It Happened to a Friend of a Friend

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Creepy cases, casual voices, uneasy nights.

The gist

It Happened to a Friend of a Friend moves between notorious crimes, wrongful convictions, haunted forests, and strange historical horrors. The mood is spooky but chatty, with grim case details offset by everyday conversation, throwback jokes, and a recurring little-stitious signoff.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About It Happened to a Friend of a Friend

It Happened to a Friend of a Friend is a creepy-stories and true-crime show with a strong conversational spine. It does not separate the dark material from the people telling it. Recent episodes move across Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka, Steven Truscott, Lake Bodom, Hoia Baciu, Reena Virk, David Shearing, Ann Woodward, Fox Hollow Farms, Jack the Ripper, Gypsy Rose Blanchard, camping horror stories, phrenology, and deadly Victorian fashion trends. That range gives the show room for notorious cases, wrongful conviction, haunted-place lore, historical violence, and odd cultural dangers. The stories can be grim. The delivery stays human-sized. A disturbing account may sit beside talk about maternity leave, a baby quilt, social batteries, old soap operas, office supplies, flash mobs, accents, or a strange video from childhood memory. The switches are part of the texture rather than a break from it. The speakers sound like friends who came prepared with notes, then kept all the side chatter in because the side chatter is also the point. The show’s title fits the atmosphere: intimate, secondhand, slightly whispered, and meant to raise the hair on the back of the neck. Its true-crime selections include cases involving missing girls, murder, contested evidence, confessions, and the question of why people do terrible things. Its horror side reaches into forests, ghosts, UFO talk, old folklore, and places with a reputation for fear. It can be blunt. It can also be oddly cozy. The opening image of turning down the lights and keeping feet tucked safely away captures the intended feeling without making the show feel theatrical. Compared with more formal crime podcasts, this one keeps the room tone: interruptions, jokes, hesitations, personal updates, and recurring signoff rituals remain visible. That gives the show a recognizable rhythm. It is not detached. It is not purely comic either. The appeal is the balance between unsettling subject matter and the comfort of familiar voices working through it together. For PlayNext, it sits at the crossing point of true crime, horror fiction adjacency, paranormal curiosity, and casual friend banter.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants true crime and eerie stories in a conversational, friend-to-friend style rather than a formal investigative tone. Best fit for someone comfortable with dark cases when they are balanced by casual banter and everyday tangents.

What sets it apart: The show’s edge is the contrast between disturbing material and loose personal conversation: murder, hauntings, and old mysteries share space with quilts, soap operas, office supplies, and throwback jokes. It feels intimate without dropping the creep factor.

In their own words

If you like the creepy, the eerie, and the weird, then we've got the tales for you. Join us for stories that make you want to pull the covers up tight, as well some fun banter peppered in there.

Why you'd press play

A bloody apron, then a pronunciation debate: your true crime night has room to exhale.

Press play if you want

  • to follow a Whitechapel clue while hearing the uncertainty around who left it
  • to think through a wrongful conviction with people willing to sit with what remains unknown
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
true crime caseswrongful convictionscamping horror storieshaunted placeshistorical crimeparanormal folklorecasual throwback banter

Talks about

Best episodes of It Happened to a Friend of a Friend

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Paul Bernardo and Karla HomolkaAug 16, 2024

A chilling account of shared violence that keeps the question of Karla Homolka's participation in view.

The episode treats the Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka case as a study in shared violence, and in the unanswered questions that still cling to it.

Steven Truscott and the Appalachian Trail KillerAug 1, 2024

A wrongful-conviction case is revisited through time of death, missed avenues, and evidence reconsidered years later.

The episode works best when it stays close to the slow unmaking of Steven Truscott's conviction. It follows the case through the paths the hosts say were left underexplored, then into the later evidence that made the original timeline harder to hold.

Lake Bodom Murders and PhrenologyJul 18, 2024

A suspicious hospital visit and a troubled local suspect keep the Lake Bodom case unsettled.

The Lake Bodom murders are framed through the suspects, alibis, and uneasy details that kept suspicion from fading. Hans Assman stands out after arriving at a Helsinki surgical hospital with dirt beneath his fingernails and bloodstained clothing, then grows more troubling…

Camping Horror Stories Part 2 (Hoia Baciu) and Reena VirkJun 21, 2024

A loose double feature where haunted-forest lore gives way to true crime revisited through Under the Bridge.

This single-episode review follows the show as it moves through two uneasy lanes: a creepy forest discussion shaped by paranormal-TV material, then the murder of a fourteen-year-old brought back into focus after one host had been watching Under the Bridge on Disney Plus, with…

Podcasts like It Happened to a Friend of a Friend

Episodes

  1. 1

    Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka

    Hidden gem

    It Happened to a Friend of a Friend ties the Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka case to Scarborough bus-stop attacks, St.

    Aug 16, 2024·51m·3 clips
  2. 2

    Steven Truscott and the Appalachian Trail Killer

    Hidden gem

    Stephen Truscott was 14 when Ontario authorities convicted him of killing 12-year-old Cheryl Lynn Harper and sentenced him to death by hanging after a two-and-a-half-hour jury deliberation.

    Aug 1, 2024·47m·3 clips
  3. 3

    Lake Bodom Murders and Phrenology

    A Lake Bodom camping trip for Mela Bjorklund's 16th birthday opens the episode with a collapsed tent and a 6 a.m.

    Jul 18, 2024·39m·2 clips
  4. 4

    Camping Horror Stories Part 2 (Hoia Baciu) and Reena Virk

    Hidden gem

    It Happened to a Friend of a Friend pairs Megan and Sarah's story exchange with Hoia Baciu Forest in northwestern Romania and the Reena Virk case from Saanich, British Columbia.

    Jun 21, 2024·37m·2 clips
  5. 5

    Camping Horror Stories and Deadly Victorian Fashion Trends

    Hidden gem

    ["A burned car near Wells Grey Provincial Park leads to the RCMP finding six dead members of the Johnson and Bentley families and a .22-caliber murder weapon.", "Megan follows the 1982 timeline from Bob Johnson's missed shift at Gorman Brothers Lumber to the September 13 discovery near Battle Mountain Road and the Bear Creek campsite clues.", "Sarah then pivots to Victorian fashion, where lead makeup, mercury hat-making, corsets, crinolines, belladonna drops, and tuberculosis all show up as status markers with physical costs.", "The episode mixes Canadian true crime with historical body-harm trivia, and the second half adds crinoline fires and the mercury problem behind the Mad Hatter image without slowing down."]

    Jun 2, 2024·34m·2 clips
  6. 6

    The Best Friend Murder and Scheele Green

    Hidden gem

    Sarah and Megan examine Skylar Neese’s 2012 disappearance from Morgantown, West Virginia, including conflicting timelines, security footage, and cell-phone evidence involving Sheila and Rachel Shove.

    Jun 1, 2024·31m·2 clips
  7. 7

    Ann Woodward and Fox Hollow Farms

    It Happened to a Friend of a Friend pairs Ann Woodward’s 1955 shooting of William Woodward Jr.

    Mar 8, 2024·41m·2 clips
  8. 8

    Jack the Ripper and a Gypsy Rose Blanchard Update

    Megan and Sarah examine Jack the Ripper's 1888 Whitechapel murders, beginning with Victorian London, its population of more than 6 million, and an East End life expectancy of 37 years.

    Feb 9, 2024·55m·3 clips
  9. 9

    Gilded Age Swindlers and New Orleans Axe Murderer

    Hidden gem

    Megan and Sarah examine Gilded Age fraud through Ellen Peck, who stole $10,000 in bonds from soap tycoon B.T.

    Jan 25, 2024·55m·3 clips
  10. 10

    Christmas Killings and Phrogging

    Hidden gem

    Sarah and Megan’s Christmas episode pairs the 2008 Corvina attack by Bruce Jeffrey Pardo, who arrived at an Ortega family party dressed as Santa, with historical Christmas killings.

    Dec 14, 2023·39m·2 clips
  11. 11

    Louise Wise Services and BTK

    Nov 16, 2023·50m
  12. 12

    Christina Boyer and The Winchester House

    Oct 26, 2023·40m
  13. 13

    Guy Paul Morin and the Devil at Loftus Hall

    Oct 13, 2023·35m
  14. 14

    The Haunting in Connecticut and Spontaneous Human Combustion

    Sep 14, 2023·49m
  15. 15

    Ed Kemper and Jaws

    Jul 28, 2023·48m
  16. 16

    Princess Caraboo and Cocaine Bear

    Jul 13, 2023·30m
  17. 17

    Shasta Groene and The Stonewall Riots

    Jun 15, 2023·41m
  18. 18

    Anna Delvey and Candy Montgomery

    Jun 1, 2023·50m
  19. 19

    Athalia Ponsell Lindsley Part 2 and Game Show Scandals

    May 18, 2023·41m
  20. 20

    Levi Weeks and Athalia Ponsell Lindsley

    May 4, 2023·48m
  21. 21

    Fairmont Banff Ghosts and The Titanic

    Apr 20, 2023·44m
  22. 22

    Murdaugh Family and James Jameson Cannibal Incident

    Two friends chat about their week, Saint Patrick's Day, matching sweaters, and a cheap movie outing, setting up their creepy story format.

    Mar 23, 2023·42m
  23. 23

    Vallow Daybell Cult (Part 2) and Angela Diaz and Michelle Hadley

    Mar 9, 2023·55m
  24. 24

    Creepy Pastas and Vallow Daybell Cult (Part 1)

    Feb 23, 2023·56m
  25. 25

    Kim Family Road Trip and Jen Shah

    Jan 26, 2023·40m
  26. 26

    Jennifer Pan and The Burari Deaths

    Jan 12, 2023·42m
  27. 27

    Christmas Crimes

    A horror fiction podcast that opens with a spooky introduction before transitioning into lighthearted banter about Christmas travel.

    Dec 24, 2022·27m
  28. 28

    Ecole Polytechnique Massacre and Spring Heel Jack

    Dec 15, 2022·41m
  29. 29

    Ed Gein and Beverly Smith

    Nov 17, 2022·39m
  30. 30

    The Bell Witch and Halloween Horrors

    Oct 27, 2022·43m
  31. 31

    Annabelle and Salem Witch Trials

    Oct 13, 2022·41m
  32. 32

    The Pied Piper of Tucson and Orloj aka the "Cursed Clock"

    Sep 29, 2022·38m
  33. 33

    Hazing Horror Stories and Vampire Tales

    Sep 15, 2022·37m
  34. 34

    The Scream Murders and The Boy in the Box

    Sep 1, 2022·40m
  35. 35

    Amusement Park Horrors and Elmer McCurdy

    Aug 4, 2022·45m
  36. 36

    La Dame Verte and The Bling Ring

    A horror fiction podcast where hosts share creepy urban legends and personal anecdotes with lighthearted banter.

    Jul 21, 2022·42m
  37. 37

    Dexter Killer and Leopold and Loeb

    Jul 7, 2022·41m
  38. 38

    Creepy Fun Facts and Chilling Prom Stories

    Jun 23, 2022·41m
  39. 39

    The Soka Forest and Angelina Napolitano

    Jun 9, 2022·45m
  40. 40

    John List and The Soap Maker of Corregio

    Hosts share a creepy story and banter about side hustles and watching X-Files.

    May 26, 2022·42m
  41. 41

    Villisca Axe Murders and Issei Sagawa

    May 12, 2022·44m
  42. 42

    Ghost Towns and Amber Hagerman

    Apr 14, 2022·51m
  43. 43

    Papin Sisters and Duplessis Orphans

    Hosts engage in casual banter before introducing a creepy story, blending humor with eerie tales.

    Mar 31, 2022·44m
  44. 44

    Creepy Chit Chat

    Hosts share creepy stories with lighthearted banter and mic setup jokes.

    Mar 17, 2022·52m
  45. 45

    Dead Woman's Crossing and David Milgaard

    Mar 3, 2022·36m
  46. 46

    Lobotomies and Staircases to Hell

    Two friends exchange playful banter and set the mood for sharing eerie stories on Galentine's Day.

    Feb 17, 2022·40m
  47. 47

    Chanie Wenjack and Victor Lustig

    Feb 3, 2022·44m
  48. 48

    Paul McCartney is Dead and Sweet Fanny Adams

    Hosts share creepy stories with humorous banter, starting with a discussion about Zoom and a birthday.

    Jan 20, 2022·40m
  49. 49

    Brentwood Five Massacre and Coupon Scams

    Jan 6, 2022·49m
  50. 50

    Christmas Ghosts and The Lawson Family Murders

    Dec 23, 2021·41m