So Supernatural · Audiochuck | Crime House

THE UNKNOWN: Reincarnation

·42 min·3 clips

A five-year-old points to a photo and says, 'That's me,' revealing a past life as a Hollywood agent no one remembers.

So Supernatural is hosted by Rasha Pecoraro and Yvette Gentile for AudioChuck. This episode is framed with Ashley Flowers providing the introduction, positioning the question of what happens after death as the greatest mystery of human existence. The hosts note that people go to war over competing answers to this question, and that reincarnation — the idea that the soul returns in a new body to live again — is one of the most widely held answers across the world's belief systems. Both hosts say they personally believe in reincarnation and past lives. Yvette shares her own past life experience, which she describes as having occurred in the late 1980s when she and her mother visited a house in Los Angeles built by Lloyd Wright and previously occupied by her great-grandfather George Hodel. At the end of the house, facing an outdoor performance area and pool, Yvette experienced a sudden and vivid sense that she was a woman in a flapper outfit, performing and entertaining a crowd. She had no prior knowledge that this area had been used for parties or performance, but later confirmed this. The hosts then move into a series of reported reincarnation cases where children — typically between ages two and six, before the supposed memories fade — provided highly specific and verifiable details about previous lives in places they had never visited, with identities they had no way of knowing about. The episode approaches these accounts with genuine curiosity rather than debunking or uncritical acceptance, presenting them as worthy of serious consideration within the broader question of what constitutes evidence about consciousness and survival after death.

As heard by us

A reincarnation story that keeps turning up details the skeptics have to work through.

The episode traces a reincarnation claim through a staged test of memory, photographs, and family details, and it works best when it keeps asking for proof instead of leaning only on storytelling.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a reincarnation case that keeps turning up specific receipts.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from So Supernatural