PRESS PLAY
Scary True Crime. Mysteries of All Kinds. Welcome friends to a one of a kind experience, the likes of which you will never forget. And if you like us then check out our other podcast called EVERY TOWN. Because Every Town, has a dark side. https://open.spotify.com/show/4K2gvVKzxlEx636qMFSooj Hosted by: Andrew Fitzgerald 👀 Watch This Episode On Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/scarymysteries 👁 Check out our movie AN ANGRY BOY: https://www.anangryboy.com 💀 MERCH: https://scary-mysteries-merch.dashery.com 💀 Scary Mysteries SECRET VAULT: https://www.patreon.com/c/scarymysteries/collections 🎧 Our Other Podcast, Every Town: https://open.spotify.com/show/4K2gvV...
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Andrew Fitzgerald turns cold cases, disputed evidence, and strange forensic clues into clear narratives that preserve uncertainty where answers remain unsettled.
Scary Mysteries regularly builds episodes around numbered collections of cases, with Andrew Fitzgerald guiding the narrative from disappearances and disputed deaths to emergency calls and unusual forensic evidence.
A barrel witnesses say vanished and clothes that don't fit make your drowning theory sweat.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A haunted-house story deepens as family crisis, ritual, and an old curse leave the mystery unresolved.
When the Haunting Follows You Home traces a troubled house, shadow figures, and testimony that never quite resolves, it is strongest when it stays close to Bob's family story.
A wood chipper homicide and two disappearances trace the uneasy line between evidence and uncertainty.
The episode works best when it lets its most disturbing material stay precise. Its opening stretch follows the Heli Crafts case through Richard Crafts, the false travel story, forensic evidence, and wood chipper fragments, turning a grotesque crime into a question of proof.
Five cold cases build quiet tension through vanished people, burned cars, and theories that never fully settle.
Scary Mysteries follows five strange cold cases with a steady eye for disappearances that still resist a clean ending. The episode moves from Joey, Billy, and Craig, whose vanishing led to speculation about negligence or a possible construction-company cover-up involving Highway…
Five true crime cases where supernatural claims brush up against brutal violence.
Scary Mysteries shapes this single episode around five haunted true crime cases, all built on the uneasy overlap between violence and claims of supernatural influence.
A dark March 2025 roundup built around possible linked murders, a Colorado burglary mystery, and an Ohio appeal.
This March 2025 collection is strongest when it tracks how a single act of violence can widen into something harder for authorities to map. The Zizian case gives the hour its darkest throughline, moving from the Vallejo landlord attack and later death to Curtis Lind's stabbing,…
A brisk monthly roundup that keeps the dread moving and the questions open.
Scary Mysteries treats June 2025 like a grim monthly roundup, moving from the devil in the Ozarks and a prison escape to the unsolved killings in the Arizona wilderness and a crypto-fueled kidnapping case in New York.
A brisk countdown about how strange evidence can mislead, then crack a case open.
Scary Mysteries builds this episode around five odd clues and the uneasy way evidence can be useful and misleading at the same time. The DNA-transfer section lands best.
A brisk tour of five unsolved small-town murder mysteries, with a cold edge.
Scary Mysteries moves through five unsolved small-town murder mysteries with a clear, unsettling point: quiet places can hide ugly histories. It spends most of its time on the Coons family massacre and Georgia Cruz in Monteverde, Florida, where a community search, a taunting…
Outdoor mysteries, mapped with human common sense.
Georgia politics from inside the room.
True crime measured by the evidence.
Mysteries, lore, and nervous laughter.
This episode of Scary Mysteries covers five strange and scary cases from July 2025, including a teenage girl charged with double homicide, a UFO sighting in Massachusetts, the serial killer Kelly Cochran, a domestic violence murder in California, and a prophecy about alien contact disrupting a global sports event.
This episode explores five chilling cold cases, including Sherry Yerley's planned abduction tied to a psychic vision, Debbie Wolf's suspicious drowning ruled an accident, Misty Copsey's disappearance linked to serial patterns, the identification of Grateful Doe by online sleuths, and Nyleen Marshall's kidnapping with disturbing letters from her abductor.
The host presents five unsolved mysteries, including a Siberian hiking tragedy where six died gruesomely, a Pennsylvania nurse's disappearance with strange leads, two men vanishing after police encounters in Florida, a paranormal figure terrorizing Glasgow, and a controversial murder investigation in Thailand.
This episode explores five dark mysteries from Colorado, including the unsolved Bennett family murders by serial killer Alex Ewing, the crimes of FBI informant Scott Kimball, a documented haunting in Black Forest, the disappearance and murder of model Kara Nichols, and the hate crime case of Maggie Long.
This episode presents five chilling true crime stories based on real 911 calls, covering cases of domestic murder, cannibalism, family annihilation, patricide, and a mass shooting by an Uber driver.
This episode covers five chilling true crime mysteries from June 2025, including a prison escape by a former police chief, unsolved teen murders in Arizona, a cryptocurrency kidnapping in New York, a social media-related homicide in Florida, and a triple murder by a former soldier in Washington.
This episode explores five bizarre clues from real-life horror stories, including a Tokyo dismemberment with surgical precision, a DNA contamination case that wrongly accused a man, Lego evidence linking a killer's child to a murder scene, a Red Bull can revealing a hidden body in Scotland, and the first use of cat DNA to convict a murderer.
This episode narrates five twisted murder mysteries, including a staged hit-and-run in Michigan, a killer cobbler's abusive past, a stocking strangler's spree, a criminal family dynasty in Australia, and a random home invasion by a teen club.
This episode explores five unsolved small-town murder mysteries, including the Coons family massacre in Wisconsin, the Shaw Creek serial killings in South Carolina, the abduction of Georgia Cruz in Florida, the burning of Jessica Chambers in Mississippi, and the Frankfurt Slasher case in Pennsylvania.
Scary Mysteries When the Haunting Follows You Home: Skinwalkers, Doppelgängers & Shadow Beings counts down five stories about alleged hauntings that leave one house and show up in bedrooms, yards, and hallways.
Scary Mysteries packs five true crime cases into one episode, centered on Al Kite, Peli Kras, Thomas Messick, Sheila Bradford, and Michael Negrete.
Scary Mysteries' "Area 5 Strange and Haunting Cold Cases" moves through five unresolved cases in Mendocino, Hannibal, Washington, Maine, and Anaheim.
Scary Mysteries counts down five haunted true crime cases, moving from Sean Sellers in Oklahoma to Daniel Hoosen in London.
Scary Mysteries' March 2025 roundup jumps from Jeffrey Ferguson's Orange County murder case to Brenda Powell's Akron killing and Sydney Powell's overturned conviction.
The host promotes a testosterone booster sponsor and briefly mentions selling a car, setting up the show's typical true crime content.
A true crime podcast that narrates mysterious and scary crime stories, with this episode featuring a story about a poisoning.
The episode covers strange and scary mysteries from around the world, starting with the case of the Yosemite Predator, a climber who used his notoriety to lure victims.
A promo for the Mentally Stronger podcast and Easy Stories in English, followed by a teaser for a true crime story about risk and death.
This episode covers strange and scary mysteries from May 2024, starting with the tragic disappearance of three surfers in Mexico.