Horror Queers is primarily a co-hosted panel format, with Joe Lipsett and Trace Thurman working through one horror film per main episode, supplemented by a lighter 'Micro Queers' segment that covers shorter, often campier or lower-profile titles. The hosts move between decades-old genre staples (The Mummy, 1932) and current releases (28 Years Later, Anaconda 2025), treating both with the same mix of close reading and casual, joke-heavy banter. A consistent thread across episodes is queer subtext: characters, imagery, or production choices that read as coded or explicit queerness, even when a film doesn't foreground it. The hosts also track industry mechanics — MPAA censorship decisions, studio rights history, box office performance, and franchise/reboot logic — as part of how they evaluate a film. Less frequently, the show shifts to an interview format, bringing on filmmakers (directors, screenwriters) to discuss a specific project's queer content, censorship fights, or thematic intent, as with the Faces of Death conversation with Daniel Goldhaber and Isa Mazzei. Episodes often end with a numeric or comparative verdict on the film, including explicit 'so bad it's good' recommendations for streaming-friendly titles. The tone ranges from serious film-historical analysis (makeup process, screenwriter background, casting) to comedic takedowns of weak scripts and lazy franchise cash-ins. Listeners who enjoy genre film podcasts, classic monster movie history, or queer media criticism are the core audience. Episode lengths vary widely, from short Micro Queers entries under 30 minutes to full panel or interview episodes running 80+ minutes. Guests are drawn from the film industry (directors, screenwriters) rather than academics or unrelated celebrities.