Talking Reviewed

    ·1h 45m
  89. 89

    The 2023 Oscar Nominations Reaction Show

    ·33m
  90. 90

    #155 - The Last Of Us/10 Most Anticipated Nerd Movies/The Pale Blue Eye Reviews

    ·2h 1m
  91. 91

    Best Everything Of 2022

    ·3h 37m
  92. 92

    #153 - The 2022 Sight and Sound Poll/She Said/The Fabelmans/Aftersun Reviews

    ·1h 24m
  93. 93

    #152 - Andor/Decision To Leave/Bones And All/Devotion Reviews

    ·1h 37m
  94. 94

    #151 - Black Panther: Wakanda Forever/Tar/Banshees Of Inisherin Reviews

    ·1h 30m
  95. 95

    #150 Pt.2 - Andor/Halloween Ends/Ticket To Paradise Reviews

    ·1h 43m
  96. 96

    #150 Pt.1 - Top Five Favorite Death Scenes In Movies

    ·3h 7m
  97. 97

    #149 - She-Hulk Finale/Rings of Power/Smile/Hellraiser Reviews

    ·1h 14m
  98. 98

    Post-TIFF Roundup W/ Cinemateq

    ·34m
  99. 99

    Negative Space Author B.R. Yeager

    ·31m
  100. 100

    #207 - A Working Man/Death Of A Unicorn/Princess Mononoke

    Hosts Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff discuss recent movie news and review 'A Working Man', 'Death of a Unicorn', and the re-release of 'Princess Mononoke'.

    ·1h 11m
  101. 101

    #229 - The Drama/Super Mario Galaxy/Exit 8

    Hidden gem

    ["Damian Sherman opens Midnight Film Society episode 229 on Friday, April 17, 2026 by teeing up Christopher Borgli's The Drama, with Zendaya and Robert Pattinson as the headliners.", "The first stretch runs through Cannes 2026 names including Ryusuke Hamaguchi, Pedro Almod\u00f3var, Pawel Pawlikowski, Ira Sachs, Cristian Mungiu, Asghar Farhadi, Hirokazu Kore-eda, and Nicolas Winding Refn, plus a note that American directors are thin on the ground.", "Their watch list spans Peter Weir's The Year of Living Dangerously, Exit 8, Tarsem Singh's The Fall, Bernardo Bertolucci's The Last Emperor, Peter Weir's The Plumber, John Carpenter's Dark Star, and Primate.", "Derek McDuff's sharpest reactions come on Exit 8 and Super Mario Galaxy, where he calls the first a psychological horror adaptation and the second a plotless pile of fan service."]

    Apr 17, 2026·1h 19m·5 clips
  102. 102

    #228 - Project Hail Mary/Picnic at Hanging Rock/Ready or Not 2: Here I Come

    Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff discuss Lord and Miller's Project Hail Mary adaptation, Peter Weir's Picnic at Hanging Rock, and Ready or Not 2: Here I Come.

    Apr 3, 2026·1h 7m·5 clips
  103. 103

    #227 - 98th Academy Awards/The Bride!/Hoppers

    Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff discuss the 98th Academy Awards, movie and TV news, and their Letterboxd assignments.

    Mar 20, 2026·1h 29m
  104. 104

    #226 - The Testament Of Ann Lee/Send Help/Nirvana The Band The Show The Movie

    Mar 6, 2026·1h 36m
  105. 105

    #225 - Splitsville/Send Help/Iron Lung

    Hosts Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff discuss movies about people trapped in various settings, including Sam Ramey's Senhulp, Marge Fishback's Iron Long, and Gore Verbinski's Good Luck, Have Fun, Don't Die, along with movie news and their Letterboxd assignments.

    Feb 20, 2026·1h 6m
  106. 106

    #224 - Wonder Man/Erin Brockovich/F1

    Hidden gem

    Damian Sherman and Derek Duff frame episode 224 of The Midnight Film Society around February 6, 2026, a batch of movie news, and their month-end catch-up after "Dumpuary." The sharpest discussion turns to Markiplier’s "Iron Lung" adaptation, which they say opened on about 3,475 screens and turned a three million dollar budget into roughly "$21 million." They also argue about Joseph Kosinski’s "F1," with Brad Pitt, Damson Idris, Javier Bardem, and Kerry Condon all named while Derek calls it a "legacy sequel for a movie that doesn't exist." The rest of the conversation moves through Catherine O’Hara, "Erin Brockovich," "Brokeback Mountain," and a run of older film discoveries, with several of those titles discussed as first-time watches.

    Feb 6, 2026·1h 10m·2 clips
  107. 107

    #223 - Most Anticipated Movies Of 2026/The Secret Agent/28 Years Later: The Bone Temple

    Hidden gem

    Ryan Coogler's Sinners gets 16 nominations, and the hosts explain why the new casting award matters.

    Jan 25, 2026·1h 58m·2 clips
  108. 108

    #222 - Top Ten Movies Of 2025

    Hidden gem

    Midnight Film Society episode 222, dated January 9, 2026, is Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff's countdown of their favorite movies of 2025.

    Jan 14, 2026·1h 59m·5 clips
  109. 109

    #222 - The Best Movies Of 2025

    Jan 9, 2026·1h 59m
  110. 110

    #221 - Hamnet/Sentimental Value/If I Had Legs I’d Kick You

    Dec 12, 2025·1h 36m
  111. 111

    #220 - The Running Man/Wicked For Good/Keeper

    Nov 28, 2025·1h 15m
  112. 112

    #219 - The Mastermind/Die My Love/Train Dreams

    Nov 14, 2025·1h 4m
  113. 113

    #218 - Shelby Oaks/Black Phone 2/Roofman/Top 5 Post-2000s Horror

    Oct 31, 2025·1h 48m
  114. 114

    #217 - TRON: Ares/Misery/Hooptober Picks

    Oct 18, 2025·54m
  115. 115

    #216 - One Battle After Another/Caught Stealing/Alien Earth

    Oct 3, 2025·1h 19m
  116. 116

    #215 - 2025 Fall Movie Preview/Eyes Of Wakanda/I'm Still Here/

    Midnight Film Society episode 215, dated September 19, 2025, opens with Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff setting up fall awards season, TIFF, and the week's movie news.

    Sep 19, 2025·1h 24m·5 clips
  117. 117

    Interview w/ Documentary Filmmaker Ashley Sabin

    Documentary filmmaker Ashley Sabin discusses her career, how she got into filmmaking, and how her approach has evolved over 20 years.

    Sep 3, 2025·32m
  118. 118

    #214 - Weapons/Kpop Demon Hunters/Together

    Aug 18, 2025·1h
  119. 119

    #213 - FF4: First Steps/Sorry, Baby/Eddington

    Aug 1, 2025·1h 16m
  120. 120

    #212 - Superman/28 Years Later/Elio

    Jul 18, 2025·1h 20m
  121. 121

    #211 - The Phoenician Scheme/Bring Her Back/The Ballad Of Wallis Island

    Jun 20, 2025·1h 20m
  122. 122

    #210 - Top 5 Movies Of 2025 So Far

    Jun 6, 2025·1h 39m
  123. 123

    #209 - Thunderbolts/Andor/Final Destination:Bloodlines

    May 23, 2025·1h 31m
  124. 124

    #208 - Summer Movie Wager 2025

    May 2, 2025·1h 24m
  125. 125

    #207 - A Working Man/Death Of A Unicorn/Princess Mononoke

    Apr 11, 2025·1h 11m
  126. 126

    #206 - Captain America 4/Black Bag/Severance

    Mar 31, 2025·1h 44m
  127. 127

    The 2025 Oscar Show Special

    Mar 4, 2025·50m
  128. 128

    #204 - The Brutalist/Companion/Presence

    Feb 17, 2025·1h 21m
  129. 129

    #203 - RIP David Lynch/10 Most Anticipated Films Of 2025

    Jan 20, 2025·1h 41m
  130. 130

    Underrated - The Wolfman

    Jan 14, 2025·40m
  131. 131

    Top Ten Movies Of 2024

    Jan 6, 2025·2h 1m
  132. 132

    #201 - Y2K/September 5/War Of The Rohirrim

    Dec 23, 2024·1h 30m
  133. 133

    #200 - Blitz/A Real Pain/Snack Shack

    Nov 25, 2024·1h 30m
  134. 134

    #199 - Anora/Conclave/Smile 2

    Nov 11, 2024·1h 17m
  135. 135

    #198 - The Apprentice/Boy's Don't Cry/Strangers On A Train

    Oct 28, 2024·1h 9m
  136. 136

    #197 - Megalopolis/Terrifier 3/VHS Beyond

    Oct 15, 2024·1h
  137. 137

    #196 - The Substance/Over The Garden Wall/My Old Ass

    Sep 30, 2024·1h 24m
  138. 138

    #195 - 2024 Fall Movie Preview

    Hosts Damian Sherman and Derek McDowell preview the 2024 fall movie season, recap summer movie winners and losers, and discuss recent movie and TV news.

    Sep 14, 2024·1h 22m
  139. 139

    #194 - Cuckoo, Strange Darling, Borderlands

    Sep 2, 2024·1h 6m
  140. 140

    Special Edition - Alien Romulus

    Aug 20, 2024·42m
  141. 141

    #193 - Trap/It Ends With Us/Alien: Romulus

    Damian Sherman and Derek McDuff discuss the 2024 summer movie season, including films like Trap, It Ends With Us, and Alien: Romulus, and check in on their summer movie wager.

    Aug 19, 2024·1h 35m
  142. 142

    Comic Con 2024 Special Edition!

    Aug 1, 2024·1h 34m
  143. 143

    #192 - The Boys/The Bear/Longlegs/Twisters

    Jul 22, 2024·1h 21m
  144. 144

    #191 - Janet Planet/Firebrand/A Quiet Place: Day One

    Jul 8, 2024·1h 19m
  145. 145

    #190 - Inside Out 2/The Bikeriders/Top Ten Movies Of 2024 (So Far)

    Jun 24, 2024·1h 42m
  146. 146

    #189 - In A Violent Nature/Hacks/Station Eleven

    Jun 10, 2024·1h 42m
  147. 147

    Top 10 Films Of 1999

    May 31, 2024·1h 48m
  148. 148

    #188 - Furiosa/I Saw The TV Glow/Poolman

    May 28, 2024·2h 20m
  149. 149

    #188 - I Saw The TV Glow/Furiosa/Canne Finale

    May 27, 2024·2h 23m
  150. 150

    #187 - The Kingdom Of The Planet Of The Aps

    May 13, 2024·1h 50m