Mysterious Headlines

150 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Missing-person cases kept in the light.

The gist

Mysterious Headlines is a true-crime show centered on missing people and cases where families still lack answers. Recent episodes trace the Out of the Dark series through missing children, missing adults, Indigenous cases, domestic violence, and ways the public can help responsibly.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Mysterious Headlines

Mysterious Headlines is a true-crime show focused on missing people and cases where answers are still missing. It is direct and earnest. The recent Out of the Dark series works like an extended public-awareness campaign, moving from missing children to missing adults, Indigenous missing-person cases, domestic violence, and concrete ways people can help. The show repeatedly returns to one moral point: families are living without closure. Episodes often begin with a clear topic, then build through statistics, named cases, and questions about what might have happened. The pacing is plainspoken rather than theatrical. The Gabby Petito case is used not only as a case narrative, but as an example of how appearance, social media, travel, public recognition, and attention can shape the response around a disappearance. That attention becomes a comparison point for cases that do not receive the same coverage. Episodes on missing people from Indian reservations discuss remoteness, lack of visibility, and the way public pressure can affect where resources go. The show also covers domestic violence as a factor in missing-adult cases, including the fear and betrayal that can sit behind harm from someone trusted. It does not treat missing adults as simple mysteries. It separates possibilities such as voluntary disappearance, outdoor accidents, weather exposure, and cases where families truly do not know what happened. Specific stories, including Michael Vaughn and Chad Polanski, are used to keep the discussion grounded. Mysterious Headlines can be heavy, especially when children, abduction, homicide, and family grief are central to an episode. It is not sensational in the excerpts provided. Its energy comes from insistence: keep looking, keep sharing, keep asking why some stories get attention while others do not. The show suits listeners who want true crime with an advocacy function, where the purpose is visibility as much as narrative.

Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer sober coverage of missing-person cases, public awareness, and unanswered questions. It especially suits people interested in how media attention, family advocacy, and local action affect unresolved cases.

What sets it apart: Mysterious Headlines stands apart by pairing case discussion with practical visibility work, including how to share stories, contact media, support families, and think critically about uneven coverage.

In their own words

A podcast where I dive beyond the headline to uncover the mystery. Focused on missing person cases and cases where victims still deserve justice!

Why you'd press play

Lori asks the witnesses herself; you get the testimony, evidence, and the host's read on it.

Press play if you want

  • courtroom recaps that follow each witness in order, right down to jury questions
  • probable-cause affidavits read closely enough that discarded phones and cleaned trucks do not fade into background noise
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
missing-person casesmissing childrenmissing adultsIndigenous missing-person casesdomestic violence and disappearancesmedia attention and public pressurefamily closureresponsible public help

Talks about

Best episodes of Mysterious Headlines

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Out of the Dark Series- Episode 6 New Arrest in Michael Vaughan CaseFeb 5, 2026

A paperwork-heavy update that keeps the Michael Vaughn case tied to timing, phone data, and vehicle details.

Mysterious Headlines treats this chapter of the Michael Vaughn case like a methodical police report, centering the October 2025 arrest of Stacey Wandra and the probable cause affidavit that names first degree murder, second degree kidnapping, and destruction or concealment of…

Day 5 of Lori Vallow Arizona TrialApr 15, 2025

A clear, witness-led account of day five in Lori Vallow's Arizona trial.

Day five of Lori Vallow's Maricopa County trial is covered in a steady, witness-by-witness way, moving from Charles Vallow's gunshot wounds to a Social Security agent's account of a life insurance beneficiary call and then to firearms testing.

Podcasts like Mysterious Headlines

Episodes

  1. 1

    Day 5 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    ·25m
  2. 2

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 15 What you can do to help Missing People

    ·5m
  3. 3

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 14 Why Missing Person Cases Matter

    ·5m
  4. 4

    New Body Cam Footage in Michael Vaughan Case

    ·1h 5m
  5. 5

    Lori Vallow Daybell’s Latest Hearing

    ·18m
  6. 6

    Shari Franke’s New Book

    ·5m
  7. 7

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 11 Domestic Violence & It’s Relation to Missing Person Cases

    ·6m
  8. 8

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 9 Gabby Petito Case

    ·13m
  9. 9

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 9 Missing Adult Cases

    ·11m
  10. 10

    Lori Vallow Representing Herself in AZ Trial

    ·8m
  11. 11

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 13 Why Indigenous Missing Persons Cases Don’t Get as much Attention

    ·7m
  12. 12

    Finally Justice For Amanda Todd

    ·18m
  13. 13

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 12 Missing Person Cases on Indian Reservations

    ·4m
  14. 14

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 8 Deep Dive into Michael Vaughan Case

    ·11m
  15. 15

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 7 Deep Dive into Sarah, Stacey, Brandon and Adrien

    ·12m
  16. 16

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 6 New Arrest in Michael Vaughan Case

    ·28m
  17. 17

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 5 Michael Vaughan- Most Unique Missing Child Case

    ·9m
  18. 18

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 4: Amber Alerts

    ·6m
  19. 19

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 3: Child Abductions by Strangers

    ·5m
  20. 20

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 2: Missing Children Cases

    ·8m
  21. 21

    Out of The Dark Series Episode 1: Introduction

    ·2m
  22. 22

    4 Year Anniversary of the Disappearance of Michael Vaughan

    ·51m
  23. 23

    Barry Morphew Indicted Again in the Case of Suzanne Morphew

    ·7m
  24. 24

    88 Children Removed From An Iowa Bible Camp-Is There A Connection To A Cult?

    ·8m
  25. 25

    Verdict Reached in Lori Vallow’s 2nd Arizona Trial Against Brandon Beudroux

    ·5m
  26. 26

    State and Defense Rest in Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial Against Brandon Beudroux

    ·9m
  27. 27

    Day 4 of Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial Against Brandon Beudroux

    ·12m
  28. 28

    Day 1 of Lori’s Arizona Trial Against Brandon Boudreaux

    ·17m
  29. 29

    Crystal Sorey Getting $2.25 million from New Hampshire #HarmonyMontgomery

    ·7m
  30. 30

    Lori Vallow’s 2nd Arizona Trial Postponed

    ·6m
  31. 31

    Lori’s Heated Pre-Trial Hearing

    ·16m
  32. 32

    Lori Vallow Requesting a Re-trial in her Arizona Case

    ·13m
  33. 33

    Verdict Reached in Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial

    ·4m
  34. 34

    Closing Arguments in Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    ·17m
  35. 35

    Day 7 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial | State Rests Their Case & Will Lori Testify?

    ·17m
  36. 36

    Day 6 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    ·14m
  37. 37

    Day 18 0f #ChadDaybell Trial | Zulema Testifies

    ·47m
  38. 38

    Day 4 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    ·30m
  39. 39

    Day 3 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    ·23m
  40. 40

    Day 2 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    ·19m
  41. 41

    Day 1 of Lori Vallow Trial in Arizona

    ·18m
  42. 42

    Jury Seated in Lori Vallow Daybell Arizona Trial

    ·9m
  43. 43

    Lori Vallow Daybell Motions and Fillings A Week Out From Trial

    ·14m
  44. 44

    Lori Vallow Daybell 2nd Pre-Trial Hearing

    ·14m
  45. 45

    Lori Vallow Trial Hearing & Dateline Interview

    ·15m
  46. 46

    Update on Missing 2 Yr Dane Paulson

    ·4m
  47. 47

    Missing 2 Yr Old Dane Paulsen

    ·20m
  48. 48

    DCYF Wants Case Dismissed #HarmonyMontgomery

    ·8m
  49. 49

    New Gabby Petito Documentary

    ·8m
  50. 50

    Unsolved Murder of Maggie Long

    ·7m
  51. 51

    Lori Vallow Wants Cameras Banned From Court

    ·7m
  52. 52

    Missing Skeleton Brothers

    ·10m
  53. 53

    Lori Vallow Wants Case Dismissed

    ·7m
  54. 54

    Mom Arrested for 10 Yr Old Out Walking Alone

    ·12m
  55. 55

    Chad Daybell’s Property Turned into a Park?

    ·14m
  56. 56

    3 Yr Anniversary of the Disapperance of Michael Vaughan

    ·20m
  57. 57

    Update in #MiyaTucker Case Miya Has Been Found

    ·9m
  58. 58

    2 More People Arrested in #MiyaTucker Case

    ·6m
  59. 59

    366 Pages Released by the FBI in the #GabbyPetito Case

    ·32m
  60. 60

    Missing 8 Month Old Miya Tucker

    ·7m
  61. 61

    Updates in #GabbyPetito Case | Gabby’s Mother Forgives Brian & Brian’s Notebook

    ·10m
  62. 62

    Chad Sentenced to Death Penalty #ChadDaybellTrial

    ·14m
  63. 63

    Sentencing Day in #ChadDaybell Case | Gut Wrenching Victim Impact Statements

    ·1h 47m
  64. 64

    GUILTY VERDICT FOR #CHADDAYBELL

    ·2m
  65. 65

    Are Charges Coming In Michael Vaughan’s Case?

    ·18m
  66. 66

    Should Family YouTube Vlogging be Regulated? | Shari Franke Speaking with Utah Lawmakers

    ·27m
  67. 67

    Day 31 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Closing Arguments & Officially on Jury Watch

    ·23m
  68. 68

    Happy Birthday JJ!

    ·6m
  69. 69

    Day 30 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Heading to Closing Arguments

    ·24m
  70. 70

    Day 29 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Bombshell Witness Testifies About Tammy’s Passing

    ·29m
  71. 71

    Day 28 of #ChadDaybell Trial | 2 Expert Witnesses for Defense

    ·19m
  72. 72

    Day 27 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Defense Continues Their Case

    ·16m
  73. 73

    Day 26 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Chad’s Kids Testify

    ·44m
  74. 74

    Day 25 of #ChadDaybell Trial | State Rests Their Case and Bombshell Motion & Issue

    ·27m
  75. 75

    Day 24 of #Chad Daybell Trial | Jail Call, Tammy’s Email & 1 More Witness for the State

    ·29m
  76. 76

    Day 23 of #ChadDaybell

    ·16m
  77. 77

    Day 22 of #ChadDaybell Trial | 7 Witnesses Take the Stand

    ·13m
  78. 78

    Day 21 of #ChadDaybell | A Simple Situation & Tammy’s Sister Testifies

    ·24m
  79. 79

    Day 20 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Tammy in ‘best shape of her life’ Prior to Passing

    ·30m
  80. 80

    Justice for Harmony Montgomery | Adam Montgomery Sentencing

    ·37m
  81. 81

    Day 19 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Detectives Testify

    ·28m
  82. 82

    Day 17 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Melanie and Ian Palowski Take the Stand

    ·37m
  83. 83

    Happy Birthday Tammy Daybell

    ·4m
  84. 84

    Day 16 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Remembering Tylee

    ·15m
  85. 85

    Day 15 #ChadDaybell Trial | His Mom Testifies Against Him

    ·46m
  86. 86

    Day 14 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Medical Examiner on the Stand

    ·45m
  87. 87

    Day 13 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Differing stories of Tammy’s Death

    ·25m
  88. 88

    BREAKING INFO in #SuzanneMorphew Case

    ·7m
  89. 89

    Day 12 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Hostile Witness on Stand?

    ·26m
  90. 90

    Day 11 of #ChadDaybell Trial

    ·23m
  91. 91

    Day 10 of #ChadDaybell Trial |Coroner Testifies

    ·33m
  92. 92

    Day 9 of #ChadDaybell Trial

    ·25m
  93. 93

    Day 8 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Colby Ryan Takes The Stand

    ·31m
  94. 94

    Day 7 of #ChadDaybell Trial | Prior Makes a Crazy Insinuation about Melanie Gibb

    ·27m
  95. 95

    Day 6 #ChadDaybell Trial Melanie Gibb on Stand

    ·1h 10m
  96. 96

    Day 5 of #ChadDaybell | Financial transactions & more!

    ·39m
  97. 97

    Colby Interviews Lori and She Wants to Represent Herself #LoriValowDaybell

    Colby Ryan interviews his mother Lori Vallow in jail about the deaths of her children Tylee and JJ.

    ·42m
  98. 98

    Day 3 of Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial

    ·14m
  99. 99

    Day 2 of Lori Vallow’s 2nd Arizona Trial- And She Gets Kicked Out of Court!?

    At Lori Vallow’s Arizona conspiracy trial, a judge warned that her loving-person claim could let prosecutors raise four prior murder convictions.

    ·20m·1 clip
  100. 100

    The End of Lori Vallow | Her Sentencing in Arizona

    Mysterious Headlines covers Lori Vallow Daybell's July 25 sentencing hearing in Arizona after convictions involving Charles Vallow and Brandon Boudreaux.

    ·1h 23m·2 clips
  101. 101

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 15 What you can do to help Missing People

    This episode discusses ways listeners can help missing person cases by sharing stories, news, and documentaries.

    Apr 10, 2026·5m
  102. 102

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 14 Why Missing Person Cases Matter

    This episode discusses why missing person cases matter, highlighting the need for justice and closure for families.

    Apr 3, 2026·5m
  103. 103

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 13 Why Indigenous Missing Persons Cases Don’t Get as much Attention

    This episode explores why missing persons cases on Indian reservations receive less attention than others, using the Gabby Petito case as a contrast.

    Mar 27, 2026·7m
  104. 104

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 12 Missing Person Cases on Indian Reservations

    This episode explores the high rates of missing Indigenous people on reservations, focusing on the 2023 statistics and the role of remoteness in these cases.

    Mar 20, 2026·4m
  105. 105

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 11 Domestic Violence & It’s Relation to Missing Person Cases

    This episode explores the link between domestic violence and missing person cases, using the Gabby Petito case as a key example.

    Mar 13, 2026·6m
  106. 106

    Out of the Dark Series Episode 9 Gabby Petito Case

    Mar 6, 2026·13m
  107. 107

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 9 Missing Adult Cases

    Feb 27, 2026·11m
  108. 108

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 8 Deep Dive into Michael Vaughan Case

    Feb 19, 2026·11m
  109. 109

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 7 Deep Dive into Sarah, Stacey, Brandon and Adrien

    Feb 13, 2026·12m
  110. 110

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 6 New Arrest in Michael Vaughan Case

    Hidden gem

    Mysterious Headlines returns to the Michael Vaughn case with October 2025 updates, centered on Fruitland Police arresting Stacey Wandra for first degree murder, second degree kidnapping, and destruction or concealment of evidence.

    Feb 5, 2026·28m·1 clip
  111. 111

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 5 Michael Vaughan- Most Unique Missing Child Case

    Jan 30, 2026·9m
  112. 112

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 4: Amber Alerts

    Jan 23, 2026·6m
  113. 113

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 3: Child Abductions by Strangers

    Jan 16, 2026·5m
  114. 114

    Out of the Dark Series- Episode 2: Missing Children Cases

    Jan 9, 2026·8m
  115. 115

    Out of The Dark Series Episode 1: Introduction

    Jan 2, 2026·2m
  116. 116

    4 Year Anniversary of the Disappearance of Michael Vaughan

    Aug 2, 2025·51m
  117. 117

    The End of Lori Vallow | Her Sentencing in Arizona

    Jul 26, 2025·1h 23m
  118. 118

    Barry Morphew Indicted Again in the Case of Suzanne Morphew

    Jun 23, 2025·7m
  119. 119

    88 Children Removed From An Iowa Bible Camp-Is There A Connection To A Cult?

    Jun 19, 2025·8m
  120. 120

    Verdict Reached in Lori Vallow’s 2nd Arizona Trial Against Brandon Beudroux

    Jun 13, 2025·5m
  121. 121

    State and Defense Rest in Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial Against Brandon Beudroux

    Jun 12, 2025·9m
  122. 122

    Day 4 of Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial Against Brandon Beudroux

    Jun 11, 2025·12m
  123. 123

    Day 3 of Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial

    Jun 10, 2025·14m
  124. 124

    Day 2 of Lori Vallow’s 2nd Arizona Trial- And She Gets Kicked Out of Court!?

    Day two of Lori Vallow's Arizona trial for conspiracy to commit murder against Brandon Boudreau, including her controversial statement in court.

    Jun 8, 2025·20m·1 clip
  125. 125

    Day 1 of Lori’s Arizona Trial Against Brandon Boudreaux

    Jun 6, 2025·17m
  126. 126

    Crystal Sorey Getting $2.25 million from New Hampshire #HarmonyMontgomery

    Jun 4, 2025·7m
  127. 127

    Lori Vallow’s 2nd Arizona Trial Postponed

    Jun 3, 2025·6m
  128. 128

    Lori’s Heated Pre-Trial Hearing

    May 16, 2025·16m
  129. 129

    Lori Vallow Requesting a Re-trial in her Arizona Case

    May 14, 2025·13m
  130. 130

    Closing Arguments in Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    Apr 22, 2025·17m
  131. 131

    Verdict Reached in Lori Vallow’s Arizona Trial

    Apr 22, 2025·4m
  132. 132

    Day 7 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial | State Rests Their Case & Will Lori Testify?

    Apr 17, 2025·17m
  133. 133

    Day 6 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    Apr 16, 2025·14m
  134. 134

    Day 5 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    Hidden gem

    A Social Security agent testified Lori Vallow married Chad Daybell on November 5, 2019 and did not notify the agency.

    Apr 15, 2025·25m·1 clip
  135. 135

    Day 4 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    Day four of Lori Vallow's Arizona trial features testimony from her brother Adam Cox about Charles Vallow's death and family dynamics.

    Apr 11, 2025·30m·2 clips
  136. 136

    Day 3 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    Day three of Lori Vallow's Arizona trial covers cross-examination of a SWAT officer about the murder of her fourth husband, Charles Vallow.

    Apr 10, 2025·23m·1 clip
  137. 137

    Day 2 of Lori Vallow Arizona Trial

    Apr 9, 2025·19m
  138. 138

    Day 1 of Lori Vallow Trial in Arizona

    Apr 8, 2025·18m
  139. 139

    Jury Seated in Lori Vallow Daybell Arizona Trial

    Apr 2, 2025·9m
  140. 140

    Lori Vallow Daybell Motions and Fillings A Week Out From Trial

    Mar 27, 2025·14m
  141. 141

    Lori Vallow Daybell 2nd Pre-Trial Hearing

    Mar 18, 2025·14m
  142. 142

    Lori Vallow Trial Hearing & Dateline Interview

    Mar 15, 2025·15m
  143. 143

    Update on Missing 2 Yr Dane Paulson

    Mar 14, 2025·4m
  144. 144

    Missing 2 Yr Old Dane Paulsen

    Mysterious Headlines covers the disappearance of two-year-old Dane Paulson, last seen in Siletz, Oregon, on March 1, 2025.

    Mar 6, 2025·20m·1 clip
  145. 145

    DCYF Wants Case Dismissed #HarmonyMontgomery

    Feb 22, 2025·8m
  146. 146

    New Gabby Petito Documentary

    Feb 20, 2025·8m
  147. 147

    Unsolved Murder of Maggie Long

    Feb 18, 2025·7m
  148. 148

    Lori Vallow Wants Cameras Banned From Court

    Feb 7, 2025·7m
  149. 149

    Missing Skeleton Brothers

    Feb 5, 2025·10m
  150. 150

    Lori Vallow Wants Case Dismissed

    Feb 3, 2025·7m