For Fawkes’ Sake: A Harry Potter Podcast

149 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Harry Potter adaptation arguments with teeth.

The gist

For Fawkes’ Sake is a Harry Potter book-to-movie comparison show built around chapter-by-chapter discussion. Recent episodes track Grimmauld Place, Creature’s story, Lupin’s crisis, Ministry propaganda, and the ways film choices sharpen or flatten the books.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About For Fawkes’ Sake: A Harry Potter Podcast

For Fawkes’ Sake is a Harry Potter book-and-film comparison show with a chapter-by-chapter spine. It is built for listeners who know the story well enough to care about what gets changed. Recent episodes cover the late-series stretch around the wedding fallout, Grimmauld Place, Creature’s Tale, the Bribe, and Magic is Might. The show moves quickly from recap into judgment. A “Phoenix flashback” sets the table, then the speakers weigh book scenes against movie scenes, including the places where the film offers only a partial match. Small differences matter here. The Hogwarts Express, the Ministry fountain, Dumbledore’s study, a missing headline, or a shifted dream vision can become evidence in a larger argument about adaptation. The commentary is funny and openly irritated. It can praise a performance one minute and complain about a shortcut the next. Character psychology gets real attention, especially when Harry confronts Lupin, Hermione reacts to Snape’s appointment, or Ron quietly understands something about elf magic before Harry does. Creature’s story becomes more than lore; it becomes a test of how Voldemort underestimates house-elf magic and how the film handles tragedy. The Daily Prophet and Ministry material bring out the show’s interest in propaganda, fear, cowardice, and compromised institutions. Dumbledore’s reputation is treated as messy rather than sacred. So are Harry’s choices. The speakers are comfortable calling out behavior they find foolish, cruel, evasive, or cowardly. They also enjoy the odd comedy of wizard phrases, potatoes, “murder munchers,” and scenes that are almost, but not quite, the same. The pacing has the feel of a conversation with notes in front of it. It is not detached criticism. It is detailed, opinionated rereading from people who still find joy in the material while refusing to let beloved scenes off the hook.

Made for: For readers and viewers who know Harry Potter well and enjoy detailed book-to-film comparison, character debate, and blunt criticism. It best suits listeners comfortable with spoilers and a conversational, sometimes sharp register.

What sets it apart: The show focuses on tiny adaptation choices and lets them carry real weight, from omitted context to actor performance to the emotional logic of a scene. Its rhythm mixes recap, close reading, comedy, and visible frustration rather than clean nostalgic praise.

In their own words

We are For Fawkes’ Sake, a Harry Potter book/movie compare and contrast podcast. We will be re-reading through the book series, re-watching the movies, and chapter by chapter comparing and contrasting the books to the corresponding (or lack thereof) parts of the movies. In addition to this, we will be be combining our knowledge of Harry Potter, writing, and filmmaking to further each episodes discussions!

As heard by us

Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Ellen and Abigail make Harry Potter adaptation choices visible by testing film scenes against the books' character logic and descriptive detail.

For Fawkes' Sake turns Harry Potter adaptation into close textual argument. Ellen and Abigail move through the books in chapter-sized sections, matching scenes to their screen counterparts and giving equal attention to what the films preserve, alter, or omit.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Harry Potter's missing movie scenes go on trial, and you get Ellen and Abigail's evidence.

Press play if you want

  • to examine every adaptation shortcut closely enough to catch what the film quietly abandoned
  • Ellen and Abigail turning character choices and magical loopholes into lively, occasionally profane debate
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Harry Potter book-to-film comparisonchapter-by-chapter rereadsGrimmauld Place scenesCreature and RegulusLupin’s attempted departureMinistry and Daily Prophet propagandaDumbledore family revelationsfilm omissions and scene changes

Talks about

Best episodes of For Fawkes’ Sake: A Harry Potter Podcast

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

Ep. 278 - Mostly BadApr 17, 2026

Ellen and Abigail bring humor and concern to Snape's appointment at Hogwarts and its effect on the students.

Snape's appointment at Hogwarts sets Ellen and Abigail talking about who might stay at the school. Ron doubts McGonagall, Flitwick, and Sprout will accept it. Harry thinks they may have little choice, and that staying would let them protect the students.

Ep. 270 - Chummy With KrummyFeb 6, 2026

Luna's sunflower and a gnome bite lead Ellen and Abigail to question the Lovegoods' look on screen.

Ellen and Abigail spend the first half of Chapter 8 with Luna and her father at the wedding. In their account of the book, Luna's bright yellow robes and large sunflower make her hard to miss.

Ep. 267 - Unpermissive ExitingJan 16, 2026

Ellen and Abigail return to Horcrux questions after a candid personal opening.

Ellen and Abigail return to their Harry Potter book and film comparison after time away. Ellen speaks about her mother's death and the break they took, then the pair pick up a question from Ron: if Voldemort could learn how to make a Horcrux from a book, why ask Slughorn about…

Ep. 266 - Wizarding Witness ProtectionOct 25, 2025

Ellen and Abigail puzzle through what Dumbledore's death means for the Fidelius Charm at Grimmauld Place.

Why does Grimmauld Place become less useful to the Order after Dumbledore's death? Ellen and Abigail work through the Fidelius Charm without pretending its rules are clear.

Podcasts like For Fawkes’ Sake: A Harry Potter Podcast

Episodes

  1. 1

    Ep. 243 - 7 out of 10

    ·46m
  2. 2

    Ep. 276 - The Potatoes Episode

    ·58m
  3. 3

    Ep. 275 - I'm Angry. I'm Disappointed.

    ·51m
  4. 4

    Ep. 274 - Misadventures

    ·48m
  5. 5

    Ep. 273 - Same-ish

    ·44m
  6. 6

    Ep. 272 - I'm Willing to Bet

    ·43m
  7. 7

    Ep. 271 - Quibbler Kool-Aid

    ·50m
  8. 8

    Ep. 270 - Chummy With Krummy

    ·58m
  9. 9

    Ep. 269 - Instinctually, Not Intelligently

    ·55m
  10. 10

    Ep. 268 - Details Schmetails

    ·51m
  11. 11

    Ep. 267 - Unpermissive Exiting

    ·45m
  12. 12

    Ep. 266 - Wizarding Witness Protection

    ·47m
  13. 13

    Ep. 265 - Not A Gryffindor

    ·59m
  14. 14

    Ep. 264 - Harry Potter and the Martyr Syndrome

    ·50m
  15. 15

    Ep. 263 - Tom Tantrum

    ·44m
  16. 16

    Ep. 262 - 6 Harry Frauders

    ·58m
  17. 17

    Ep. 261 - Voldemort Fudd

    ·53m
  18. 18

    Ep. 260 - Dish on Dumbledore

    ·51m
  19. 19

    Ep. 259 - ADHP

    ·45m
  20. 20

    Ep. 258 - Malfoy Mocking

    ·50m
  21. 21

    Ep. 257 - Spot On

    ·48m
  22. 22

    Trailer - Deathly Hallows

    ·1m
  23. 23

    HP and the Epic Universe

    ·1h 10m
  24. 24

    Ep. 256 - Word Dropsies and Addsies

    ·1h 15m
  25. 25

    Ep. 255 - Word Switchies

    ·1h 18m
  26. 26

    Ep. 254 - Snape is Dada

    ·1h 15m
  27. 27

    Ep. 253 - King of Clapback

    ·1h 1m
  28. 28

    Ep. 252 - Literally Unceremoniously

    ·1h 10m
  29. 29

    Ep. 251 - Tearing Up

    ·1h 1m
  30. 30

    Ep. 250 - Big Ball of Chaos

    ·1h 3m
  31. 31

    Ep. 249 - Dead as a Dumbledoornail

    ·54m
  32. 32

    Ep. 248 - Party Time Bellatrix

    ·1h 2m
  33. 33

    Ep. 247 - Cheeky Little Bastards

    ·1h 5m
  34. 34

    Ep. 246 - Smarter Martyr

    ·53m
  35. 35

    Ep. 245 - Dumbledoes

    ·1h 15m
  36. 36

    Ep. 244 - Demons and Kelpies and Sprites, Oh My!

    ·1h 8m
  37. 37

    Ep. 277 - The Dobby Show

    ·54m
  38. 38

    Ep. 242 - You-Know-Who-Tattoo

    ·1h 6m
  39. 39

    Ep. 241 - Attack Him With Love

    ·1h 15m
  40. 40

    Ep. 240 - More Moaning Myrtle

    ·1h 17m
  41. 41

    Ep. 239 - Dumby-dore

    ·1h 1m
  42. 42

    Ep. 238 - WTF Movie

    ·1h 4m
  43. 43

    Ep. 237 - Wet Sarcasm

    ·1h 6m
  44. 44

    Ep. 236 - Ernie's Tasty Dumpling

    ·1h 16m
  45. 45

    Ep. 235 - Oh Roonil Wazlib

    ·1h 5m
  46. 46

    Ep. 234 - Magic Grammarly

    ·1h 7m
  47. 47

    Ep. 233 - Lovely Lady Trinkets

    ·1h 5m
  48. 48

    Ep. 232 - Dumbledore Dungeon Master

    ·1h 26m
  49. 49

    Ep. 231 - Niffler for Knowledge

    ·1h 19m
  50. 50

    Ep. 230 - Eau de Hagrid

    ·1h 21m
  51. 51

    Ep. 229 - Meddling With Malfoy

    ·1h 23m
  52. 52

    Ep. 228 - Harry Level Trauma

    ·1h 10m
  53. 53

    Ep. 227 - Coach Dumbledore

    ·1h 28m
  54. 54

    Ep. 226 - Wizard Cherries

    ·1h 32m
  55. 55

    Ep. 225 - Emotion and Luck

    ·1h 3m
  56. 56

    Ep. 224 - Knife Advice

    ·1h 20m
  57. 57

    Ep. 223 - Meddling Powers Activate!

    ·1h 5m
  58. 58

    Ep. 222 - Drama Drama Drama

    ·1h 20m
  59. 59

    Ep. 221 - Definite Dings

    ·1h 3m
  60. 60

    Ep. 220 - 2 Out of 10

    ·1h 15m
  61. 61

    Ep. 219 - Lemon Water

    ·1h 25m
  62. 62

    Ep. 218 - Youngledore

    ·1h 11m
  63. 63

    Ep. 217 - Dirty Harry

    ·1h 10m
  64. 64

    Ep. 216 - Ron-Com

    ·1h 19m
  65. 65

    Ep. 215 - Am I Confunded Right Now?

    ·57m
  66. 66

    Ep. 214 - Magical Jack*ss

    ·1h 14m
  67. 67

    Ep. 213 - Sassy Ogden

    ·1h 22m
  68. 68

    Ep. 212 - Naked Harry Potter

    ·1h 11m
  69. 69

    Ep. 211 - And...Spit!

    ·1h 8m
  70. 70

    Ep. 210 - World Wide Wizarding Web

    ·1h 14m
  71. 71

    Ep. 209 - Abomi-Snape-tion

    ·1h 13m
  72. 72

    Ep. 208 - Harry in a Hopeless Place

    ·1h 6m
  73. 73

    Ep. 207 - Meddling Bone

    ·1h 20m
  74. 74

    Ep. 206 - Prats and Brats

    ·1h 12m
  75. 75

    Ep. 205 - Love Potion Personified

    ·1h 7m
  76. 76

    Ep. 204 - Move the Plot Forward

    ·1h 19m
  77. 77

    Ep. 203 - Veela Whammy

    ·1h 28m
  78. 78

    Ep. 202 - Dreamus Lupin

    ·1h 13m
  79. 79

    Ep. 201 -Yo, I Gotta Pee!

    ·1h 1m
  80. 80

    Ep. 200 - Magic, Karlee, Magic.

    ·1h 17m
  81. 81

    Ep. 199 - Violent but Silent

    ·54m
  82. 82

    Ep. 198 - Peace Out Yo, Albus Dumbledore

    ·57m
  83. 83

    Ep. 197 - Grasping at Straws

    ·1h 2m
  84. 84

    Ep. 196 - Expla-Snape-tion

    ·1h 11m
  85. 85

    Ep. 195 - Obliviating and Gaslighting

    ·1h 8m
  86. 86

    Ep. 194 - Minister Mayhem

    ·1h
  87. 87

    Trailer - Half-Blood Prince

    ·1m
  88. 88

    Ep. 193 - Job Security

    ·1h 9m
  89. 89

    Ep. 192 - Scrabble Points

    ·1h 2m
  90. 90

    Ep. 191 - Peckers Up!

    ·1h 2m
  91. 91

    Ep. 190 - Everyone Experiments at Hogwarts

    ·54m
  92. 92

    Ep. 189 - Young Adults or Old Children?

    ·1h 20m
  93. 93

    Ep. 188 - Dumbledore’s Downfall

    ·52m
  94. 94

    Ep. 187 - Boldedort

    ·58m
  95. 95

    Ep. 186 - Just the Gist

    ·55m
  96. 96

    Ep. 185 - Mic Drop Moment(s)

    ·1h 25m
  97. 97

    Ep. 184 - Tackle Prophecy

    ·1h 23m
  98. 98

    Ep. 183 - Insanely Young Pancakes

    ·1h 16m
  99. 99

    Ep. 182 - It’s the Little Dings

    ·1h 12m
  100. 100

    Ep. 181 - Meddle Detector

    ·1h 4m
  101. 101

    Ep. 278 - Mostly Bad

    Hidden gem

    Ellen and Abigail compare and contrast the Harry Potter book and movie, focusing on Chapter 11 of Order of the Phoenix and its film adaptation.

    Apr 17, 2026·46m·2 clips
  102. 102

    Ep. 277 - The Dobby Show

    Ellen and Abigail compare and contrast the second half of Chapter 11 of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix with its film adaptation, highlighting key differences and film liberties.

    Apr 10, 2026·54m·2 clips
  103. 103

    Ep. 276 - The Potatoes Episode

    Ellen and Abigail discuss the first half of Chapter 11 of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, comparing it to the film adaptation.

    Apr 3, 2026·58m·2 clips
  104. 104

    Ep. 275 - I'm Angry. I'm Disappointed.

    Hidden gem

    Ellen and Abigail discuss the first half of chapter 10 of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, comparing it to the film adaptation, focusing on the trio's discovery of Lily's letter and the locket horcrux.

    Mar 20, 2026·51m·2 clips
  105. 105

    Ep. 274 - Misadventures

    Ellen and Abigail recap the second half of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix chapter nine and corresponding film scenes, focusing on the trio's arrival at 12 Grimmauld Place and Harry's vision of Voldemort.

    Mar 6, 2026·48m
  106. 106

    Ep. 273 - Same-ish

    Ellen and Abigail discuss the first half of Chapter 9 of Harry Potter, comparing the book and film scenes of the trio fleeing the death eater invasion after the wedding.

    Feb 27, 2026·44m
  107. 107

    Ep. 272 - I'm Willing to Bet

    Ellen and Abigail compare and contrast the wedding scene from Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows book and film, focusing on Xenophilius Lovegood's necklace, Dumbledore's reputation, and the arrival of Kingsley's Patronus.

    Feb 20, 2026·43m
  108. 108

    Ep. 271 - Quibbler Kool-Aid

    Feb 13, 2026·50m
  109. 109

    Ep. 270 - Chummy With Krummy

    Hidden gem

    Ellen and Abigail compare the book and movie versions of Harry Potter, focusing on Scrimgeour's visit and the start of Bill and Fleur's wedding.

    Feb 6, 2026·58m·2 clips
  110. 110

    Ep. 269 - Instinctually, Not Intelligently

    Jan 30, 2026·55m
  111. 111

    Ep. 268 - Details Schmetails

    Jan 23, 2026·51m
  112. 112

    Ep. 267 - Unpermissive Exiting

    ["For Fox Sake revisits *Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows* chapter six, \"The Ghoul in Pajamas,\" and keeps comparing the book's setup to the film's missing scenes.", "Ellen and Abigail cover Ron's spattergroit decoy, Hermione's summoning charm on Dumbledore's office books, and the first detailed explanation of how Horcruxes can be destroyed.", "They also track Mrs.

    Jan 16, 2026·45m·3 clips
  113. 113

    Ep. 266 - Wizarding Witness Protection

    Hidden gem

    For Fox Sake covers Deathly Hallows chapter 6, "The Ghoul in Pajamas," where Hermione erases herself from her parents' lives and Molly Weasley tries to stall Harry with chores.

    Oct 25, 2025·47m·4 clips
  114. 114

    Ep. 265 - Not A Gryffindor

    Oct 18, 2025·59m
  115. 115

    Ep. 264 - Harry Potter and the Martyr Syndrome

    Oct 3, 2025·50m
  116. 116

    Ep. 263 - Tom Tantrum

    Sep 27, 2025·44m
  117. 117

    Ep. 262 - 6 Harry Frauders

    Sep 19, 2025·58m
  118. 118

    Ep. 261 - Voldemort Fudd

    Sep 12, 2025·53m
  119. 119

    Ep. 260 - Dish on Dumbledore

    Sep 5, 2025·51m
  120. 120

    Ep. 259 - ADHP

    Aug 29, 2025·45m
  121. 121

    Ep. 258 - Malfoy Mocking

    Aug 22, 2025·50m
  122. 122

    Ep. 257 - Spot On

    Aug 15, 2025·48m
  123. 123

    HP and the Epic Universe

    Jul 11, 2025·1h 10m
  124. 124

    Ep. 256 - Word Dropsies and Addsies

    Ellen, Abigail, and Max discuss differences between US and UK versions of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, focusing on chapter 21 and minor textual changes.

    May 23, 2025·1h 15m
  125. 125

    Ep. 255 - Word Switchies

    May 16, 2025·1h 18m
  126. 126

    Ep. 254 - Snape is Dada

    May 9, 2025·1h 15m
  127. 127

    Ep. 253 - King of Clapback

    May 2, 2025·1h 1m
  128. 128

    Ep. 252 - Literally Unceremoniously

    Apr 25, 2025·1h 10m
  129. 129

    Ep. 251 - Tearing Up

    Apr 11, 2025·1h 1m
  130. 130

    Ep. 250 - Big Ball of Chaos

    Apr 4, 2025·1h 3m
  131. 131

    Ep. 249 - Dead as a Dumbledoornail

    Mar 21, 2025·54m
  132. 132

    Ep. 248 - Party Time Bellatrix

    Mar 14, 2025·1h 2m
  133. 133

    Ep. 247 - Cheeky Little Bastards

    Mar 7, 2025·1h 5m
  134. 134

    Ep. 246 - Smarter Martyr

    Feb 21, 2025·53m
  135. 135

    Ep. 245 - Dumbledoes

    Feb 14, 2025·1h 15m
  136. 136

    Ep. 244 - Demons and Kelpies and Sprites, Oh My!

    Jan 31, 2025·1h 8m
  137. 137

    Ep. 243 - 7 out of 10

    Jan 24, 2025·46m
  138. 138

    Ep. 242 - You-Know-Who-Tattoo

    Jan 17, 2025·1h 6m
  139. 139

    Ep. 241 - Attack Him With Love

    This episode is a compilation of advertisements for home design, credit union, and community banking services.

    Jan 10, 2025·1h 15m
  140. 140

    Ep. 240 - More Moaning Myrtle

    Dec 6, 2024·1h 17m
  141. 141

    Ep. 239 - Dumby-dore

    Nov 22, 2024·1h 1m
  142. 142

    Ep. 238 - WTF Movie

    Nov 15, 2024·1h 4m
  143. 143

    Ep. 237 - Wet Sarcasm

    Nov 8, 2024·1h 6m
  144. 144

    Ep. 236 - Ernie's Tasty Dumpling

    Nov 1, 2024·1h 16m
  145. 145

    Ep. 235 - Oh Roonil Wazlib

    Oct 25, 2024·1h 5m
  146. 146

    Ep. 234 - Magic Grammarly

    Oct 18, 2024·1h 7m
  147. 147

    Ep. 233 - Lovely Lady Trinkets

    Oct 11, 2024·1h 5m
  148. 148

    Ep. 232 - Dumbledore Dungeon Master

    Oct 4, 2024·1h 26m
  149. 149

    Ep. 231 - Niffler for Knowledge

    Sep 28, 2024·1h 19m