Roll for Weird is an actual play of the tabletop game Monster of the Week, told through a party that mostly adventures in Kentucky. The players make a running joke of that home turf: a character carrying only a mighty shotgun and a big knife has never needed to hide either, because in Kentucky, they reason, everybody has a shotgun on their back. Travel changes that. A stretch of the story sends the group to Niagara Falls, where concealing weapons suddenly matters and someone keeps watching the party without showing up in a photograph. At the centre of the cast is Silas Lancaster, a vampire whom the rest of the party calls Grandad. He scouts as a cloud of mist, weighs whether a bat or a large demonic mastiff would draw fewer looks, and at one point is described as sitting in Shadow's pokeball. Shadow, another party member, looks into the future with an amulet. Misty and Filbert chase down research, some of it in Silas's own library. That digging turns up the Mackey family, based in New York City, in which Charles Mackey was a werewolf and more non-humans are likely. The allies are as strange as the enemies. Samantha arrives with FBI reinforcements, and a Bigfoot named Harry brings company, at one point forming a linebacker wall so a shotgun can get within range. Against them stand demons, divine forces and a hostess whose whispers turn people on each other. The game's mechanics stay in plain view. A roll of ten lets a player choose an extra effect, spending a hold buys a flash of hidden information, and the narrator offers a time skip when the table would rather get to the meeting. Planning is its own comedy. Players debate blending in, admit they look like a Scooby Doo crew, float the idea of everyone wearing suits, and warn that without a scene jump they will end up at a Chili's. When a fight finally breaks, the references keep coming: a force beam becomes a Kamehameha, and someone calls for a spirit bomb. Each session in view opens with a group recap, sometimes improvised and sometimes read from someone's notes, which gives a returning listener a foothold. The language at the table is loose and often salty, and the violence runs to shotguns, demon crowds and wounds that a vampire cannot heal. Episode titles are phrased in the party's own voice, among them 'We Forgot Kenny Again', 'I Didn’t Want Him to Die' and 'I Don't Need a License I Have a Vampire'. Silas's reach extends beyond the campaign: he also stars in Storytime with Silas, a stand-alone horror anthology from the same Majestic Goose network.