Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Weird history, loose nerves, sharp banter.

The gist

Phone It In is a SoBros Network show where Stoney Keeley and Rooster talk through oddball history, creepy cases, disasters, conspiracies, and internet theories. The appeal is the collision between researched weirdness and digressive banter that can veer from Spring-heeled Jack to molasses plumbing without losing the thread.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast

Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast sits in the space where creepy folklore, disasters, internet paranoia, and historical oddities all feel like part of the same conversation. The show comes from SoBros Network and carries a loose, self-aware energy from the opening minutes. Stoney Keeley identifies himself as the host and EIC at SoBros Network. Rooster is introduced as the cryptid queen of SoBros Network, and her presence gives the show much of its off-kilter texture. The subjects are broad but recognizably strange. Spring-heeled Jack, the Enfield Poltergeist, Rendlesham Forest, Lake Nyos, the Great Molasses Flood, Dead Internet Theory, creepy Reddit stories, and Titanic conspiracy claims all appear in the recent run. That range tells a reader what the show values: the old story that refuses to die, the disaster that sounds impossible, and the modern theory that makes ordinary online life feel suspect. The episodes are conversational rather than sealed-off presentations. Stoney Keeley tends to lay out the case, then the exchange opens into questions, jokes, objections, side trails, and half-serious attempts to make sense of the material. The show is comfortable with uncertainty. A strange story might become a conversation about memory, rumor, fear, and whether a person could exploit a legend. A conspiracy theory can be entertained long enough to test its logic, then punctured when the pieces do not line up. A disaster can be treated with genuine fascination while still leaving room for absurd detours. The pacing is casual and sometimes chaotic. That is not a flaw in the product so much as the product itself. Phone It In does not sand down the human parts of talking about weird history: fatigue, tangents, bad jokes, live comments, misread names, and sudden horror-movie opinions stay in the room. The result is less like an academic tour and more like two people following a strange file until it either makes sense or gets funnier. It can be blunt. It can be morbid. It is also curious, skeptical when needed, and unusually good at letting the ridiculous and the unsettling sit side by side. For PlayNext discovery, the show is a strong fit for listeners who want creepy and historical subjects without a solemn museum voice. It gives the strange story, then lets the conversation breathe around it.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants creepy history, disasters, folklore, and conspiracy talk in a casual conversational style. Best for someone comfortable with irreverent humor around strange or unsettling subjects.

What sets it apart: Phone It In stands apart by letting the research share space with visible uncertainty, jokes, side tangents, and real-time reactions. The show’s odd-history lane feels less scripted than many creepy or history programs, while still returning to the facts, doubts, and legends at the center of each topic.

In their own words

Stoney Keeley and Rooster dive into history, lifestyle, current events, a whole host of various topics, and honestly maybe a combination of all of the above on Phone It In, brought to you by SoBros Network.

Why you'd press play

The Enfield Poltergeist comes with ghost-lawyer worries, if your spooky history needs a little heckling.

Press play if you want

  • a paranormal story with room for doubt and a joke about being sued by ghosts
  • Stoney and Rooster to turn a teleporting warship into a debate about getting to the grocery store
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
weird historycreepy casescryptids and folklorehistoric disastersinternet theoriesconspiracy claimscreepy Reddit storieshorror movies

Talks about

Best episodes of Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Ep. 88: Spring-heeled JackNov 12, 2025

Spring-Heeled Jack stays unsettling because memory, rumor, and illusion all remain in play.

Spring-Heeled Jack comes through as a story built around fear, memory, and the unstable life of rumor. The attack account is vivid, with red eyes, fire-breathing, and claws tearing at a girl's neck and arms before her sister intervenes, but Stoney Keeley and Rooster keep the…

Ep. 87: Creepy Reddit Stories, Pt. 6Oct 28, 2025

A sixth Halloween round of allegedly true Reddit scares, carried by doppelganger unease and easygoing host banter.

Phone It In's annual Halloween episode turns creepy Reddit stories into a familiar ritual, with Stoney Keeley and Rooster back for a sixth year of allegedly true scares.

Ep. 86: Dead Internet TheoryOct 22, 2025

A loose, funny conversation about bots, fake popularity, and the influence that comes from controlling the trend.

Dead Internet Theory comes across as a live question about manufactured attention and the way it can move real people. Stoney Keeley and Rooster work through bot activity, fake likes, and the uneasy idea that political ads can seem more persuasive when popularity is inflated,…

Ep. 85: The Enfield PoltergeistSep 10, 2025

A tipsy, skeptical Enfield episode where ghost lore, the Warrens, and The Conjuring 2 all crowd the room.

The Enfield Poltergeist plays as an early spooky-season look at how a haunting story starts to build its own weather. Stoney Keeley and Rooster track the case into its investigation, with Morris Gross of the SPR, reports of levitating children and moving furniture, and the…

Ep. 84: Did JP Morgan Sink the Titanic?Aug 19, 2025

A Titanic conspiracy is weighed against evidence, logistics, and one enormous gamble.

Phone It In takes on the claim that J.P. Morgan's alleged role in the Titanic disaster points to a conspiracy with a neat villain and a messy path to tragedy.

Podcasts like Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    Ep. 88: Spring-heeled Jack

    Hidden gem

    Phone It In episode 88 treats Spring-Heeled Jack as a Victorian folklore figure first reported in 1837 and later sighted across London, Liverpool, Scotland, and the Black Country.

    Nov 12, 2025·1h 11m·4 clips
  2. 2

    Ep. 87: Creepy Reddit Stories, Pt. 6

    Hidden gem

    ["Phone It In Ep.

    Oct 28, 2025·1h 8m·5 clips
  3. 3

    Ep. 86: Dead Internet Theory

    Hidden gem

    Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast spends this episode on dead internet theory, with Stoney Keeley and Rooster tying the idea to bot activity, algorithmic curation, and the feeling that the web is less human than it used to be.

    Oct 22, 2025·1h 5m·5 clips
  4. 4

    Ep. 85: The Enfield Poltergeist

    Hidden gem

    Phone It In Episode 85 starts with Stoney Keeley and Rooster joking about Truly, White Claw, Publix, and Aldi German Week before Rooster connects the topic to The Conjuring 2.

    Sep 10, 2025·1h 22m·5 clips
  5. 5

    Ep. 84: Did JP Morgan Sink the Titanic?

    Hidden gem

    Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast Episode 84 examines the claim that J.P.

    Aug 19, 2025·1h·4 clips
  6. 6

    Ep. 83: The Lake Nyos Disaster

    Hidden gem

    ["Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast episode 83 covers the 1986 Lake Nyos disaster in northwestern Cameroon, where a limnic eruption killed 1,746 people and 3,500 livestock.", "Big Natural Stoney Keeley and Rooster frame the story with their SoBros Network banter, and Rooster says she first saw Lake Nyos on TikTok.", "They explain that a limnic eruption is dissolved carbon dioxide suddenly erupting from lake water, forming an invisible gas cloud that can descend into valleys.", "The episode also covers Joseph Nickwine's survivor account, the 82-foot wave and 330-foot water column, and the degassing pipes installed at Lake Nyos in 2001 and 2011."]

    Jul 15, 2025·1h 13m·5 clips
  7. 7

    Ep. 82: The Rendlesham Forest Incident

    Hidden gem

    Episode 82 of Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast focuses on the December 1980 Rendlesham Forest incident near RAF Woodbridge in Suffolk, England.

    Jun 17, 2025·1h·4 clips
  8. 8

    Ep. 81: The Great Molasses Flood

    Hidden gem

    Phone It In: A Weird History Podcast episode 81 covers the 1919 Great Molasses Flood in Boston, where a 50-foot storage tank held 2.3 million gallons and failed at 12:30 p.m.

    Jun 3, 2025·1h 6m·4 clips
  9. 9

    Ep. 80: The Philadelphia Experiment

    Phone It In episode 80 on SoBros Network centers on the Philadelphia Experiment, with Stoney Keeley and Rooster reading a passage that claims the U.S.

    May 12, 2025·1h 15m·5 clips
  10. 10

    Ep. 79: Agatha Christie

    Hidden gem

    Phone It In spends this episode on Agatha Christie, whom Rooster calls the queen of mystery after a live-video glitch and some opening banter on SoBros Network.

    Apr 22, 2025·1h 10m·4 clips
  11. 11

    Ep. 78: The Enfield Monster

    Apr 1, 2025·1h 7m
  12. 12

    Ep. 77: Tunnels in New York City

    Mar 11, 2025·58m
  13. 13

    Ep. 76: Octopuses

    Feb 25, 2025·59m
  14. 14

    Ep. 75: Remote Viewing

    Feb 11, 2025·57m
  15. 15

    Ep. 74: Shackleton's Trans-Antarctic Expedition

    Jan 14, 2025·1h 2m
  16. 16

    Ep. 73: The Lost Colony of Roanoke

    Dec 17, 2024·49m
  17. 17

    Ep. 71: Creepy Reddit Stories, Pt. 5

    Oct 29, 2024·53m
  18. 18

    Ep. 70: Edgar Allan Poe

    Oct 23, 2024·59m
  19. 19

    Ep. 69: Werewolves

    Oct 8, 2024·1h 4m
  20. 20

    Ep. 68: Oak Island Money Pit

    Sep 24, 2024·59m
  21. 21

    Ep. 67: Ancient Aliens

    Sep 10, 2024·1h 8m
  22. 22

    Ep. 66: Cruise Ship Deaths

    Aug 28, 2024·56m
  23. 23

    Ep. 65: The Simulation

    Aug 14, 2024·1h 3m
  24. 24

    Ep. 64: Alchemy

    Jul 31, 2024·1h 9m
  25. 25

    Ep. 63: Kentucky Meat Shower

    Stoney Keeley and Rooster discuss the bizarre historical event known as the Kentucky meat shower.

    Jul 17, 2024·1h 3m
  26. 26

    Ep. 62: The Biltmore Estate

    Jun 22, 2024·1h 18m
  27. 27

    Ep. 61: Rasputin

    Jun 5, 2024·1h 44m
  28. 28

    Ep. 60: Missing 411

    May 22, 2024·1h 25m
  29. 29

    Ep. 59: The Loveland Frogman

    May 1, 2024·1h 1m
  30. 30

    Ep. 58: Chuck E. Cheese

    Apr 18, 2024·55m
  31. 31

    Ep. 57: Qin Shi Huang Mausoleum

    Apr 3, 2024·1h 5m
  32. 32

    Ep. 56: The Ghost Club

    Mar 20, 2024·1h 2m
  33. 33

    Ep. 55: Mysterious Booms of Morristown

    Feb 14, 2024·1h 4m
  34. 34

    Ep. 54: The Hysteria Over Elvis Presley

    Jan 17, 2024·1h 10m
  35. 35

    Ep. 53: The Yeti

    Dec 13, 2023·1h 9m
  36. 36

    Ep. 52: A History of Cannibalism

    Nov 16, 2023·1h
  37. 37

    Ep. 51: Creepy Reddit Stories, Vol. 4

    Oct 23, 2023·1h 3m
  38. 38

    Ep. 50: Men In Black

    The hosts discuss a bizarre historical cult involving drugs, blending weird history with current events and lifestyle topics.

    Oct 11, 2023·58m
  39. 39

    Ep. 49: Phantom Horses

    Sep 12, 2023·58m
  40. 40

    Ep. 48: The History of the English Language

    Stoney and Rooster discuss the history of the English language in this episode of their podcast.

    Aug 30, 2023·52m
  41. 41

    Ep. 47: Capitalism

    Aug 15, 2023·1h 48m
  42. 42

    Ep. 46: Modern Credible UFO Stories

    Jul 19, 2023·1h 8m
  43. 43

    Ep. 45: Zé Arigó

    Jun 5, 2023·1h 2m
  44. 44

    Ep. 44: The Appalachian Mountains

    Apr 26, 2023·54m
  45. 45

    Ep. 43: The Daedalus Sea Serpent

    Two hosts discuss the Daedalus Sea Serpent, a historical cryptozoological legend, in a casual, humorous style.

    Mar 28, 2023·1h 1m
  46. 46

    Ep. 42: Dodge City, Kansas

    Mar 10, 2023·48m
  47. 47

    Ep. 41: Dark Matter

    Jan 19, 2023·1h 11m
  48. 48

    Ep. 40: Mary Shelley

    Dec 9, 2022·1h 1m
  49. 49

    Ep. 39: Sinkholes

    Nov 4, 2022·45m
  50. 50

    Ep. 38: Creepy Reddit Stories, Pt. 3

    Oct 19, 2022·46m