5 CREEPY Small Town Murder Mysteries That Remain Unsolved

·26 min·2 clips

Investigators found hundreds of adult tapes in the Coons family's decaying farmhouse, hinting at disturbing secrets.

This episode explores five unsolved small-town murder mysteries, including the Coons family massacre in Wisconsin, the Shaw Creek serial killings in South Carolina, the abduction of Georgia Cruz in Florida, the burning of Jessica Chambers in Mississippi, and the Frankfurt Slasher case in Pennsylvania. Each story delves into the dark secrets and investigative failures that left these crimes unresolved.

As heard by us

A brisk tour of five unsolved small-town murder mysteries, with a cold edge.

Scary Mysteries moves through five unsolved small-town murder mysteries with a clear, unsettling point: quiet places can hide ugly histories. It spends most of its time on the Coons family massacre and Georgia Cruz in Monteverde, Florida, where a community search, a taunting…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Five unsolved small-town murder mysteries, a calm surface, and no neat answer by the end.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Scary Mysteries