Honestly?! A Horrorcast

49 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Horror movies, trivia, trope bingo and constant detours.

The gist

Honestly?! A Horrorcast is Zoë and Logan's season-by-season run through horror films, and season five went from Re-Animator and Society to The Substance and Together. Between bits of song and side tangents, they read out production trivia, tick off trope bingo squares and rank the whole lineup when the season ends.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Honestly?! A Horrorcast

Honestly?! A Horrorcast is Zoë and Logan's running conversation about horror films, organized into numbered seasons, with season five closing on a finale. Episodes start on the word 'Honestly' and a quick roll call, and almost none go straight to the movie. Openers drift into bits of song: a Zoey 101 theme, a guess at whether a tune is Nickelback, a chant about Vans. Real-life interruptions get narrated too. A storm scrapped one recording, an illness hit what they call the Honestly household, and a holiday stretch left them admittedly inconsistent. A passing truck even gets promoted to third co-host. Once the film is on the table, the show turns into a trivia binge. Season five covered Videodrome, Re-Animator, Society, Tusk, The Substance and Together, and each gets its own stack of production lore. For Re-Animator, the effects department went through 24 gallons of fake blood, on a shoot where the makeup effects artist had never used more than two. Tusk brings casting and crew stories: Quentin Tarantino passing on a role, and Greg Nicotero turning down the walrus suit because of The Walking Dead before recommending Robert Kurtzman. For Together, the standout fact is that Dave Franco and Alison Brie spent hours in a prosthetic that merged their arms, bathroom breaks included. The Substance gets a references round, from the sleazy producer named after Harvey Weinstein to Demi Moore describing the film as a blend of Death Becomes Her, a Jane Fonda workout video and The Picture of Dorian Gray. The structure is loose but easy to recognize. Fun facts are sometimes sorted into categories such as special effects, alternate versions and foreshadowing. Goofs and gaffes get their own airing, and Society is held against a trope bingo card with squares like a gaslit character and someone calling out into the dark. The pair clearly prize practical effects, and their loudest praise goes to scenes that are proudly over the top. Teasing is part of the texture, down to one of them threatening to withhold the fun facts entirely. The finale wraps the season with a full ranking, The Substance first and Society last, and they point out that Re-Animator, their second film of the season, finished second. Past seasons come up in passing, with mentions of having covered Saw X and Final Destination Bloodlines. Sign-offs rarely vary: leave a written review, send a screenshot and get limited-edition, season-specific stickers in return, with merchandise on offer too. For a first listen, the finale works as a map, since it walks back through the whole season in ranked order.

Made for: Suits a listener who wants horror talk as a relaxed hangout, with production trivia and trope-spotting mixed into plenty of silliness. It fits anyone happy to follow a season's slate of films, from Re-Animator to The Substance.

What sets it apart: What separates it is the structure under the jokes: numbered seasons of films, fun facts sorted into categories, a trope bingo card and a finale that ranks the whole slate. All of it comes from two voices that break into song without warning.

In their own words

A biweekly horrorcast hosted by Zoë and Logan where they dissect and discuss the horror genre in all its gory glory. Tune in each season as they explore a curated collection of frightening flicks all linked by a common theme or franchise. Think “Let’s Get Sickening” (illness-based horror), “Send In The Clowns” (movies featuring killer clowns), or “I Want To Play A Game” (a deep dive into the Saw franchise).In each episode, Zoë and Logan breakdown the plot, the tropes, and the moments that make them go, “Honestly?!”Join them every other Friday as they unpack the good, the bad, and the so-bad-it’s-good.

Why you'd press play

Final Destination bingo gives your most pedantic horror opinions somewhere to go.

Press play if you want

  • to play along with Zoe and Logan's bingo cards, then contest what earns a square
  • to hear the goofs and gaffs behind an absurd death get the scrutiny they deserve
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
horror film breakdownsbehind-the-scenes fun factspractical effects and fake bloodtrope bingogoofs and referencesend-of-season rankingssong-filled tangentsreview-for-stickers sign-off

Talks about

Best episodes of Honestly?! A Horrorcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

S5: Episode #7 - Season Five FinaleFeb 27, 2026

A loose season wrap-up where rankings, mock awards, weather delays, vertigo, and "juxtaposition" all get their moment.

Honestly?! closes the season with a relaxed, affectionate wrap-up built around Zoe and Logan revisiting their rankings before handing out the Honestly Awards for the films, characters, and moments they covered.

S5: Episode #4 - Tusk (2014)Jan 9, 2026

A chaotic return lets Tusk's production trivia take over the night.

Honestly comes back from its holiday-season lull with Tusk (2014), and the episode keeps the same loose, unruly energy as the hosts' return. Zoey and Logan interrupt their own runway, drift into a Zoey 101 theme-song detour, and even make room for a passing truck before easing…

S5: Episode #3 - Society (1989)Dec 12, 2025

Zoe and Logan turn shunting, horror tropes, and continuity errors into an easygoing near-bingo return.

After a brief hiatus, Zoe and Logan settle back into their horror podcast with a relaxed bingo-card pass through the movie's secret society, shunting, family twist, gaslighting, and adjusted horror-callout beats.

Podcasts like Honestly?! A Horrorcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    S5: Episode #7 - Season Five Finale

    Zoe and Logan close Honestly?!

    Feb 27, 2026·1h 23m·5 clips
  2. 2

    S5: Episode #6 - Together (2025)

    Zoe and Logan on Honestly?!

    Feb 6, 2026·1h 7m·4 clips
  3. 3

    S5: Episode #5 - The Substance (2024)

    Zoe and Logan review Coralie Fargeat's The Substance (2024), a body-horror film centered on Elizabeth Sparkle, Harvey, Sue, and Monstro Eliza Sue.

    Jan 23, 2026·56m·4 clips
  4. 4

    S5: Episode #4 - Tusk (2014)

    Hidden gem

    ["Honestly?!

    Jan 9, 2026·1h 3m·4 clips
  5. 5

    S5: Episode #3 - Society (1989)

    Hidden gem

    Honestly?!

    Dec 12, 2025·56m·4 clips
  6. 6

    S5: Episode #2 - Re-Animator (1985)

    Zoe and Logan examine Re-Animator (1985), a cult American horror comedy loosely inspired by H.P.

    Nov 21, 2025·1h·4 clips
  7. 7

    S5: Episode #1 - Videodrome (1983)

    Honestly?!

    Nov 7, 2025·1h 2m·4 clips
  8. 8

    S4: Episode #7 - Season Four Finale

    Aug 15, 2025·2h 9m
  9. 9

    S4: Episode #6 - Final Destination: Bloodlines (2025)

    Honestly?!

    Aug 1, 2025·1h 28m·5 clips
  10. 10

    S4: Episode #5 - Final Destination 5 (2011)

    Zoe and Logan review Honestly?!

    Jul 18, 2025·1h 21m·5 clips
  11. 11

    S4: Episode #4 - The Final Destination (2009)

    Zoe and Logan review The Final Destination (2009), also called Final Destination 4 and Final Destination 3D, focusing on Nick O’Bannon’s racetrack premonition.

    Jul 4, 2025·1h 15m·5 clips
  12. 12

    S4: Episode #3 - Final Destination 3 (2006)

    Jun 13, 2025·1h 20m
  13. 13

    S4: Episode #2 - Final Destination 2 (2003)

    May 30, 2025·1h 24m
  14. 14

    S4: Episode #1 - Final Destination (2000)

    May 16, 2025·1h 14m
  15. 15

    S3: Episode #7 - Season Three Finale

    Mar 13, 2025·1h 15m
  16. 16

    S3: Episode #6 - Lisa Frankenstein (2024)

    Feb 27, 2025·1h 11m
  17. 17

    S3: Episode #5 - American Mary (2012)

    Feb 14, 2025·1h 25m
  18. 18

    S3: Episode #4 - Jennifer's Body (2009)

    Jan 31, 2025·1h 15m
  19. 19

    S3: Episode #3 - Teeth (2007)

    Jan 10, 2025·1h 12m
  20. 20

    S3: Episode #2 - Ginger Snaps (2000)

    Dec 26, 2024·1h 12m
  21. 21

    S3: Episode #1 - Audition (1999)

    Dec 12, 2024·1h 20m
  22. 22

    S2: Episode #7 - Season Two Finale

    Sep 13, 2024·1h 26m
  23. 23

    S2: Episode #6 - They/Them (2022)

    Aug 30, 2024·1h 21m
  24. 24

    S2: Episode #5 - Fear Street Part Two: 1978 (2021)

    Aug 16, 2024·1h 27m
  25. 25

    S2: Episode #4 - The Final Girls (2015)

    Aug 2, 2024·1h 7m
  26. 26

    S2: Episode #3 - Sleepaway Camp (1983)

    Jul 19, 2024·1h 10m
  27. 27

    S2: Episode #2 - The Burning (1981)

    Jul 5, 2024·1h 11m
  28. 28

    S2: Episode #1 - Friday the 13th (1980)

    Jun 21, 2024·1h 11m
  29. 29

    Episode #11 - Season One Finale

    Apr 5, 2024·1h 19m
  30. 30

    Episode #10 - Saw X (2023)

    Mar 22, 2024·1h 22m
  31. 31

    Episode #9 - Spiral (2021)

    Mar 8, 2024·1h 18m
  32. 32

    Episode #8 - Jigsaw (2017)

    Feb 23, 2024·1h 34m
  33. 33

    Episode #7 - Saw 3D (2010)

    Feb 9, 2024·1h 32m
  34. 34

    Episode #6 - Saw VI (2009)

    Jan 26, 2024·1h 24m
  35. 35

    Episode #5 - Saw V (2008)

    Jan 12, 2024·1h 27m
  36. 36

    Episode #4 - Saw IV (2007)

    Dec 29, 2023·1h 34m
  37. 37

    Episode #3 - Saw III (2006)

    Zoë and Logan discuss the Saw franchise, focusing on the third installment, Saw 3, and share their excitement about the series.

    Dec 15, 2023·1h 26m
  38. 38

    Episode #2 - Saw II (2005)

    Zoe and Logan discuss the plot and tropes of Saw II in their horror movie analysis podcast.

    Dec 1, 2023·1h 22m
  39. 39

    Episode #1 - Saw (2004)

    Nov 17, 2023·1h 35m
  40. 40

    Episode #225 - Fan Exposé

    Sep 1, 2023·1h 12m
  41. 41

    Episode #224 - A-Goo!

    Mar 17, 2023·1h 10m
  42. 42

    Episode #223 - We Found Tubi In A Hopeless Place

    Mar 3, 2023·1h 23m
  43. 43

    Episode #222 - XXX-Mas: Christmas Came

    Dec 9, 2022·1h 14m
  44. 44

    Episode #221 - WhatsApp: The Documentary

    Nov 25, 2022·59m
  45. 45

    Episode #220 - The Crossover Event Of The Season

    Nov 11, 2022·1h 13m
  46. 46

    Episode #219 - It's An Oven, Rodg!

    Oct 28, 2022·1h 6m
  47. 47

    Episode #218 - Tender Uncle Wayne

    Sep 9, 2022·1h 12m
  48. 48

    Episode #217 - Boo Boo In Garters

    Aug 5, 2022·1h 23m
  49. 49

    Episode #216 - He's Just Some Guy(Derogatory)

    Jul 22, 2022·1h 21m