Middle Aged And Creeped Out podcast · Middle Aged And Creeped Out podcast

Middle Aged Mini #224 - One if by Land, Two if by Sea Restaurant

·20 min·1 clip
Unseen eyes watch patrons at One if by Land, Two if by Sea, where lights flicker and electronics come alive on their own.
Todd, Sean, Nate, and guest Pete Peterson start with easy in-studio banter and jokes about being abducted by a Mako limousine, a helicopter, a castle, a tour bus, or an old RV. The conversation then shifts to One if by Land, Two if by Sea and its haunted, romantic look, complete with hanging candlelit chandeliers. The crew keeps circling back to how beautiful the place looks and how much they would like to visit. The ghost lore broadens out from there. They talk about a woman on the stairs, believed to have been one of the Ziegfeld Follies actresses who tripped on her dress and broke her neck. They also note a woman dressed in black rather than white. The restaurant manager's experiences add more odd detail: picture frames tilt by themselves, machines activate by themselves, lights turn on without explanation, and staff light a candle for a ghost believed to be a Ziegfeld Follies girl. The episode ends with the group sounding interested in making the trip, and the mood stays curious rather than grim.

As heard by us

A haunted-restaurant episode that keeps its friendly table talk and lets the setting do most of the work.

Middle Aged And Creeped Out makes One if by Land, Two if by Sea feel like a small haunted history lesson with a real room behind it. The episode does well with the Burr lore, the missing Patriot, and the way Todd, Sean, Nate, and Pete keep things moving without sounding stiff or…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A haunted Manhattan restaurant stop for listeners who like ghost lore with friendly banter.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on