True crime with blunt, conversational shock.
Mystery History Podcast covers murders, notorious trials, survival stories, and strange events through a conversational true-crime lens. Allison and Rachel move between case detail, disbelief, side comments, and source notes without sanding off the grimness.
PRESS PLAY
Mystery History Podcast is a conversational true-crime show led in the excerpts by Allison and Rachel. Its subject matter ranges from famous courtroom spectacles to cases that feel like they should be better known. The OJ Simpson episodes place the show inside a murder trial and the public spectacle around it. Julie Jensen's murder brings in domestic suspicion, a letter written before death, admissibility fights, and the long legal path that followed. Shawn Grate's case turns on charm, violence against women, and the speakers' disbelief at how warning signs were missed or minimized. Dennis Nilsen shifts the setting to pubs, invited guests, concealed bodies, and the horrifying ordinariness of someone living over evidence. Lake Mead lets the show stretch into unresolved dread, with receding water, found remains, and the uneasy thought of what a lake can hide. Mary Vincent's story is handled as an account of extreme violence and survival, with the speakers returning to the sheer force of her endurance. Marvin's bulldozer rampage adds a different kind of true-crime spectacle: grievance, preparation, armor, cameras, and destruction. The show is not polished into courtroom distance. It reacts. The speakers interrupt themselves, ask practical questions, make side remarks, and cite sources at the end. Episodes often open with personal updates, schedule notes, Patreon mentions, or acknowledgments of Jamie's help with topics and notes. That looseness is part of the identity. It makes the darkest stories feel as if they are being worked through aloud, with shock and skepticism still intact. The humor is casual and sometimes sharp, but the cases remain the center. Listeners get facts, chronology, and context without losing the spontaneous feel of two people trying to understand disturbing behavior. Mystery History Podcast fits true-crime fans who want grim stories told plainly, with human reactions left in the room. It is especially suited to listeners who like a mix of infamous cases, discoveries, survival stories, murder trials, and odd destructive events.
Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer informal case storytelling, visible reactions, and a mix of infamous trials, disturbing murders, survival accounts, and strange events.
What sets it apart: The show keeps the research trail and the speakers' real-time reactions close together, so cases feel processed aloud rather than packaged into a detached documentary voice.
We are the Mystery History Podcast. We discuss conspiracy theories, true crime, the supernatural and everything in between, with our subtle attempts at humor along the way.
Grisly case notes meet Allison and Rachel's wait-what reactions, so you never feel lectured at.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Lake Mead's receding water reveals a grim shoreline mystery, handled with curiosity, unease, and a conversational sense of dread.
Lake Mead's falling water leaves the shoreline feeling like a grim record, as Allison and Rachel talk through bodies surfacing in quick succession and the uneasy question of how many may still be hidden.
A harrowing Mary Vincent episode shaped by stark detail and the hosts' stunned disbelief.
Episode 173 follows the Mary Vincent case through its most harrowing stretch, focusing on her survival after a roadside attack leaves her naked, beaten, bloody, and presumed dead.
True crime through the courtroom lens.
Missing-person cases kept in the light.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
Mystery History Podcast's Episode 176 traces Marvin Heemeyer's conflict over a two-acre Colorado property bought for $42,000, including sewage disputes and opposition to the Docheff family's concrete plant.
Shawn Grate's case traces assaults, exploitation, and multiple women's killings in Ohio.
Mystery History Podcast episode 174 traces the deaths at Lake Mead, the reservoir behind Hoover Dam about 30 miles east of Las Vegas.
Mystery History Podcast episode 173 follows Mary Vincent McGriff, a 15-year-old dancer who had already performed in Las Vegas, Hawaii, and Australia before leaving home during her parents’ divorce.
Mystery History Podcast's Episode 171 follows Dennis Nilsen from his 1945 birth in Fraserburgh, Scotland, through military service, relationships, and employment as a civil servant.
Mystery History Podcast’s Episode 170 examines Julie Jensen’s 1998 death in Pleasant Prairie, Wisconsin, after Julie left neighbors a letter identifying Mark Jensen as her first suspect.
During the 1946 Moonlight Murders, Texarkana teenagers armed themselves and waited in parked cars until mistaken-identity encounters prompted police to intervene.
Allison and Rachel recount how 24-year-old Sydney Loof met Bailey Boswell on Tinder in November 2017 and vanished after their second date.
The hosts recap the OJ Simpson murder trial and announce a giveaway after reaching 100,000 downloads.
The hosts discuss the OJ Simpson murder trial, sharing personal memories and opinions on his guilt.
The hosts introduce an episode about pyramid and Ponzi schemes, discussing their differences and relation to multi-level marketing.
The hosts discuss the Saint Valentine's Day Massacre with their signature blend of humor and mystery.
The hosts discuss the disappearance of Kara Nichols, including recent updates from 2022, with their signature humor.
The hosts discuss the missing person case of Fawn Marie Mountain, blending true crime with humor and audience engagement.
The hosts recap the previous episode and discuss the Craigslist killer Richard Beasley case.
The hosts introduce a two-part episode on the Craigslist Killer Richard Beasley, discussing the case and its differences from another Craigslist killer.