Ghostly Thistle
29 episodes listed below
Ghost stories with a guilty conscience.
The McIlwraith Statements follows Sarah McIlwraith as she revisits her role in Investigations into Paranormal Phenomena. The cases move through haunted houses, alleged possession, mediums, dreams, cover-ups, and the ruin left behind when belief and ambition curdle together.
PRESS PLAY
The McIlwraith Statements is a supernatural fiction series told as a bruised account of a public scandal and the private hauntings behind it. Its centre is Sarah McIlwraith, whose connection to ghosts places her inside the IPP study, Investigations into Paranormal Phenomena. The premise sounds like a paranormal case file. The experience is closer to a guilty witness statement, given years too late and with every room still remembered in uncomfortable detail. The show returns again and again to the difference between proof and truth. Dr Robin Strother's study is described as disgraced, but Sarah's recollections suggest a messier story than forged results and scientific fraud. Episodes move carefully through haunted properties, troubled families, mediums, old institutions, religious fear, and the strange logistics of trying to measure what refuses to behave like evidence. The horror is often quiet. A door will not close, a room stays cold, a figure appears where no one else can see it, or a group of ghosts stare at something nobody living understands. Then the real unease arrives, because people bring their pride, grief, suspicion, and need for control into every investigation. The show is especially strong when skepticism and belief fail at the same time. Priests may be biased. Scientists may be arrogant. Mediums may be false, real, frightened, or dangerous to know. Sarah's own judgment is never spotless, and the narration keeps circling back to what she missed, what she excused, and what she still cannot fully explain. Later episodes widen the story through lucid dreams, a recurring sense of inherited sight, and Margaret Donaldson's role in violence against mediums and psychics. It is not a brisk monster-of-the-week series. It is patient, grave, and thick with aftermath, using supernatural cases to examine ruined careers, moral cowardice, and the terrible comfort of deciding that someone else deserved what happened. Listeners who enjoy intimate paranormal drama, investigative structure, and slow-burn gothic unease will find a show that treats ghosts as both literal presences and unfinished business.
Made for: For listeners who like slow-burn supernatural fiction, unreliable memory, paranormal investigations, and horror shaped by consequence rather than spectacle.
What sets it apart: It treats ghosts, mediums, and possession through the language of regret, failed evidence, and institutional damage, making each case feel like part confession and part investigation.
Sarah McIlwraith is haunted by the past. It doesn’t help that she can also see ghosts. Listen to Sarah as she recounts her involvement in the infamous IPP study, and her search for the truth behind the disaster.
Based on 5 episodes we listened to · September 2026
A first-person supernatural serial where paranormal cases, scientific doubt, and buried guilt steadily tighten around Sarah's account of the IPP study.
The McIlwraith Statements turns Sarah's recorded recollections into a tightly connected supernatural serial, with the disgraced IPP study supplying both its mystery and its emotional pressure.
The recorder clicks on, and you inherit fifteen years of guilt, ghosts, and one ruined paranormal study.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A tense episode that turns a coffee-shop meeting into an ugly reckoning.
The McIlwraith Statements closes on a coffee-shop meeting that feels pointed because it is so controlled: the speaker picks the place, brings the files, and tries to force Margaret Donaldson to answer for what she has done.
A measured Edinburgh haunting that builds its fear through watching and waiting.
A house museum in Edinburgh is framed as a patient haunting, where the unease comes from staff movement, shifting rooms, cameras, and the stubborn difficulty of fixing on anything that will not stay still.
A patient, haunted return to the study's end, where guilt and doubt finally stop keeping their distance.
This episode returns to the study's end and the guilt the narrator has carried for nearly three years. Its strength is the steady grip on concrete detail: the asylum, the van, and Ewan Brodie's arrival.
A possession story that keeps skepticism uneasily in the room.
The episode follows a young woman who is said to be possessed, and it keeps medicine, faith, and skepticism in uneasy contact. Strother wants to rule demons out, while the narrator stays wary, since ghosts are one thing and demons are another.
A slow burn confession where office clutter and old scandal turn colder.
Sarah McElwraith tells the story like a confession, and that is what gives the episode its pull. It stays with Dr Robin Strothers, the man tied to the IPP scandal, and the moment a stranger walks into the office and starts going through papers.
A dreamlike brothel haunting ties fear to rumor, shame, and duty.
Episode 23 keeps returning to a recurring dream set in a village of stone cottages. The details are vivid enough to carry the scene on their own: dirt roads, chimneys, carts, horses, and women in white linen caps.
Serialized pulp radio drama: Red Panda battles android-army supervillain Captain Clockwork in 1930s Toronto.
Deborah Treisman and a guest writer read and dissect one archival short story monthly.
Mike Muncer and a different guest dissect two horror films per episode, by subgenre.
A recurring dream keeps changing on her.
A hard story arrives before its details can slip away.
The team visits a house museum in Edinburgh that has picked up a reputation for hauntings.
Episode 14 of The McIlwraith Statements follows the narrator Sarah as she recounts a paranormal investigation of an abandoned Victorian asylum in Scotland, two years into the study she has been describing across the series.
Sarah recounts her team's investigation into Heather McQueenie, a young woman allegedly possessed by a demon, exploring tensions between science and religion.
This is the first episode of The McIlwraith Statements, in which Sarah McIlwraith introduces herself as the unnamed data analyst who worked on Dr Robin Strother's paranormal research study — a study that became one of the most notorious scientific scandals of its era.