Slice By Slice is a horror discussion show shaped by categories, franchises, directors, and the habits of people who keep horror in their regular calendar. Jesse and Josh anchor most of the excerpts as speakers. Their conversations are loose, direct, and spoiler-forward, with the kind of pacing that moves from a plot beat to a joke to a serious continuity complaint without stopping to reset the room. The show is especially at home with franchise logic. Scream episodes become arguments about openings, characters, missing references, survival plausibility, and what a new generation of fans loses when earlier characters are brushed aside. That same attention carries into gateway horror, where a family-facing film can still prompt detailed talk about creepy imagery, foreshadowing, story rules, and visual style. Slice By Slice also has room for horror fandom as lived experience. Halloween plans, rainy trick-or-treating, pumpkin beer, home theater double features, and Halloween Horror Nights Orlando sit beside conventional movie review material. The result feels less like a clean critic’s desk and more like a long-running horror friendship with microphones nearby. It can be rough around the edges. Episodes mention recording problems, busy schedules, missed plans, and the effort of keeping the show moving while life gets in the way. That informality is part of the identity. The conversations still carry plenty of specific opinion, from praise for period detail and costume work to impatience with abrupt endings or character choices that do not track. Kevin Smith’s work becomes a chance to talk about youth, comedy, horror adjacency, Red State, Tusk, and the way a filmmaker’s voice can follow fans over time. Evil Dead, Renfield, Bruce Campbell events, haunted houses, slashers, vampires, and horror icons all fit under the same broad umbrella. Slice By Slice suits horror fans who like spoilers, side roads, personal context, and candid reactions more than tidy scorekeeping. It is fan criticism with a backlog, a calendar, and a lot of opinions.