Middle Aged And Creeped Out podcast
500 episodes listed below
PRESS PLAY
Based on 4 episodes we listened to · September 2026
It turns haunted-place lore into a communal examination, with Todd, Sean, Nate, and occasional guest Pete weighing each strange detail together.
Todd and Sean approach paranormal accounts as stories to be turned over in company. On Middle Aged And Creeped Out podcast, they move between a location's history and the claims attached to it, while Nate, the tech engineer, punctures the tension with dry interjections.
Alleged spirit cats, then Austin Powers: your kind of haunted hangout?
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A skeptical, lightly comic pass through a famously strange paranormal case.
This episode tracks Todd, Sean, and Nate as they work through the Skoll experiment in a loose, skeptical register. The story moves from the reported lights and levitation to spirit voices, cat-and-dog materializations, and objects said to appear from nowhere, while the hosts…
A haunted-ship discussion that balances eerie lore with a loose group-table rhythm.
The Queen Mary episode treats the ship as a haunted landmark built out of deaths, rumors, and reports people cannot quite pin down. Todd, Sean, Nate, and guest Pete move from the ship's history into the eerie stories around it, and the loose group rhythm is part of the appeal.
A hand-built castle story with curiosity, jokes, and a little loose banter.
The episode keeps its attention on Bishop Castle as a hand-built, lifelong project and lets the hosts respond with curiosity and a dry sense of humor.
A haunted-restaurant episode that keeps its friendly table talk and lets the setting do most of the work.
Middle Aged And Creeped Out makes One if by Land, Two if by Sea feel like a small haunted history lesson with a real room behind it. The episode does well with the Burr lore, the missing Patriot, and the way Todd, Sean, Nate, and Pete keep things moving without sounding stiff or…
Peace, gratitude, and growth in real life.
Life lessons from ordinary turning points.
Minnesota kindness, with hockey and heart.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 252, hinting at paranormal tales about Eloise Asylum while casually discussing their recording schedule and personal activities.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce their podcast and chat casually about their week, including a dinner at Ford's Garage, before hinting at paranormal topics.
This episode features a guest chat with Mark DeNardo from Third Power Paranormal, discussing paranormal tales and investigations.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce their new studio space and tease an upcoming interview with paranormal investigators Kelley and Don Reese from Triple 3 Paranormal.
The hosts Todd and Sean discuss their podcast scheduling and recording process in a casual, humorous conversation.
The hosts Todd and Sean, with engineer Nate and guest Pete, introduce their mini-episode about the Tokoloshe while sharing casual banter about coffee, drinks, and small daily wins.
This episode features a guest chat with Jenny Sullivan of Emerald Isle Paranormal Researchers discussing paranormal investigations and creepy experiences.
The hosts discuss Burg Eltz Castle, focusing on its ghostly lore including the tragic tale of Agnes Eltz from the 16th century and its reputation as a fairy tale castle in Germany.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 258 with casual banter about their week and the spooky Saturday recording.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce their paranormal-themed podcast episode and discuss technical issues with microphone shocks.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 249 with casual New Year's banter about recording ahead of schedule and food traditions like corned beef and cabbage.
The hosts introduce a mini episode about Prospect Place, chosen by Austin Lawrence, with show notes available for source links.
Three hosts discuss a humorous patient encounter involving an old saying about a chair 'giving up the ghost' while introducing their paranormal-themed podcast.
The hosts Todd and Sean introduce a mini episode about King's Arms Tavern, chosen by Nate, after casual banter about weather and upcoming content.
The hosts discuss the questing beast, a mythical creature from folklore, as part of their exploration of cryptids and legendary beasts.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 243, discussing their return and teasing a haunted location topic.
The hosts Todd and Sean introduce a mini-episode about the Golden Fleece Pub, a spooky or mysterious location, on their Middle-Aged and Creeped Out Podcast.
The hosts introduce a mini episode about the Bone Church of Rome, specifically the Capuchin Crypt, sourced from the Grim Life Collective YouTube channel.
The hosts discuss Halloween and introduce a haunted location, Erie Cemetery in Pennsylvania, as the main topic for this episode.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce their Halloween special with a guest chat about paranormal tales, but the conversation starts with a confusing math discussion about zero.
This mini-episode discusses the Mishler Theater in Altoona, Pennsylvania, which is considered one of the most haunted theaters in the state with a history dating back to 1906.
This episode of the Middle-Aged and Creeped Out Podcast discusses the Octagon Hall Museum, a historic eight-sided building with potentially creepy or haunted elements.
This episode features casual, humorous banter between hosts discussing creepy topics like the Santa Compaña legend and a dog story, with playful interruptions and inside jokes.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 245, discussing their podcast format and comparing it to recording a book while noting Todd's absence due to family business.
The hosts Todd and Sean introduce their Middle-Aged Mini episode, discussing their eclectic and therapeutic conversations, including off-air talk and a missed joke, while hinting at a haunted theme with the Bruce Mansion title.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 246 with casual banter about their lives and chiropractor before hinting at discussing paranormal tales related to Rolling Hills Asylum.
This episode discusses Captain Grant's Inn, a historic bed and breakfast from 1754, highlighting its cozy atmosphere, amenities, and hospitality.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 254 about the Kecksburg UFO incident while discussing the cold weather in Indianapolis.
The hosts Todd and Sean introduce a mini episode of their Middle-Aged and Creeped Out podcast, discussing their return and casual banter before hinting at a topic about Mother Shipton.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 250, which will cover the paranormal Smurl House hauntings, while briefly discussing their podcast's five-year anniversary.
This is a brief introductory episode for the Middle-Aged and Creeped Out Podcast focusing on Spike Island.
This mini episode features hosts Sean and Nate discussing the show's episode numbering, Todd's absence, and sharing a dad joke from Sean's cousin.
This episode features an interview with paranormal investigator and author Katie Paige, discussing her experiences and research into unexplained phenomena.
This mini-episode introduces a discussion about the Lake Club in Springfield, Illinois, as part of a middle-aged podcast exploring creepy or unusual topics.
The hosts introduce and discuss The Treasurer's House in York, England, a location with paranormal history and connections to money.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 251 with banter about paranormal topics and a Netflix show suggestion.
Hosts Todd and Sean introduce their mini episode with casual banter about being wound up, referencing jokes and movies like Cannonball Run.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out discuss their podcast room being invaded and moving plans while setting up a paranormal-themed episode.
This mini-episode explores the topic of giants in mythology and folklore, discussing their origins and characteristics.
This episode discusses Rufford Old Hall, a reportedly haunted historical location, with hosts Todd and Sean exploring its supernatural aspects and history.
This episode features hosts Todd, Sean, and Nate discussing their personalities and conversational styles while introducing a paranormal-themed show about haunted locations in Teesside.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce their paranormal podcast and briefly discuss local Notre Dame football before presumably delving into tales of Malvern Manor.
The hosts celebrate their 100th episode of a paranormal podcast with humorous banter about maintaining their unpolished style while discussing creepy tales like Skinwalker Ranch.
This episode explores the mysterious Belmez Faces, a paranormal phenomenon in Spain where ghostly faces appeared on the floor of a house.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 239, which will feature tales of the paranormal, specifically focusing on haunted Glamis Castle.
The hosts of Middle-Aged and Creeped Out introduce episode 260 with casual banter about the weather and their show's paranormal theme.
The hosts discuss the Scole Experiment, a five-year paranormal investigation in 1990s England that claimed to provide scientific proof of the afterlife through seances, spirit communications, and unexplained phenomena like levitating objects and faces on film.
The hosts discuss the haunted history of One if by Land, Two if by Sea restaurant in New York City, covering ghostly activity tied to Aaron Burr, his daughter Theodosia, and other spirits, with tales of apparitions, EVPs, and staff encounters.
The hosts discuss Bishop Castle in Colorado, a hand-built structure by Jim Bishop over 50 years, highlighting its dangerous features, Bishop's personal struggles, and its legacy as a unique roadside attraction.
The hosts discuss the haunted history of the RMS Queen Mary, covering its construction, famous passengers, and tragic events like the watertight door accident and sinking of another ship.
The hosts introduce a mini-episode about the Fresno Nightcrawler cryptid with lighthearted banter.
Hosts Todd and Sean engage in lighthearted banter before introducing a mini-episode about the Devil's Bridge of Germany.
Hosts Todd, Sean, and Nate introduce their podcast about paranormal and creepy stories, sharing casual banter and setting up story time.
The hosts engage in casual, humorous banter about their mini episode count and introduce a topic about Willow's Weep House.
Hosts Todd, Sean, and Nate engage in comedic banter and introduce a paranormal story episode.
Hosts Todd and Sean joke and banter about the number 222 and personal stories in a mini-episode of their horror comedy podcast.
Hosts Todd, Sean, and Nate return to the studio to share and discuss creepy paranormal tales with humorous banter.
Hosts share personal experiences and listener tales of paranormal events and creepy occurrences.
Two hosts engage in lighthearted, humorous banter about technical glitches and weather.
Hosts Todd, Sean, and Nate introduce their paranormal storytelling podcast with humorous banter and a warning of creepy tales.