True crime with chaotic spooky banter.
I'm Sorry...What?! is a loose, joke-heavy true crime show built around murder cases, mysteries, strange history, and October-ready paranormal stories. The tone swings from case details to chaotic side comments without sanding down the darker material.
PRESS PLAY
I'm Sorry...What?! is a true crime comedy show built from murder cases, disappearances, spooky stories, odd historical events, and the kind of banter that refuses to stay in its lane. The episodes move from Daniel Robinson and Orsolya Gala to Rhonda Hinson, PA Jane Doe, the Sisters in Black murder, the Reservoir Dogs murder, Tania Head, and the Elizabeth Shoaf kidnapping. The subject matter is often grim. The delivery is deliberately casual, loud, and interruptive. Case details share space with personal updates, health chaos, moving stress, wedding planning, skull mugs, cow pictures, and strange running jokes. That friction is the point. The show can spend time on search efforts, unidentified remains, suspicious wills, alleged ghosts, old murder cases, or vanished aircraft, then immediately veer into impressions, spooky-season riffs, or a tangent about an internet definition nobody was ready for. It has a home-recorded immediacy rather than a polished newsroom cadence. The speakers sound comfortable with each other, and the show lets that comfort shape the pacing. Some listeners will come for the cases. Others will stay for the disorder around the cases. October episodes lean into haunted stories, paranormal claims, and eerie mysteries, including Flight 19, the missing mariner, and ghostly testimony around Zona and Mary Jane Hester. Other entries reach into disturbing real-world crimes, missing people, kidnapping, medical exploitation, and family manipulation. The humor is blunt, irreverent, and sometimes abrasive, but it functions as release rather than as distance from the facts. The show is best understood as true crime told across a messy kitchen table, with research notes nearby and no guarantee that anyone will make it through an introduction cleanly. It is not tidy. It is not solemn. It is a rowdy, macabre hangout for listeners who like their case storytelling mixed with friendship, strange side roads, and dark comic whiplash.
Made for: For true crime listeners who like murder cases, disappearances, spooky legends, and mystery episodes delivered with irreverent friend-to-friend energy. It fits people who prefer loose conversational pacing over formal documentary narration.
What sets it apart: The show's edge comes from its whiplash between researched case material and impulsive personal banter. It can cover grim facts, paranormal claims, and strange history while still feeling like an unruly late-night conversation.
A True Crime Podcast where we talk about murder and shenanigans.
A ghost story acquires 'Trouty Mouth'; you came for the mystery and stayed for the heckling.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A grim window shooting and a strange electrical case give the hosts room for dark humor and oddball impressions.
Episode 137 sets a grim window shooting beside the stranger story of Mike "Madman" Markham and his Jacob's ladder work. That pairing gives the review its charge: one half sits with resentment, inheritance, and the image of a fancy house, while the other moves into voltage,…
A loose Halloween chat gives way to a suspicious funeral, a mother's dread, and a ghostly true-crime claim.
Episode 136 starts in a loose October register, with Christina and Amanda moving from skull-mug coffee, birthdays, and a planned break into the story of Zona's death.
A search for Daniel Robinson keeps turning up remains, but not the answer to what happened to him.
Daniel Robinson's disappearance is framed as a search defined by uncertainty: reports of unusual behavior before he vanished, human remains later determined not to be his, and search efforts led by David and McGrath that keep producing questions instead of answers.
A grim Sneed sisters case moves through bedside pressure, loose host banter, and an elephant-shaped comic coda.
Episode 134 stays loose and conversational as Christina and Amanda move from rabbit-teeth jokes into the Sneed sisters story, where Oshi's illness gives the hour its strongest unease. The case turns on Dr.
True crime with cocktails and chaos.
True crime with table-talk bite.
True crime with rough-edged comic detours.
True crime with sharp Scottish banter.
Alphabetized true crime with dark, talky edges.
Christina's Flight 19 story centers on five U.S.
Mike Markham says a Jacob's ladder in Missouri turned into a vortex, made a screw disappear, and later became a brownout story on Art Bell.
Episode 136 of I'm Sorry...What?!
Episode 135 of I'm Sorry...What?!
Episode 134 of I'm Sorry...What?!
The hosts chat about their personal lives and upcoming schedule changes before diving into a true crime case.
The hosts engage in comedic banter before introducing a true crime story.
The hosts engage in humorous banter and discuss a movie before likely transitioning to a true crime case.