Killer

49 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Two hosts, one case, walked through testimony by testimony.

The gist

Killer is a conversational true crime show from David and Craig, who split a case into numbered parts and talk it through together. Its Delphi episodes follow the trial of Richard Allen for the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German by testimony day, alongside a post-mortem on his conviction.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Killer

Killer is a true crime show hosted by David Chabotty with co-host Craig Sitzlein, and it prefers to stay with a case across several parts. Cases get numbers and parts. The most sustained run in the recent episodes is the Delphi material, which follows the trial of Richard Allen for the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German across four numbered trial installments and 'The Delphi Murders - Post Mortem Show'. By the hosts' own account, Part 1 recapped the murders and what immediately followed, and Part 2 turns to the trial itself. Part 1 also covers the investigation of a man named Klein, who ran a fake online persona built on a male model's photographs and had been in contact with Liberty close to the time of her death. The trial episodes go through the testimony day by day. On day nine, Stacy Bozanovsky, a forensic scientist and DNA analyst, testifies that none of the items she tested carried Allen's DNA, and the hosts note that a single hair found in Abby's hand belonged to Libby's older sister, Kelsey. The pair do not just relay the record. One of them calls the defense's push against a vaguely stated prosecution point a great strategy. A courtroom claim that Allen's appearance had not changed also draws a pointed reaction, set against how visibly he had changed since his arrest photo. The episodes also show real feeling. In Part 2 the conversation turns to how the two girls stayed together in the woods instead of splitting up, and to the possibility, raised by an unspent bullet, that the attacker had a gun as well as a knife. The post-mortem, framed around the conviction, includes a moment-by-moment narration of the phone video from the bridge, down to the second and the figure the hosts call 'bridge guy'. Around the case work, the register is loose and good-natured. The hosts joke about which of them is the better half, grumble about technical demons, and admit that one of these days they will act like they have been here before. They say openly that the show is back after a five-year gap, and when that timeline brushes against presidential politics they steer clear of it. Housekeeping is part of the texture too: a new website at killerpodcast.org with the back catalog still being added, social accounts, and a Patreon pitched as a coffee fund. The numbered format reaches beyond Delphi, to 'Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 2 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 1)', whose opening describes a community so frightened that people slept with shotguns and bought dogs. Every Delphi installment closes on the same two words: stay safe. What a listener gets is a case followed patiently, testimony by testimony, by two hosts who say plainly what they make of it. The subject matter is heavy, including the killing of two girls, child exploitation and sexual violence, and it is discussed directly.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants a murder trial followed testimony by testimony in relaxed two-host conversation, and who can handle frank discussion of violence against children.

What sets it apart: Instead of one tidy retelling, Killer stays with a case across numbered parts, tracking trial days, forensic results and courtroom tactics, and gives the verdict its own post-mortem episode. The hosts' own reactions sit right alongside the testimony.

In their own words

Welcome to Killer: A True Crime Podcast. David and Craig break down new cases and provide the latest news in the True Crime community.

Why you'd press play

The Delphi trial, day by day, for your inner "wait, what about the DNA?"

Press play if you want

  • to follow the testimony in order and have time to question what each witness establishes
  • to hear David and Craig think aloud about the gaps in the forensic evidence
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Delphi murdersTrial of Richard AllenTrial testimony by dayForensic and DNA evidenceDefense and prosecution tacticsGolden State KillerMulti-part murder cases

Talks about

Best episodes of Killer

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

The Delphi Murders - Post Mortem ShowMar 26, 2025

David and Craig revisit the Delphi bridge video as an ordinary walk turns frightening.

Killer's first post-mortem review centers on the Delphi trial, Richard Allen's conviction, and the phone video Libby recorded on the bridge. David and Craig spend their strongest stretch tracking the clip beat by beat: Abby on the bridge, Libby's camera moving toward the gravel,…

The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 4Mar 17, 2025

A steady, conversational look at the Delphi trial's late phase and the emotional weight around its conclusion.

The Delphi trial coverage follows a late stage of the case against Richard Allen for the murders of Abigail Williams and Liberty German, keeping its attention on how the courtroom record narrows toward a conclusion.

The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 3Mar 11, 2025

Forensic testimony gives this Delphi trial episode its tension, especially where the evidence stops short of certainty.

Trial coverage here is strongest when it stays with what the forensic work could prove, and what it could not. The episode follows Stacy Bozanovsky's testimony on sexual assault kits, blood samples, crime-scene swabs, clothing, and a 40 caliber Smith and Wesson cartridge, with…

The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 2Feb 23, 2025

A measured, conversational review of Richard Allen's trial coverage, attentive to courtroom structure and uncertainty near the bridge.

This PlayNext single-episode review follows the Delphi murder trial installment as it turns from the killings and immediate aftermath toward Richard Allen's courtroom proceedings.

The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 1Feb 3, 2025

A long-awaited return gives the Anthony Shots investigation a clear, chronological account of its online trail and legal fallout.

Killer returns after an almost five-year silence with a relaxed reintroduction before settling into the online trail around Liberty German. David and Craig address the gap plainly, thank the listeners who stayed subscribed, and frame the restart as a chance to rebuild momentum…

Podcasts like Killer

Episodes

  1. 1

    The Delphi Murders - Post Mortem Show

    Killer Podcast's Delphi post-mortem revisits the trial that ended with Richard Allen's conviction, with David and Craig arguing that the case rests on a stack of circumstantial evidence.

    Mar 26, 2025·39m·2 clips
  2. 2

    The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 4

    Hidden gem

    Brian Harshman testified that Richard Allen's voice matched the bridge-guy audio from Libby German's phone, and the jury heard the 'down the hill' recording again.

    Mar 17, 2025·55m·4 clips
  3. 3

    The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 3

    Killer covers days 6-11 of the Richard Allen trial in Delphi, Indiana, with David Chabotty and Craig Sitzlein recapping testimony from Kathy Schenck through Dr.

    Mar 11, 2025·55m·5 clips
  4. 4

    The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 2

    Killer's "The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 2" covers the October 18, 2024 trial start in Carroll County, Indiana, where Judge Gahl barred cameras and jury photos.

    Feb 23, 2025·1h 1m·4 clips
  5. 5

    The Delphi Murders - The Trial of Richard Allen - Part 1

    Killer's Delphi recap centers on the 43-second bridge video, the reported "down the hill" audio, and the day Abby Williams and Liberty German went missing in Delphi, Indiana.

    Feb 3, 2025·56m·3 clips
  6. 6

    Delphi Murders - The Trial - Part 1 - 2025 Trailer

    Jan 25, 2025·5m
  7. 7

    Case 032 - Jennifer Dulos

    Jennifer Dulos disappeared after dropping her five children at school in New Canaan on May 24, 2019.

    Oct 5, 2020·27m·2 clips
  8. 8

    Golden State Killer - Victim Impact Statements - Part 2

    Elizabeth Hupp recounts that Joseph DeAngelo shot her father, Claude Snelling, when he tried to rescue her in 1975.

    Sep 15, 2020·1h 3m·2 clips
  9. 9

    Golden State Killer - Victim Impact Statements - Part 1

    Jane Carson Sandler recounts Joseph DeAngelo binding her and her three-year-old son during a 1976 home invasion, then describes anxiety that still follows helicopters and ski masks.

    Sep 3, 2020·1h 11m·2 clips
  10. 10

    Killer News - Week of June 22, 2020

    Jul 3, 2020·16m
  11. 11

    Case 031 - The Black Wall Street Massacre

    Jul 1, 2020·28m
  12. 12

    Case 030 - Cletus Reese

    May 29, 2020·36m
  13. 13

    Case 029 - The Whitaker Family

    May 20, 2020·29m
  14. 14

    Case 028 - Jacob Evans

    May 13, 2020·57m
  15. 15

    Case 027 - Skylar Neese

    Apr 30, 2020·42m
  16. 16

    Case 026 - Lisa R. Snyder

    Apr 21, 2020·37m
  17. 17

    Case 025 - Edward Wayne Edwards - Part 3

    Apr 13, 2020·37m
  18. 18

    Case 025 - Edward Wayne Edwards - Part 2

    Apr 7, 2020·1h 6m
  19. 19

    Case 025 - Edward Wayne Edwards - Part 1

    Mar 30, 2020·28m
  20. 20

    Case 024 - Nathaniel Bar-Jonah

    Mar 23, 2020·50m
  21. 21

    Case 023 - Ellen Greenberg

    Mar 13, 2020·40m
  22. 22

    Killer - Case Update - Episode 001 - 2020

    Mar 6, 2020·48m
  23. 23

    Bonus Show - New Show Announcements, Case Updates, and Q & A

    Jun 10, 2019·1h 21m
  24. 24

    Case 022 - The Great Brinks Robbery - Part 2

    May 28, 2019·1h 6m
  25. 25

    Case 022 - The Great Brinks Robbery - Part 1

    May 20, 2019·44m
  26. 26

    Case 021 - The Delphi Murders

    May 13, 2019·1h 4m
  27. 27

    Case 020 - Joseph "The Cannibal" Metheny

    May 6, 2019·38m
  28. 28

    Case 019 - Karla Homolka & Paul Bernardo

    Apr 29, 2019·41m
  29. 29

    Case 018 - The Disappearance of Benjamin Brubaker

    Apr 8, 2019·55m
  30. 30

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 11 - (The Original Night Stalker - Part 2)

    Mar 25, 2019·1h 9m
  31. 31

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 10 - (The Original Night Stalker - Part 1)

    Mar 18, 2019·40m
  32. 32

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 9 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 8)

    Mar 11, 2019·51m
  33. 33

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 8 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 7)

    Mar 4, 2019·1h 1m
  34. 34

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 7 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 6)

    Feb 25, 2019·1h 1m
  35. 35

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 6 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 5)

    Feb 18, 2019·1h 9m
  36. 36

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 5 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 4)

    Feb 11, 2019·1h 11m
  37. 37

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 4 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 3)

    Feb 4, 2019·1h 5m
  38. 38

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 3 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 2)

    Jan 28, 2019·1h 1m
  39. 39

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 2 - (The East Area Rapist - Part 1)

    This episode begins a multi-part series on the Golden State Killer, detailing the terror he inflicted on communities.

    Jan 21, 2019·1h 10m
  40. 40

    Case 017 - The Golden State Killer - Part 1 - (The Visalia Ransacker)

    This episode begins the story of the Golden State Killer, focusing on the Visalia Ransacker phase and Detective Bill McGowan's confrontation with the suspect.

    Jan 7, 2019·48m
  41. 41

    Case 016 - The Farmville Murders

    Dec 31, 2018·51m
  42. 42

    Case 015 - Trayvon Martin

    Dec 24, 2018·1h 29m
  43. 43

    Case 014 - Paul John Knowles

    This episode details the life and crimes of serial killer Paul John Knowles, from his troubled childhood to his first incarceration.

    Dec 17, 2018·38m
  44. 44

    Case 013 - The Happy Face Killer - Part 2

    This episode details the first murder committed by the Happy Face Killer, Keith Jesperson, in 1990.

    Dec 10, 2018·58m
  45. 45

    Case 013 - The Happy Face Killer - Part 1

    This episode begins a deep dive into the Happy Face Killer case, exploring the killer's background and the impact on his family.

    Dec 3, 2018·49m
  46. 46

    Case 012 - The Pike County Murders

    This episode details the 2016 Pike County Murders, where eight members of the Roden family were killed execution-style in their homes.

    Nov 26, 2018·53m
  47. 47

    Case 011 - The Cleveland Strangler

    This episode investigates the Cleveland Strangler case, detailing the discovery of multiple bodies in a house and the ongoing investigation.

    Nov 19, 2018·52m
  48. 48

    Case 010 - Pork Chop Rob

    The episode examines newly released police interrogation tapes of serial killer Robert Pickton, who hints at multiple murders but stops short of a full confession.

    Nov 12, 2018·57m
  49. 49

    Case 009 - The Toolbox Killers

    Nov 5, 2018·50m