Deja vu becomes a tidy, unsettling puzzle built from one ordinary meeting.
The episode turns deja vu into a small, unnerving puzzle, starting with the ordinary jolt of being in a meeting and feeling as if every line has already happened.

Audiochuck | Crime House
211 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
Most mysteries can be solved by looking at the facts. But sometimes, the truth lies somewhere in the unknown… Enter the realm of true crime’s most bizarre occurrences, and unravel all the possible explanations. No matter how strange or surreal they get.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
So Supernatural tests eerie claims against testimony, records and alternative explanations while preserving the pleasure of an unresolved story.
So Supernatural treats uncanny stories as cases to be examined, pairing Ashley Flowers' narrative guidance with conversational reactions that keep belief and doubt in the same room.
A haunted house meets parental burnout; you can keep one eyebrow raised for both.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Deja vu becomes a tidy, unsettling puzzle built from one ordinary meeting.
The episode turns deja vu into a small, unnerving puzzle, starting with the ordinary jolt of being in a meeting and feeling as if every line has already happened.
A Yale secret society story that turns family dynasties, tomb lore, and political power into a single slow burn.
Supernatural frames Skull and Bones as a climb from campus self-discovery to a Yale secret society whose reach runs into the presidency, business, and politics.
A reincarnation story that keeps turning up details the skeptics have to work through.
The episode traces a reincarnation claim through a staged test of memory, photographs, and family details, and it works best when it keeps asking for proof instead of leaning only on storytelling.
A Cape Girardeau UFO legend built around a smuggled photo and a trail of testimony.
The episode frames a 1941 UFO crash in Cape Girardeau, Missouri, as a hometown legend that only grows more elaborate with time. It moves from a pastor said to have given last rites at the wreck to a smuggled photograph, then into the uneasy business of evidence that is supposed…
An internet-born Elevator Game story that ties into the Elisa Lam case without losing its eerie pull.
This episode traces an internet-born Elevator Game tale from its creepy rules and recorded attempts into the Elisa Lam case, which explains why the folklore kept its hold.
Elvis turns more intriguing when the story follows his mystic side.
Elvis Presley is presented less as the king of rock and roll than as a man pulled toward mysticism, the occult, natural healing, and a possible UFO encounter.
A measured retelling that lets the strange activity escalate in steady, unsettling steps.
So Supernatural tracks a London family in the late 1970s, with four little kids drawn into a case where furniture shifts, matches flare, and toys begin to move.
A brisk, creepy revisit that keeps the reported haunting easy to follow and hard to shake.
So Supernatural revisits the Gary, Indiana Demon House with a brisk, conversational pace that keeps the reported haunting easy to track and difficult to dismiss.






So Supernatural hosts Rasha Pecoraro and Yvette Gentile explore reincarnation — the belief that souls return to Earth in new bodies after death — through a combination of personal anecdotes and reported cases where individuals provided specific, verifiable details about past lives they had no conventional way of knowing.
This episode explores the conspiracy theory that the Vatican possesses a device called the chronovisor, built in the 1950s, which allegedly allows priests to view historical events like Cicero's speeches in Ancient Rome.
This episode explores the mysterious Dodleston Messages, a rumored case of time travel communication through technology, connecting it to the nostalgia of pen pals and modern social media.
This episode explores the mysterious 1953 Kinross Incident where a fighter jet disappeared over Lake Superior while pursuing an unidentified aircraft.
This episode explores the concept of the Akashic Records as a spiritual repository of soul information, using Edgar Cayce's experiences to illustrate how accessing it can aid in self-awareness and healing.
This episode explores the 1942 Battle of Los Angeles UFO incident, connecting it to the 1938 War of the Worlds radio hoax and examining government responses to potential alien threats.
This episode explores near death experiences and the possibility of an afterlife through interviews and research, challenging our fear of death.
This episode explores the haunting of the Pritchard family in 1966 England by the Black Monk of Pontefract, a spirit that was once a man of faith, examining themes of exorcism and spiritual conflict.
This episode explores the mysterious phenomenon of animal mutilations in remote wilderness areas, where livestock are found dead with surgical precision and no explanation.
This episode explores the mysterious case of John Titor, an online figure who claimed to be a time traveler from 2036 and made dark predictions about the future.
This episode explores the mystical and healing aspects of the ocean while hinting at hidden dangers and true crime stories in natural settings.
The host discusses the mysterious Naga Fireball Festival in Thailand, where glowing red fireballs rise from the Mekong River each October, exploring its supernatural allure and unexplained origins.
This episode introduces 'The Final Hours', a true crime podcast hosted by Sarah Turney and Kourtney Nichole that examines the moments leading up to disappearances through detailed timeline analysis and lived experience.
This episode explores the phenomenon of the 'third man factor,' where people in life-threatening situations report encounters with a guiding presence, questioning whether it's a psychological coping mechanism or supernatural contact.
This episode explores the haunted history of Bobby Mackey's Music World, a Kentucky honky tonk bar known for supernatural encounters, satanic rituals, and claims of being a gateway to hell.
This episode features an interview with native Hawaiian storyteller Lopaka Kapanui discussing Madame Pele and supernatural legends in Hawaii.
This episode features Native Hawaiian Master Storyteller Lopaka Kapanui discussing the Night Marchers legend and other Hawaiian supernatural folklore.
This episode explores savant syndrome, a medical mystery where people suddenly gain extraordinary skills after brain injuries or disorders.
This episode explores the suspicious circumstances and conspiracy theories surrounding Operation Highjump, a 1946 U.S.
This episode explores the 1903 Van Meter incident where dozens of people in a small Iowa town reported encountering a mysterious cryptid with a blinding light, terrible stench, and bulletproof qualities.
This episode explores the mysterious disappearance of an entire Inuit village at Anjikuni Lake in northern Canada in 1930, where villagers vanished suddenly, leaving behind evidence of a hasty and possibly supernatural threat.
This episode explores the 1977 Colares UFO incident in Brazil, where residents reported being attacked by a UFO with lasers that caused physical harm, challenging hopeful narratives about benevolent aliens.
This episode explores the conspiracy theory that the U.S.
This episode explores the theory of ghosts as residual energy trapped in space, using the 2002 case of a ghost car crash witnessed in Surrey, England as a compelling example.
Sisters Yvette and Rasha have an emotional conversation with celebrity astrologer Aliza Kelly, who reads their birth charts and their mother's chart, deepening their family connection through astrology.
This episode explores the 1989 alien abduction case of Linda Napolitano in Manhattan, challenging typical UFO stereotypes by occurring in a densely populated urban area.
This episode explores a haunted house case in San Pedro, California, where a woman used a Ouija board to identify a ghost, revealing a story that goes beyond typical paranormal activity.
This episode explores the mysterious Zone of Silence in Mexico's Chihuahuan Desert, where cell phones hardly work and strange phenomena occur, introduced by the Park Predators podcast host Delia D'Ambra.
This episode explores the urban legend of Bloody Mary through a nostalgic 1999 teenage sleepover scenario, connecting it to true crime stories in wilderness settings.
This episode explores Pluckley Village in Kent, England, which holds the Guinness World Record as the most haunted town with 17 reported ghosts tied to real historical events.
This episode explores the theory that alien invasions might involve Unidentified Submerged Objects (USOs) rather than the typical Hollywood depiction of spacecraft descending from the sky.
This episode discusses the discovery of an interstellar comet named 3I Atlas, its unusual flight path suggesting possible intelligent origin, and its connection to the Sagittarius constellation and historical signs of extraterrestrial life.
This episode explores the mysterious case of Dorothy Eady, who after a near-fatal fall in childhood began recalling detailed memories of a past life in ancient Egypt.
This episode explores the chilling 1971 case of Maria Gomez Camara in Spain, who discovered ghostly faces appearing in her kitchen floor, leading to an even more disturbing discovery when the concrete was removed.
This episode revisits the dark holiday legend of Krampus, exploring its eerie traditions and growing popularity in modern celebrations like SantaCon.
This episode investigates the mysterious and supernatural side of Elvis Presley, exploring theories that he had occult powers, telekinesis, and connections to aliens.
Hosts Yvette Gentile and Rasha Pecoraro cover the 1966 Westall UFO incident, in which over 200 students, teachers, and staff at Westall High School near Melbourne, Australia witnessed a large metallic craft descend, hover, and apparently land in a field behind the school.
So Supernatural hosts Yvette Gentile and Rasha Pecoraro investigate the 1941 Cape Girardeau, Missouri UFO crash — a lesser-known incident that occurred six years before Roswell and is sometimes called the Roswell before Roswell.
So Supernatural host Ashley Flowers takes over the episode to investigate deja vu, driven by personal obsession with the phenomenon.
This episode explores the mysterious 1942 disappearance of two Navy pilots from a blimp that crashed in Daly City, California, examining various theories about their fate.
The episode explores the Enfield Poltergeist case from 1977, where a family in London experiences furniture moving, strange noises, and poltergeist activity centered on their 11-year-old daughter Janet.
So Supernatural revisits one of its most popular episodes — the 2011 case of Latoya Almonds and her family in Gary, Indiana, who moved into a rental house at 3860 Carolina Street and within months reported escalating supernatural phenomena: swarms of unexplained black flies, shadowy figures, oversized muddy boot prints with no source, children allegedly levitating, and family members being thrown across rooms by unseen forces.
Yvette Gentile and Rasha Pecoraro explore Baba Yaga, the ancient Slavic witch figure who appears in folklore since at least 1755 and may have roots in far older oral traditions.
So Supernatural hosts Yvette Gentile and Rasha Pecoraro investigate the Elevator Game, a paranormal ritual that emerged from Korean and Japanese internet forums around 2008-2011 and spread to English-language horror communities.
The episode explores the haunted story of Bob Cranmer and his family, who experienced severe paranormal activity in their Pittsburgh dream home, including demonic possession, exorcisms, and historical tragedies tied to the property.
This episode explores the legend of the lost city of Atlantis, from Plato's original writings to modern archaeological theories.
So Supernatural hosts Rasha Pecoraro and Yvette Gentile investigate Skull and Bones, the Yale University secret society founded in 1832 whose members have included multiple US presidents.
The host promotes another true crime podcast and shares personal experiences as a flight attendant, setting up a discussion of supernatural true crime cases.
The episode promotes another podcast and then introduces the story of La Llorona, a classic supernatural legend.
The episode begins with ads and then introduces a discussion about the iconic Hollywood sign in Los Angeles.
The episode promotes another true crime podcast and then introduces a discussion about disturbing and supernatural content on YouTube.
The episode discusses the Loch Ness Monster as a famous cryptid, highlighting its history and sightings.
The episode promotes another podcast and then introduces a bizarre medical mystery involving a patient with cervical cancer.
The hosts introduce a bonus AMA episode where they share personal stories and answer listener questions.
The episode discusses the Bell Witch haunting, a supernatural case of a family tormented by a malevolent entity for four years.
This episode covers the disappearance of Maria Martin in 1827, as revealed through a dream experienced by her stepmother.
This episode explores the 1952 Flatwoods, West Virginia monster sighting, a classic unexplained mystery.