Fast riffs, bad ideas, real chemistry.
PitM runs on comic-table momentum: a guest arrives, someone notices a weird phrase, and the whole room starts chasing it. The result is loose, loud, inside-baseball comedy where card games, road stories, dating shows, viral clips, and tour plugs can all become fuel.
PRESS PLAY
PitM is a comedy panel that treats conversation like a contact sport. The setup is simple. Comedians sit down with a guest, press record, and let the room decide where the episode is going. A mic problem can become the opening bit. A birthday gift can derail the table. A card game, a binder, a pair of sneakers in Fortnite, or a strange viral clip can suddenly become the center of gravity. The show rarely lands on one topic for long, because the pleasure is in watching the group keep the ball alive. Someone throws out a line. Someone else makes it worse, stranger, or more specific. Then the whole table chases the new version until another phrase opens a side door. That rhythm gives PitM a raw, green-room feel, with less interest in polished interviewing than in comic pressure and group timing. Recent episodes show how wide that pressure can run: Brad Williams talks comedy, a YouTube special, and dwarf-joke competition; David Jolly gets folded into road stories and bleak animal humor; Jake Ricca joins a run of college, car, and street-corner anecdotes. Shawn Gardini's episode starts from names, audio checks, weekend drinking, and game-console silliness. Mike Rainey walks into a room full of odd props, unstable microphones, and escalating reactions. Alex Cureau's appearance spins through cereal mascots, celebrity scandal references, sports clips, dating shows, and White Castle embarrassment. Sarah Bell's episode leans into friendship mileage, old TV dating formats, and politics-adjacent joking that quickly turns sideways. The show is often affectionate underneath the noise. It is also blunt, juvenile, and deliberately uncomfortable. PitM's best moments come when everyone seems to be talking at once but the bit still somehow sharpens. It is for listeners who want comics being reckless together, not a tidy guest biography or a clean topical recap. The appeal is the room: fast mouths, long callbacks, bad ideas tested in public, and enough familiarity to make the chaos feel lived-in.
Made for: For comedy fans who like loose panel shows, stand-up-world banter, and jokes that escalate through interruption and callbacks. Best for listeners comfortable with abrasive, adult humor.
What sets it apart: PitM feels less like a formal podcast and more like being dropped into a comic hangout already in motion. Its identity comes from the speed of the room: props, mic issues, road stories, viral clips, and guests all becoming immediate joke material.
Comedians Nate Marshall, Andy Malafarina, and LeMaire Lee discuss.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
PitM makes comic momentum from interruptions, personal stories, guest chemistry, and riffs that grow stranger each time they change hands.
PitM turns loose conversation into a relay of interruptions, callbacks, and escalating riffs. Nate Marshall, Andy Malafarina, and LeMaire Lee move quickly from road stories and disastrous meals to old jobs, birthday gifts, online videos, games, and celebrity jokes.
A dick cake and Magic cards share a birthday; your taste for filthy affection decides the rest.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A loose comedy hangout turns Munchkin boasts, marriage math, and NBA detours into escalating riffs.
A boast about being the Munchkin champ sends this single-episode review into the kind of loose comedy sprawl PlayNext can sort well: relationship math, age jokes, NBA opinions, and the oddly sturdy punch of a kid just saying LeBron James.
Board trouble gives way to a chaotic, affectionate run through animal stories, guest history, and David Jolly's tour-date scramble.
PitM's episode with David Jolly plays like a loose room hang that keeps combusting before it can settle. It starts with the panel wrestling the board into shape, then slides through Patreon plugs, Austin-guest qualifications, and a roadside dog story that turns the whole…
Jake brings the stories, and the table happily worries every loose detail into another bit.
Jake drops into a loose panel where stray phrases become arguments, chants and running jokes. An opening freestyle swerves into mock bravado about wrongdoing, setting the pattern for the hour: commit to the bit, leave the mess intact and see who can push it further.
Cereal nostalgia, scandal jokes, basketball stories, and a White Castle offer spiral into loose, escalating comedy.
This single-episode review tracks a loose, fast-moving conversation that turns cereal-commercial nostalgia into crude riffs, celebrity scandal jokes, basketball stories, and a White Castle run-in with Joanna Angel.
A birthday gift exchange spins into Magic cards, old jokes, and a firing bit.
PitM turns a birthday gift exchange into a reliable comic engine, mostly by letting every sweet gesture curdle into a bit. Andy's Magic cards and Bone Crusher bug start as presents, then become fuel for the group's return to a penis-cake joke, the high-pitched laugh around it,…
Buffalo food, Skankfest travel, Domino's rescue, and a chess detour turn into a loose, filthy hangout.
Buffalo food gives the episode its first push: wings, beef on weck, chicken fried steak, and the kind of meals that sound as if a teenager made the menu after a dare.
Sarah joins an affectionate mess of road stories, dating-show memories and arguments nobody plans to settle.
After a month apart, the reunion quickly turns into a comic audit of friendship: road-trip rankings, hours spent together in cars, and the precise meaning of affection delivered as an insult. Sarah slips easily into the group's rhythm.
Sharp Black pop culture commentary with gossip, jokes, and blunt advice.
Awards season, celebrity memoirs, and new music picked apart with host Louis Fertel and guests.
Comedian Chris Gethard takes one anonymous call a week and can't hang up first.
Isa Calderón and Lucía Lijtmaer riff on feminism and TV history from Spanish stages.
Graham Clark and Dave Shumka turn one small topic into a full episode of tangents.
A chaotic podcast intro where hosts struggle with technical issues and joke about Hunter Biden before starting the show.
Comedians discuss Lamar's podcasting habits and a woman named Molly with large breasts.
Tyler Langois shares a bizarre story about being molested while cutting in line.
The hosts discuss their exhausting experience at South by Southwest, interrupted by ads for Chevy, Nordstrom, and LinkedIn.
The hosts of Paintings in the Mouth introduce a new segment 'Babe of the Week' after reading sponsor ads.
Comedians Nate Marshall, Andy Malafarina, LeMaire Lee, and guest Sarah Bell record episode 249 of PitM in a casual, banter-filled session.
Comedians LeMaire Lee, Nate Marshall, and Andy Malafarina are joined by guest Chris Faga for a freewheeling holiday episode.
Comedians banter about a card game called Munchkin and joke about offensive slurs.
The hosts of Panties in the Mouth introduce guest David Jolly and share a humorous anecdote about a friend whispering the n-word at a festival.
Jake Ricca joins the Paintings in Mouth podcast for a chaotic freestyle session and banter.
A casual conversation among podcast hosts about potential show ideas, Fortnite sneakers, and audio adjustments.
Mike Rainey joins the hosts to share a story about a shocking microphone incident during a college band performance at a Red Bull event in Easton.
Alex Cureau talks about moving from Boston back toward New York, but the strongest local color comes from New Orleans, where he says the city feels like Vegas and "very European." The hosts keep circling comedy life on the road, including a nine-week driving tour, Boston, Buffalo, and why Austin still feels workable after New York.
Crowd work is framed as a split job when the group says, "the crowd does 60% of the job."