Cult-film criticism at full speed.
Swimfans treats movies like live wires: plot recap first, then a rush of jokes, visual detail, cultural read, and argument. The panel moves from Fresh Kill’s toxic sushi capitalism to Dark City’s breathless cutting without sanding off the weird edges.
PRESS PLAY
Swimfans is a rapid, film-literate panel show built around movies that invite strong reactions. It is casual, but not casual about cinema. Episodes tend to start with freewheeling banter, then settle into scene-level criticism that notices rhythm, framing, costumes, performance choices, and the strange social pressure inside a film’s world. The show is especially alive when the movie is thorny. Fresh Kill becomes a conversation about toxicity, consumption, class performance, and the lure of belonging to a broken system. Vulcanizadora becomes a test case for abrasive pacing, spartan detail, independent-film conviction, and violence that arrives fast and leaves the viewer sitting with it. Dark City opens into a discussion of breathless editing, noir momentum, and what happens when a movie refuses to vary its register. Oscar coverage lets the panel argue through prestige drama, acting choices, family melodrama, artistic ego, and where a film’s stated emotional logic does or does not hold. The references come quickly. So do the corrections. A comparison to The Matrix, mumblecore, JRPGs, or a red-carpet joke can appear without much warning, but the point usually returns to the movie in front of them. Swimfans is not polished awards-show recitation or tidy academic analysis. It is louder, stranger, and more conversational than that. The panel’s rhythm is full of interruption, self-revision, and callback, which gives the criticism a live-wire feeling. The jokes can be edgy, and the films under discussion often involve sex, violence, despair, family damage, or body horror-adjacent intensity. Still, the show’s main engine is enthusiasm. It cares about how films move, how they look, what they are trying to get away with, and why a flawed or difficult object can still feel worth arguing over for hours.
Made for: For film fans who like fast panel chemistry, concrete formal analysis, and messy arguments about cult movies, prestige releases, and strange genre objects.
What sets it apart: Swimfans pairs chaotic conversational energy with unusually specific scene-level observation. It can joke for minutes, then land a careful read of editing tempo, social class, performance, or production design.
#1 EROTIC THRILLER/TEEN MOVIE PODCAST IN THE WORLD. TRUST NO GHOUL
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Swimfans pairs freewheeling host chemistry with unusually specific attention to how movies look, move, and make their arguments.
Swimfans turns film discussion into a lively collision of close criticism and unruly conversation. Josh McKenzie, Craig Neeson, and Jennifer Hocking move from jokes and personal detours into precise arguments about performance, editing, production design, and narrative…
Dark City's rapid cuts get a close reading; you get the filthy group chat attached.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A lively Fresh Kill discussion links glowing fish, class ritual, and cinematic self-harm into one strange ecosystem.
Fresh Kill gives the Swimfans panel a dense, unsettled object to work through: Shireen and Claire raising Honey near the Fresh Kills dump, salvaged objects carrying social residue, and Claire and Johnny's sushi bar turning glowing fish into a scene of appetite, status, and…
A loose, sharply observed conversation about family drama, performance, and Craig as a youth pastor.
Swimfans finds a useful angle in the odd gap between religious riffing and family drama. A quick run on clasped hands, mortal sins, and Craig as a youth pastor gives way to a fuller discussion of a film where an actress rejects a role from a director she hates, then sees the…
A brisk, unruly Oscar-season debate asks whether polished craft can make up for a shaky central chemistry.
Swimfans starts its Oscar-season Best Picture coverage with the first five directors in a two-part run through ten nominees, but the red-carpet framing is quickly overtaken by Truman Capote jokes, MDMA wordplay, and a mock warning about keeping 50 yards away.
A quick, funny review of a film where every new character brings a whole visual world with them.
Swim Fangs starts with a loose, profane panel exchange, then narrows into a lively appreciation of a film that treats every new character and location as a visual dare.
A lively PlayNext discussion of relentless editing, rhythm, and the strain behind the film's momentum.
This PlayNext review frames the episode around the film's defining pressure point: the cut. Matthew Tuceroni and the panel keep returning to the feeling of speed, weighing short shots, relentless momentum, and the contrast with The Matrix's more pronounced swings between action…
Loose, lore-heavy Star Wars conversation.
The hosts of Swim Fans playfully brainstorm code names for their hypothetical spy outfit, referencing the film Three Days of the Condor.
Swimfans discusses Greg Araki's 1997 film Nowhere, the third film in the teenage apocalypse trilogy and a one-day Los Angeles story centered on Dark, Mel, Lucifer, and Montgomery.
A group of friends engage in darkly humorous banter about therapy, secrets, and Jeffrey Dahmer, with a mention of a Patreon bonus episode.
A podcaster shares his experience of feeling sick after an intense leg day workout, mistaking muscle soreness for COVID-19.
The hosts introduce a choose-your-own-adventure episode revisiting movies influenced by The Matrix.
The hosts discuss the 1992 film Unlawful Entry, focusing on its plot and Ray Liotta's role.
The hosts of Swimfans, Josh McKenzie, Craig Neeson, Spiral Alex, and guest Matthew Tucciarone, discuss the 1998 Alex Proyas film 'Dark City.' They provide a detailed plot summary, noting the amnesiac protagonist John Murdoch, the mysterious Strangers who reshape the city nightly, and the twist that the city is a spaceborne terrarium.
Swimfans’ Josh, McKenzie, and Craig Newson review Lucio Fulci’s 1981 film The Beyond, set at a New Orleans hotel.
The hosts introduce the 1994 film Fresh Kill, about a lesbian couple in New York City dealing with a giant dump and a multinational corporation.
A podcast episode where hosts discuss the 2024 film Vulcanizadora, about two men camping in the woods.
Two friends discuss the name Josh, its cultural associations, and its appearance in JRPGs like Final Fantasy 16.
Kevin Jay Stanton joins to discuss the film 'In the Mood for Love' and reminisce about 2000s fashion trends like studded belts.
Matt and Jennifer discuss Matt's new sourdough hobby and gender role reversals before introducing the podcast's Oscar coverage.
Swimfans podcast covers five 2026 Oscar-nominated films: One Battle After Another (Paul Thomas Anderson), The Secret Agent (Kleber Mendonça Filho), Sentimental Value (Joachim Trier), Sinners (Ryan Coogler), and Train Dreams (Clint Bentley).
Swimfans hosts Josh McKenzie, Craig Neeson, and Jennifer Hawking cover the first five 2026 Oscar Best Picture nominees: Begonia (Yorgos Lanthimos), F1 (Joseph Kosinski), Frankenstein (Guillermo del Toro), Hamnet (Chloe Zhao), and Marty Supreme (Josh Safdie).