Help Me Hayley: Cold Case Files

NonStop Local

57 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

In their own words

When she isn't anchoring weekend newscasts, NonStop Local's Hayley Guenthner produces investigative pieces and covers crime all over the Inland Northwest. Help Me Hayley: Cold Case Files podcast reveals some of Spokane's most notorious, if not forgotten, crime cases.

Why you'd press play

One Jane Doe sketch looks painfully familiar to a daughter; you'll want to hear what she found.

Press play if you want

  • to notice the details a family can't dismiss, like tools left neatly in another room
  • to hear how forensic genetic genealogy gave investigators a lead after years with DNA
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Talks about

Best episodes of Help Me Hayley: Cold Case Files

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

The Little WitnessApr 4, 2022

Suzanne Timms connects a childhood memory of Patty Otto's disappearance to a Jane Doe rendering.

This single-episode review centers on Suzanne Timms, who has long carried a childhood memory of her mother, Patty Otto, disappearing after a violent fight at home in Lewiston, Idaho.

Like a PuzzleMar 21, 2022

A long-stalled Palouse case advances through forensic genetic genealogy.

Haley Gunther follows the Palouse home invasions and sexual assaults that unsettled the community from November 2003 to March 2004, then tracks the long stretch of stalled leads that followed.

SOLVED: The Campfire GirlNov 22, 2021

A decades-old Spokane murder is resolved through DNA, exhumation, and persistent detective work.

A 62-year-old homicide case finally arrives at an answer as investigators identify John Ray Hoff as the killer of nine-year-old Candy Rogers, who was kidnapped, sexually assaulted, and murdered in March 1959.

Red FlagsNov 16, 2021

Moved tools, a troubling text, and a family still waiting for answers shape Guy Geyer's case.

Guy Geyer's disappearance is framed through the small details that made his family's concern hard to shake: an unfinished remodel, valuable tools gathered neatly in a back bedroom, and a truck that turned up days later.

Missing AngelSep 20, 2021

A careful missing-person episode centered on a father's grief, a friend's enduring hope, and a case still waiting for a solid tip.

Angel Dawn Wilson vanished from Spokane in August 2007 at age 17, and this single episode stays close to the personal weight of a case without a confirmed ending.

The Blue 10-Speed PART 2Jul 27, 2021

Kristen's 1981 murder remains defined by a missing bicycle, one witness account, and unanswered questions.

The Blue 10-Speed Part 2 stays with Kristen, a 22-year-old University of Idaho senior last seen riding her blue 10-speed on U.S. Highway 95 from Moscow to Lewiston in June 1981.

Melinda's Message

A careful account of a stalled missing-person case, shaped by grief and a direct call for answers.

This piece keeps its focus on Melinda Lopez's disappearance in Newport, Washington, and that focus helps. The family grief comes through plainly, and the stalled state of the case gives the story real weight without leaning on decoration or overstatement.

Forever 16

A patient cold-case hour that gives equal weight to remembrance and investigation.

This episode treats the 1978 killing of 16-year-old Chrisanne Baxter as both a case and a life worth remembering. It gives Chrisanne Baxter room to feel real through family and friend memories before moving into the detective work that, after 45 years, led investigators to…

Podcasts like Help Me Hayley: Cold Case Files

  • Bear BrookNHPR

    NHPR's Jason Moon investigates the Bear Brook barrel murders and a New Hampshire wrongful-conviction case.

  • Up and VanishedTenderfoot TV

    Cold cases worked in plain view, from Nome outward.

  • Missing & MurderedCBC

    Unanswered loss, family histories and the pursuit of accountability.

  • The Lady VanishesLiSTNR

    A daughter, a coroner, and a long-unanswered disappearance.

  • The Coldest Case in LaramieSerial Productions & The New York Times

    A former cop's DNA, a dropped case, unreliable memories.

  • Kuper IslandCBC

    A school's history, carried in survivors' lives.

Episodes

  1. 1

    On the 12th Floor

    Hidden gem

    This episode investigates the 1973 cold case murder of 25-year-old Archie Gonia, who was beaten and strangled in the Davenport Hotel in Spokane.

    ·13m·1 clip
  2. 2

    Murder at 9th and Lincoln | Cold Case Files | Episode 2

    ·16m
  3. 3

    Downtown Alley Murder | Cold Case Files | Episode 1

    ·14m
  4. 4

    The Disappearance of Chris Jennings | Cold Case Files | Episode 3

    ·15m
  5. 5

    Forever 16

    This episode of Help Me Hayley investigates the 1978 cold case murder of 16-year-old Chrisanne Baxter.

    ·16m·1 clip
  6. 6

    Danielle Shinaver: 30 Years Later | Cold Case Files | Episode 2

    Hidden gem

    This episode investigates the 1996 cold case murder of 25-year-old Danielle Schenever, who was brutally beaten to death in her Spokane apartment.

    ·16m·1 clip
  7. 7

    The Disappearance of Chris Jennings | Cold Case Files | Episode 3

    This episode investigates the 1980 disappearance of 16-year-old Chris Jennings from the Kootenai County Fairgrounds in Idaho.

    ·15m·1 clip
  8. 8

    The Nurse

    This episode investigates the 1981 disappearance of 24-year-old nurse Kathy Rae Gregory in Spokane, Washington.

    ·16m·1 clip
  9. 9

    Downtown Alley Murder | Cold Case Files | Episode 1

    Hidden gem

    This episode investigates the 1997 murder of Margaret Ansemmo in Spokane, Washington, a case initially overshadowed by a serial killer investigation.

    ·14m·1 clip
  10. 10

    Melinda's Message

    This episode investigates the disappearance of Melinda Lopez from Newport, Washington, who vanished in November 2020 after sending distressed messages.

    ·18m·1 clip
  11. 11

    Her Name is Ruth

    This episode details the 39-year investigation into the murder of Ruth Bell Wehmeyer, a Jane Doe found dismembered in the Spokane River in 1984.

    ·13m·1 clip
  12. 12

    The White Purse

    Jul 11, 2022·14m
  13. 13

    The Little Witness

    Hidden gem

    Help Me Hayley: Cold Case Files examines Patty Otto’s 1976 disappearance from Lewiston, Idaho, through the memories of her three-year-old daughter, Suzanne Timms.

    Apr 4, 2022·26m·1 clip
  14. 14

    Like a Puzzle

    Haley Gunther reports on Pullman home invasions and sexual assaults that occurred near Pioneer Hill between November 2003 and March 2004.

    Mar 21, 2022·26m·1 clip
  15. 15

    Jane Doe 19

    Hidden gem

    Help Me Hayley: Cold Case Files examines Deanna Criswell’s case after her murdered body was found in Tucson in 1987.

    Feb 12, 2022·21m·1 clip
  16. 16

    SOLVED: The Campfire Girl

    Haley Gunthner revisits the 1959 kidnapping, sexual assault, and murder of nine-year-old Candace Rogers, a case Spokane investigators worked for 62 years.

    Nov 22, 2021·30m·2 clips
  17. 17

    Red Flags

    Amanda Geyer describes Guy's unlocked work site, abandoned truck, missing keys, and every tool moved into another room.

    Nov 16, 2021·22m·1 clip
  18. 18

    Missing Angel

    Angel Dawn Wilson disappeared from Spokane, Washington, in August 2007 at age 17, and no confirmed contact followed.

    Sep 20, 2021·23m·1 clip
  19. 19

    The Blue 10-Speed PART 2

    Help Me Hayley: Cold Case Files returns to Kristen Davids, a 22-year-old University of Idaho senior last seen biking from Moscow to Lewiston on June 26, 1981.

    Jul 27, 2021·42m·2 clips
  20. 20

    The Blue 10-Speed

    Jun 29, 2021·14m
  21. 21

    Twisted

    Jun 17, 2021·12m
  22. 22

    The Hanging on Tubbs Hill

    Jun 9, 2021·23m
  23. 23

    Rage at the Rodeway

    May 5, 2021·25m
  24. 24

    The Good Fight

    Mar 23, 2021·23m
  25. 25

    The Deadly Getaway

    Feb 10, 2021·21m
  26. 26

    The Missing

    Jan 6, 2021·23m
  27. 27

    Five More Minutes

    Dec 3, 2020·24m
  28. 28

    The Last Block: SOLVED

    Oct 26, 2020·23m
  29. 29

    A Mystery in the Mountains

    Oct 12, 2020·15m
  30. 30

    Dying Words

    Sep 21, 2020·24m
  31. 31

    A Secret to the Grave

    Aug 17, 2020·29m
  32. 32

    Murder on Main Street

    Aug 4, 2020·19m
  33. 33

    Nothing Good Happens after Midnight

    Apr 14, 2020·18m
  34. 34

    How can dumping a murdered body be a misdemeanor?

    Mar 2, 2020·27m
  35. 35

    The House on Heroy

    Jan 29, 2020·16m
  36. 36

    Murder, Love and Money

    Jan 23, 2020·19m
  37. 37

    The Devil's in the Details

    Nov 14, 2019·18m
  38. 38

    The Yates Effect

    Oct 21, 2019·16m
  39. 39

    The Evidence Room

    Sep 23, 2019·12m
  40. 40

    Off Ramsey Road

    Aug 28, 2019·17m
  41. 41

    Into the Woods

    Jul 15, 2019·21m
  42. 42

    The Note

    Jun 14, 2019·21m
  43. 43

    The Last Block

    May 17, 2019·14m
  44. 44

    The Girl in the Lilac Dress

    Mar 27, 2019·11m
  45. 45

    Where is the Justice?

    Mar 5, 2019·20m
  46. 46

    Overkill

    Feb 22, 2019·15m
  47. 47

    Closing Time

    Feb 9, 2019·10m
  48. 48

    An Open Window

    Feb 1, 2019·16m
  49. 49

    Unrecognizable

    Jan 25, 2019·7m
  50. 50

    Almost Home

    Jan 11, 2019·22m
  51. 51

    Vanished

    Nov 19, 2018·21m
  52. 52

    Somebody was watching

    Nov 12, 2018·17m
  53. 53

    Stabbed in the Heart

    Nov 5, 2018·9m
  54. 54

    The Campfire Girl

    Oct 29, 2018·11m
  55. 55

    While She Was Sleeping

    Oct 10, 2018·19m
  56. 56

    The Missing Wedding Guest

    Sep 21, 2018·17m
  57. 57

    The Dark Dream

    Sep 7, 2018·11m