River City Mystery - Investigating mysteries in southern Indiana, southern Illinois, and western Kentucky

This episode investigates the mysterious disappearance of 24-year-old Andy Wagner from Evansville, Indiana, exploring the circumstances and family concerns while calling for community assistance.

This episode explores reports of a phantom train heard by police officers in Swadland Coat, connecting it to local paranormal phenomena and personal anecdotes.

This episode explores the mysterious disappearance of Zac, focusing on his struggles with schizophrenia and medication, as told through personal family accounts.

This episode investigates the 2020 murder of Troy DeWayne Smith in Evansville, Indiana, initially misclassified as an overdose, with details from his brother who discovered the body and the delayed police investigation.

This episode explores the unsolved 1991 murder of retired attorney Arthur Denton, who was beaten and stabbed in his Timber Lake home while his wife Wilma was duct-taped in the basement, raising questions about whether it was a violent home invasion or a perfect murder.

This episode explores the mysterious 1982 discovery by Russell Burroughs of a hidden pit in Illinois containing carved symbols and an ancient stone face, which he believed could rewrite North American history.

This episode features an interview with Geraldine Sutton Stith, daughter of a witness to the 1955 Kelly-Hopkinsville "Little Green Men" UFO encounter, discussing her family's firsthand experience and her books on the case.

Host Matt Deig interviews Joni Mayhan, a paranormal investigator and author, about her books on hauntings in Posey County and New Harmony, Indiana, discussing the connection between history and paranormal events.

This episode explores the remarkable life of Wild Man Joe, a formerly enslaved man who survived a steamboat explosion and became a legendary figure in Evansville, Indiana.

This episode investigates the unsolved 1968 murder of housewife Doris McDonough in Evansville, Indiana, detailing the events of that day and the family's routine.

This episode examines the unsolved 2005 murder of Jean Cook, a mother of two who was shot during a robbery at an Evansville gas station where surveillance footage was unavailable.

This episode features an interview with retired police detective Joe Weigant about his paranormal investigation work, cryptid sightings, and psychic abilities in the Evansville area.

This episode features an interview with Evansville's forest witch Crystal Foltz, discussing animistic practices, sacred spaces, and the ethics of connecting with nature without possession.

This true crime podcast episode investigates the 2015 murder of 20-year-old Blake Crews in Henderson, Kentucky, focusing on his background as a musician and the circumstances surrounding his death.

This episode features a live stream discussion with Savannah about the Elizabeth Bannister case, a mysterious unsolved crime from 2000, comparing it to a twisted version of the movie Clue.

This episode investigates the unsolved Odin Fire Poltergeist case in Davies County, Indiana, exploring whether it involves cursed ground or paranormal phenomena.

This episode features an interview with Chris, the best friend of missing person Zach Carey, discussing the last known sighting and concerning text messages from May 2023.

This episode investigates mysterious complaints from guests at a motel run by Rodney and Gene in the fall of 1994, hinting at paranormal or unexplained phenomena.

This episode explores reported Bigfoot sightings and encounters in the Hoosier National Forest region of southern Indiana, based on accounts from the Bigfoot Field Researchers Organization.

This episode explores the discovery of over 700 rare U.S.

This episode investigates the disappearance of Theresa Rideout from Chandler, Indiana, a cold case with very little public information.

Host Matt Deig investigates reports of the Garvin Lake Creature, starting with a personal anecdote about attending a baseball game with a rain delay that led to a walk around the lake.