Catholic arguments with pint-table warmth.
Pints With Aquinas brings Catholic teaching into roomy, conversational episodes where arguments about atheism, the Resurrection, fasting, discernment, and modern unbelief get tested out loud. It mixes debate, spiritual advice, guest interviews, audience calls, and enough banter to keep doctrine from feeling sealed behind glass.
PRESS PLAY
Pints With Aquinas is a long-form Catholic conversation show with a taste for direct questions and patient answers. It is not afraid of argument. Recent episodes press into atheism, the Resurrection, Mormonism, Lenten fasting, vocational discernment, enchantment, and the ordinary difficulty of living Christian commitments. The show often starts with a challenge that sounds simple. Then it slows down. A phrase like “extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence” becomes a full discussion about probability, theism, history, and what kind of evidence actually matters. A claim about the Resurrection becomes a conversation about witnesses, alternative explanations, Roman guards, martyrdom, and whether belief can be reasonable on historical grounds. The apologetics episodes are energetic and sometimes combative in framing, but the actual appeal is usually careful reasoning mixed with informal back-and-forth. There is also a pastoral side. In episodes about discernment and marriage, the show turns from big claims to the more intimate work of surrender, prayer, woundedness, family, friendship, and Christian community. Lent is treated as practical formation, not just seasonal self-improvement. Fasting, Aquinas, and viewer comments all become ways of asking what discipline is for. The interview rhythm matters. Guests such as Trent Horn, Dr. Trent Dougherty, Joe Heschmeyer, Sr. Mary Rachel Capets, Dr. Martin Shaw, and Brian Holdsworth bring the show into debate, philosophy, spirituality, story, and practical counsel. The surrounding style is loose and familiar, with jokes, drink-table warmth, and occasional audience voicemails or comments breaking into the flow. It can wander, but usually with purpose. A story about modern people losing a sense of quest can lead toward enchantment. A question about a coming marriage can lead toward the limits of self-improvement. A skeptical objection can lead toward a larger claim about God, reason, and trust. Pints With Aquinas suits listeners who want Catholic teaching to sound lived-in: serious about doctrine, comfortable with debate, and willing to move from banter to conviction without changing rooms.
Made for: For Catholics, Christians, and spiritually curious listeners who like long conversations about faith, reason, prayer, and moral life. It especially fits people who want apologetics and pastoral counsel in an informal, talk-it-through style.
What sets it apart: The show combines Catholic intellectual argument with a relaxed conversational rhythm, moving easily from Aquinas, fasting, and historical evidence to TikToks, voicemails, jokes, and personal stories. It feels less like a polished lecture series than a sustained attempt to reason faithfully in public.
Long form discussions, debates, and teachings on the Catholic faith.Join our Locals community: https://mattfradd.locals.com/support
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Matt Fradd makes Catholic reasoning approachable by pairing serious apologetics with candid conversations about prayer, vocation, marriage, fasting, and mystery.
Pints With Aquinas gives Matt Fradd room to test Catholic belief through argument, conversation, and practical counsel. Discussions with Trent Horn and Dr.
Leprechauns enter the God debate; your objections get more room than a punchline.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A Catholic reply to atheist analogies, with enough self-critique to keep it honest.
Pints With Aquinas takes up a familiar atheist challenge and keeps the focus on a basic question: what kind of evidence would make belief rational if God were compared to leprechauns and fairies?
An Easter apologetic weighs the empty tomb against guards, grave robbers, and the limits of knowingly false testimony.
Pints With Aquinas frames its Easter special around the resurrection as a historical question, weighing the empty tomb, the guards, and the conduct of those nearest to the claim. The host and philosopher Dr. Trent Doherty move from a light opening about martinis and Dr.
A practical, prayerful look at vocation, marriage, and the support that helps both endure.
The episode turns toward practical discernment, with Sister Mary Rachel and the host tracing vocation, marriage, and the habits that shape both.
Modern distraction, lost rites of passage, and a silent star become a meditation on mystery.
The episode frames modern life as a condition of being constantly worked on by stories. Martin Shaw begins with the narratives people take in through their phones, describing how they can pull people into trance-like states from the moment they wake and quietly suggest they are…
A brisk Catholic case on atheism, explanation, and how much certainty belief needs.
This PlayNext episode tests atheism through two linked questions: what counts as an explanation, and when belief is warranted. The host and Trent Horn begin with familiar comparisons to fairies, leprechauns, and unicorns, then tighten the distinction.
Two Bible translators unpack Scripture's hardest passages, from Revelation's 666 to the Witch of Endor.
Live sermons with Easter-shaped urgency.
Matt Fradd hosts Last Call, exploring St.
This episode features host Matt Fradd sharing his personal journey to Christian faith and previewing an interview with Dr.
Matt Fradd hosts Trent Horn on 'Pints With Aquinas' to critique atheist arguments from social media clips.
Gabriel Castillo defines the Rosary as meditation on Jesus Christ’s life, with the Hail Mary serving as a repeated prayer.
Pints With Aquinas examines sedevacantism through a discussion with Dr.
Trent Horn and Matt open with a blunt atheist comparison.
["Pints With Aquinas uses a Holy Thursday conversation with Dr.
The host celebrates the 10th anniversary of Pints with Aquinas by playing and responding to listener voicemails, reflecting on the podcast's humble beginnings and growth in the Catholic media landscape.
This episode critiques Mormonism by examining Joseph Smith's polygamy and comparing it to biblical prophets like Jacob and David to argue against his prophetic authority.
This one starts with vocation and stays grounded in the practical details.
The conversation opens with a question about the story modernity tells itself.
This episode explores St.
Matt Fradd announces a new show called Last Call, which will feature more laid-back, shorter episodes with guests, starting with an episode reviewing past sets with Father Gregory Pine.
This episode features an interview with Sister Mary Rachel, O.P., discussing the purpose of female religious sisters, the importance of prayer and discernment in vocation, and insights into convent life in Nashville.
The host announces a major life change involving relocating to Croatia to teach at a Catholic institute after a trip to Austria where he wrote books and received an invitation from a Greek Catholic bishop.