Wrestling talk with basement-couch comic drift.
Marty & Sarah turns pro-wrestling conversation into a lived-in comedy routine, with AEW gripes, Patreon updates, neighborhood stories, and pet chaos sharing the same couch. The show suits listeners who like their wrestling talk affectionate, distracted, and willing to chase a joke until it becomes its own storyline.
PRESS PLAY
Marty & Sarah is a wrestling-comedy show that treats the week in wrestling as a launchpad, not a fence. The center of gravity is conversation. Marty and Sarah move through AEW reactions, WWE comparisons, pay-per-view energy, women’s division frustrations, and wrestling-adjacent pop culture with the speed of people who have been making each other laugh for a long time. Then the topic slips. Suddenly MTV is a time capsule, Portlandia is a mourning ritual, My Blue Heaven has a wrestling tie-in, printer ink has become a subscription nightmare, or a dog named Buddy is being analyzed like a complicated character on television. That is where the show lives. It is not clean recap radio. It is a basement hang with callbacks, mock-serious theories, affectionate interruptions, and enough wrestling vocabulary to reward fans who know the difference between a hot angle and a plot point that needs more heat. The comedy often starts small: snow in Wisconsin, a neighbor interaction, a Patreon update, a pet habit, a throwaway memory. Then it gets bigger and stranger until the joke has its own little mythology. The wrestling talk is similarly personal. AEW can be praised as solid, criticized for unfocused booking, or used as a way to talk about what makes a performer feel special. WWE fans, Triple H press questions, Tony Khan, Paige, Willow Nightingale, Jade, Toni Storm, Samoa Joe, Hangman Page, Kevin Nash, and JR all surface in the recent run, but the show does not flatten them into analysis-board pieces. They become part of the hosts’ shared comic weather. There is also a real warmth under the noise. The episodes repeatedly nod to longtime listeners, Patreon supporters, friends, family stress, illness, and the simple relief of being back after time away. That sincerity never turns glossy. It usually gets folded into a joke, a goodbye, a song bit, or one more digression. The result is a show for people who like wrestling, but also like hearing wrestling people talk about everything around wrestling: pets, aging, movies, work, nostalgia, local errands, comedy, and the weird little rituals that make a weekly show feel alive.
Made for: For wrestling fans who enjoy AEW and WWE talk filtered through loose comedy, domestic stories, and long-running callbacks. Best for listeners who prefer a warm, chaotic hang over formal recap structure.
What sets it apart: The show’s edge is its willingness to let wrestling analysis become a bit, then let the bit reveal something sincere. Few wrestling-comedy shows make booking complaints, MTV nostalgia, Buddy updates, and Patreon housekeeping feel like the same ongoing conversation.
Two comedians who met and fell in love over pro-wrestling open up their hearts and minds weekly to address the state of things - any things! You never know who will show up or where the lines between fantasy and reality blur. Your buds Marty & Sarah are your tour guides on this joyful romp through the fields of nowadays.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Wrestling analysis becomes intimate and funny through Marty and Sarah's quick riffs, domestic detours, and alertness to performance.
Marty and Sarah turn wrestling talk into conversational comedy, letting analysis share the room with domestic life, pets, movies, MTV memories, and invented voices.
AEW booking shares the couch with Buddy's high-heel habit, if that's your kind of wrestling night.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Buddy's dog-puberty update sends Marty and Sarah into a funny, gently skeptical drift through MTV nostalgia.
Marty and Sarah settle into a wintry Wisconsin-basement rhythm, moving from snow-scraping and thawed-out dog poop to Buddy, their nine-month-old puppy, who seems to be entering dog puberty.
A warm comedy hang where casual advice, an old grievance, and podcast logistics all become bits.
Marty and Sarah take a loose, affectionate route through podcast distribution, career advice, and a grievance from the comedy world. An iHeartRadio roast joke leads into a complaint about a difficult colleague, Jerry Seinfeld's casual encouragement of Orny Adams, the irony…
A wrestling catch-up keeps slipping into neighborhood etiquette, fake IDs, Buddy's foot fixation, and a watch-along invitation.
Marty and Sarah turn a casual catch-up into a reminder of why their show works best when it sounds unplanned. Patreon neighborhood walks, the etiquette of recording near neighbors, and an age-gap bar story all become material, with Sarah's own "walking hypocrite" admission…
A puppy-parent spiral that wanders through printer subscriptions, wrestling questions, lawn edges, and bedtime.
Marty and Sarah make new puppy parenthood feel like a comic stress test, as Marty treats poop pickup like a calling and the conversation widens into respect for dog parents, cat parents, kid parents, and anyone handling puppies and babies at once.
A compassionate mental-health discussion gives way to sharp wrestling talk and a thoroughly examined Vince McMahon walk.
The hosts open with a personal discussion of mental-health awareness and grief. One recalls the guilt and unanswered questions that followed a close friend's death, giving their appeal to talk to someone real weight.
A stranger calls. Chris Gethard listens. Anything can surface.
Marty and Sarah return from a week off to discuss the chaotic state of AEW on its three-year anniversary.
Marty opens up about his decision to restart medication after five years due to a new, severe depression, linking it to mental health awareness in wrestling.
Two comedians and wrestling fans banter about their week, including a concert and a movie.
Comedians Marty and Sarah discuss wrestling and pop culture with humorous banter.
Marty and Sarah record at Zach Thompson's house in Illinois after Zach mailed Marty the Galoob wrestling figures his brother Sam collected before dying in 2012.
Marty and Sarah return from their Wisconsin basement to give a Buddy the dog update, noting he's nine months old and newly shaved down.
Marty and Sarah open with distribution-platform banter and a compound roast joke about 'iHeart Disease Radio' before recapping their casual daily life, including hanging Christmas lights and neighbor Glenn's punctuality.
Marty and Sarah frame the episode as a return to regular podcasting after Patreon walk-and-talks, a dog named Buddy, and a few months of hesitation about restarting.
Marty and Sarah spend a long stretch on R-Truth's WWE return, including the reported lower-rate offer, the unanswered Triple H calls, and the shift from R-Truth to Ron Killings.
A true-crime story turns on a wife poisoning her husband before the airport meeting for $30 million.
Comedians Marty and Sarah discuss the Super Bowl, podcast algorithms, and a friend's dental fundraiser in a lighthearted wrestling-themed show.
Comedians Marty and Sarah discuss their wrestling podcast, announce signing Noli to their network, and promote Patreon content.