Forgive Me!

50 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

A new priest, one confession at a time.

The gist

Forgive Me! is scripted fiction built on confession: Father Ben, a young priest trying a little too hard, hears one eccentric parishioner after another at St. Patrick's in a made-up Texarkana, NY. The feed also carries trailers for other audio dramas from the Fable & Folly Network.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Forgive Me!

Forgive Me! is scripted audio fiction built around the confessional. Father Ben is the priest listening there. He is young, Catholic, and trying a little too hard. He has been moved from Binghamton to St. Patrick's, a parish in a fictional Texarkana, NY, and the reasons for the move are kept murky. That leaves him new in town, in a job where people come to him to tell him things. Each parishioner who steps in is another eccentric local. Their lives are tangled together, so the town comes into focus one admission at a time. The show is filed under comedy drama, and the premise covers both halves: funny moments, sad ones, and some that are plainly painful, all rooted in Catholic life. It is a format built for character studies. Forgive Me! belongs to the Fable & Folly Network, whose on-air slogan is about fiction producers flourishing. Recent entries in the feed include several episodes labelled 'Presenting', each one a trailer for another show rather than a new confession. 'Presenting: UN-TITLED' introduces a scripted comedy that retells the sword-in-the-stone myth from the view of the people left standing around while it happens, and its clip features a squire who says he dabbles in acting. 'Presenting: Re:Dracula' pitches a full-cast, text-accurate adaptation of Dracula that publishes episodes as close to real time as the story's events allow. 'Presenting: Not Quite Dead' promotes a mostly single-narrator horror romance about walking corpses, vampires and the pull between Alfie and Casper, with an excerpt set in an A&E department at York Hospital. 'Presenting: Remnants' comes from Hanging Sloth Productions: an apprentice, supervised by a figure called Sir, reads the life stories held in ordinary objects like a broken pocket watch or a silk scarf, then has to decide whether to shelve or discard them. 'Presenting: Moonburn', from August Year Round Productions, sets up an 18-year-old named Lucas moving into a New York City boarding home, where he finds diary cassette tapes left decades earlier by a former occupant, Carter. There is also an episode titled 'Forgive Apollyon! A Crossover'. Taken together, the trailers make the feed a sampler of audio fiction, from horror romance to young adult slice-of-life. Anyone who came for Father Ben should know those trailers are not part of his story. What sets Forgive Me! apart is its narrow frame: one priest, one confessional, one town, and a steady line of people with something to admit.

Made for: Suits a listener who enjoys scripted audio fiction built from character sketches, and who likes comedy that can turn sad or painful, especially around faith and Catholic parish life.

What sets it apart: Instead of following a single plot line, it uses the confessional as a revolving door: each parishioner is a new voice, and the connections between them surface through what they admit to a newly arrived priest.

In their own words

Forgive Me! tells the story of Father Ben, a try-hard young Catholic priest who was recently reassigned from Binghamton to St. Patrick’s, a new parish in the fictional Texarkana, NY, under mysterious circumstances. Each episode follows Ben into the confessional with another eccentric parishioner from around town, exploring the intertwined lives of this new community and the funny, sad, and sometimes painful experiences that come out of the Catholic experience.

Why you'd press play

A vampire and a man in a dragon costume audition for your next fiction fixation.

Press play if you want

  • to try a full-cast Dracula adaptation before committing to another Gothic rabbit hole
  • to hear a squire patch a plot hole with a dragon costume
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Catholic parish lifeConfessionSmall-town eccentricsA young priest's new assignmentIntertwined lives of a communityFable & Folly Network fiction trailers

Talks about

Best episodes of Forgive Me!

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Presenting: UN-TITLEDNov 30, 2025

A borrowed dragon costume, a wooden sword, and a squire's shaky reach for heroic relevance.

Presenting: UN-TITLED turns a rescue story into a comic scramble for relevance. Phelan the Squire shows up with a wooden sword, a borrowed dragon costume, and a plan that keeps running into hunger, theatrical ego, and the messy work of building a legend from the edge of the…

Presenting: Re:DraculaOct 26, 2025

A night coach ride becomes a full-cast descent into gathering dread.

Presenting: Re:Dracula sends a traveler into an uneasy night ride under the count's instructions, where the road feels less like a route than a trap.

Presenting: Not Quite DeadOct 12, 2025

An intimate horror romance where an obituary, a hospital shift, and measured blood point Alfie toward transformation.

Presenting: Not Quite Dead begins with Alfie trying to write his own obituary, a bleak assignment made awkward enough to keep the horror close to the skin.

Presenting: RemnantsSep 28, 2025

A dark fantasy thriller turns ordinary objects into intimate moral tests for an apprentice still learning the cost.

Remnants builds a dark fantasy thriller around a simple, resonant hook: a mysterious apprentice can read the lives held inside ordinary objects.

Presenting: MoonburnSep 14, 2025

A queer coming-of-age welcome turns uncanny when Lucas's new room becomes the route to a boarding home's roof.

Moonburn opens as a young adult queer slice-of-life story about Lucas, an 18-year-old trying to begin again in a New York City boarding home. His new room comes with more baggage than expected: after an awkward, bloodied first meeting with Caleb, he finds out the housemates pass…

Podcasts like Forgive Me!

  • Decoder Ring TheatreDecoder Ring Theatre

    Serialized pulp radio drama: Red Panda battles android-army supervillain Captain Clockwork in 1930s Toronto.

  • The New Yorker: FictionThe New Yorker

    One writer, one archive story, read and then examined.

  • Light HouseiHeartPodcasts

    A haunted family home, remembered chapter by dated chapter.

  • The Evolution of HorrorMike Muncer

    The ideas and craft behind the scares

  • Horror QueersBloody FM

    Horror's pleasures, politics and plot holes.

  • Radio RentalTenderfoot TV & Audacy

    Creepy tapes from a very strange shelf.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Presenting: UN-TITLED

    Hidden gem

    Marcus Aurelius turns up as a prop in a sword-in-the-stone farce about a middle-aged squire.

    Nov 30, 2025·31m·2 clips
  2. 2

    Presenting: Re:Dracula

    Hidden gem

    Fable & Folly Network presents Re:Dracula as a "text-accurate adaptation" of Bram Stoker's Dracula, released chronologically and "as close to real time as possible." The episode features Ben Galpin as Jonathan Harker, Karim Kronfli as Dracula, and Steven Andresano directing, with sound design by Tal Maneer.

    Oct 26, 2025·41m·2 clips
  3. 3

    Presenting: Not Quite Dead

    Hidden gem

    Not Quite Dead's pilot, Presenting: Not Quite Dead, follows Alfie, an A&E nurse in York, as he explains a night that starts with torn throats and ends with a blood supply running low.

    Oct 12, 2025·25m·1 clip
  4. 4

    Presenting: Remnants

    Hidden gem

    Celine says, "Reality is all about believing" after explaining why her clients think Monet and Renoir are real.

    Sep 28, 2025·31m·2 clips
  5. 5

    Presenting: Moonburn

    Hidden gem

    Carter says, "after this one year, these recordings will be all that's left of me."

    Sep 14, 2025·32m·2 clips
  6. 6

    Forgive Root (Windfall Crossover Republish)

    In this Forgive Me and Windfall crossover, Father Ben hears Captain Octavius Root explain how he helped frame his father for rebuilding a shrine to Medina.

    May 11, 2025·29m·2 clips
  7. 7

    Easter 2025 Special: High Holiday

    Apr 20, 2025·10m
  8. 8

    Presenting: How I Died

    In How I Died, coroner John Spacer hears Maggie Lane speak during her autopsy in Springfield.

    Apr 13, 2025·29m·2 clips
  9. 9

    The Pranking Priests of St. Patricks (April Fools' Special)

    Apr 1, 2025·9m
  10. 10

    Presenting: Waiting for October

    Mar 9, 2025·20m
  11. 11

    Presenting: Alpha 8

    Feb 9, 2025·53m
  12. 12

    Presenting: Candy Claus, Private Eye

    Dec 22, 2024·29m
  13. 13

    A Christmas Clara

    Dec 8, 2024·26m
  14. 14

    Thanksgiving With the Colony

    Nov 17, 2024·20m
  15. 15

    Where Angels Fear to Tread

    Oct 13, 2024·18m
  16. 16

    Crossover: Forgive Arden - The Pranked Priests of St. Patrick's

    Sep 29, 2024·25m
  17. 17

    Forgive Apollyon! A Crossover

    A fictional podcast following a young priest as he hears confessions from eccentric parishioners, blending humor and heartfelt moments.

    Aug 4, 2024·23m
  18. 18

    Forgive Me! St. Kilda: A Crossover

    Jul 7, 2024·20m
  19. 19

    Confessions By Usher Pt. 2

    May 31, 2024·15m
  20. 20

    Arbor Day Special: It's Turtles All the Way Down

    Apr 26, 2024·15m
  21. 21

    St. Patrick's St. Patrick's Day Special - Oops, All Snakes!

    Mar 17, 2024·23m
  22. 22

    One of the Dogs (LIVE SHOW!)

    Feb 18, 2024·45m
  23. 23

    Forgive Colette: The Kingmaker Histories Crossover

    Nov 26, 2023·20m
  24. 24

    3.13 || Anything Interesting?

    Nov 5, 2023·32m
  25. 25

    3.12 || Closing the Case

    Oct 15, 2023·30m
  26. 26

    3.11 || The Plot Thickens

    Oct 1, 2023·29m
  27. 27

    3.10 || Mental Gymnastics

    Sep 17, 2023·35m
  28. 28

    3.09 || Señor Mystery

    Sep 3, 2023·30m
  29. 29

    Confessions With Klem: Forgive the Freemasons

    Aug 27, 2023·18m
  30. 30

    3.08 || Free David

    Aug 20, 2023·35m
  31. 31

    3.07 || To Be a Feral Cat Feeder

    Aug 6, 2023·31m
  32. 32

    Forgive Where the Stars Fell?

    Jul 9, 2023·30m
  33. 33

    3.06 || Putting the You in Rules

    Jun 25, 2023·30m
  34. 34

    3.05 || Pre-Cana Counseling

    Jun 4, 2023·27m
  35. 35

    3.04 || In Pursuit of Truth & Justice

    May 21, 2023·33m
  36. 36

    3.03 || Praying the Rosary

    May 7, 2023·29m
  37. 37

    3.02 || Have a Great Vigil

    Apr 23, 2023·32m
  38. 38

    3.01 || (Another) Disaster at the Donut Festival

    Apr 9, 2023·28m
  39. 39

    Forgive Me! Season 3 IndieGoGo Announcement

    Mar 2, 2023·6m
  40. 40

    Thanksgiving With the Moynahan's

    A priest visits his mother for Thanksgiving dinner, leading to family tension and a discussion about his brother's absence.

    Nov 24, 2022·24m
  41. 41

    Hallow Be Thy Name

    Oct 31, 2022·33m
  42. 42

    You Can't Eat a Shoe

    Sep 5, 2022·19m
  43. 43

    Forgive Me Away (Crossover with Give Me Away)

    Father Ben awkwardly begins his first confession session with a new parishioner, revealing the show's comedic and dramatic take on Catholic life.

    Aug 28, 2022·40m
  44. 44

    Forgive Red Line Pt. 2 (Greater Boston Crossover Special!)

    Jul 26, 2022·40m
  45. 45

    Forgive Red Line Pt. 1 (Greater Boston Crossover Special!)

    Jul 19, 2022·40m
  46. 46

    Announcing: Forgive Red Line!

    Jul 12, 2022·4m
  47. 47

    Forgive The Vanishing Act!

    Jun 26, 2022·40m
  48. 48

    An Update, a Crossover Announcement, and The Vanishing Act!

    Jun 22, 2022·5m
  49. 49

    Creator's Roundtable

    May 22, 2022·40m
  50. 50

    The Other Rabbit (Easter Special!)

    Apr 17, 2022·29m