Dorney's Vinyl: A Classic Album Podcast

150 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Classic rock, ranked from the record shelf.

The gist

Dorney's Vinyl treats classic rock albums like record-store finds: researched, scored, ranked, and argued over track by track. Odd episodes focus on records and soundtracks, while EP installments shift into games, book reviews, concert notes, movie talk, Billboard history, and Rock and Roll Hall of Fame cases.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Dorney's Vinyl: A Classic Album Podcast

Dorney's Vinyl is a weekly classic-rock show organized around albums, record collecting, and the small arguments that make music fandom fun. Its core format is the album review. Those episodes move through artist context, album history, personnel, track listings, singles, magazine responses, then a final stretch of song opinions, rankings, and scores. The structure is familiar from episode to episode, which gives the show the feel of a carefully kept listening notebook. It is not limited to studio albums. Recent selections include Pat Benatar's Precious Time, Creedence Clearwater Revival's Willy and the Poor Boys, Dire Straits' Brothers in Arms, the Rolling Stones' Tattoo You, and soundtrack records such as Vision Quest. The soundtrack angle matters because the show pays attention to placement, hit singles, and how a compilation holds together as an album. Between album reviews, the even-numbered EP episodes widen the shelf. Some are games, including Album Cover Password, Album Millionaire, first-words challenges, rock trivia, and a Sporcle classic-rock haiku quiz. Some feature the speaker's wife. Other EPs collect music-adjacent material: book reviews, movie reviews, concert reviews, Billboard chart snapshots, Rock and Roll Hall of Fame inductee talk, and Hall of Shame cases for artists the show argues should already be inducted. The show is at its sharpest when research and preference collide. It might compare solo careers through album and singles performance, quote period reviews, list session players, then pivot into a blunt complaint about a Hall of Fame omission or a song that runs too long. The tone is conversational and direct. Details matter here. Chart positions, certifications, producers, instruments, writers, magazine blurbs, and track order all become part of the judgment. The final rankings give each review a clear destination. Dorney's Vinyl suits listeners who like classic rock canon talk without polished radio distance. It sounds like a record collector making a case from notes, shelves, memory, and repeat listens.

Made for: For classic rock fans who enjoy track-by-track album talk, chart trivia, soundtrack records, music books, and Rock and Roll Hall of Fame arguments. It also fits vinyl collectors who like structured opinions more than casual playlist chatter.

What sets it apart: The show alternates formal album reviews with EP-style games and music-history side quests, so the feed feels both organized and homemade. Its signature move is pairing research-heavy record context with ranked personal reactions.

In their own words

As a classic rock enthusiast (even though I was born in the mid-1990s), I discuss my favorite albums that were released 10-20 years before I was born and give my ranking of the songs on the album. I have also included Extended Podcasts, which include autobiography reviews, concert reviews, movie reviews, games, and more!

As heard by us

Based on 4 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Album history, close listening and ranked track verdicts give classic-rock records a clear, personal critical frame.

Dorney's Vinyl turns album listening into a repeatable act of judgment. The host first establishes an album's personnel, recording history, singles and contemporary reviews, then returns after an intermission to rank every track and assign an overall score.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

This is your record-club friend who brings liner notes, rankings, and a final score.

Press play if you want

  • the backstory before you decide whether the record still earns shelf space
  • every track judged individually, because 'the singles were good' is not a ranking
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
classic rock album reviewstrack-by-track song rankingssoundtrack album reviewsRock and Roll Hall of Fame argumentsmusic book reviewsBillboard chart historyrecord collection gamesused 33s and 45s

Talks about

Podcasts like Dorney's Vinyl: A Classic Album Podcast

  • Accidental Tech PodcastMarco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa

    Apple talk with useful digressions.

  • Sound Opinions

    Chicago critics DeRogatis and Kot pair new-album reviews with deep dives into records like Rumours.

  • Heat RocksMaximumFun.org

    Oliver Wang and Morgan Rhodes dig one album deep with a guest each week.

  • Pop Shop PodcastBillboard

    Billboard's Keith Caulfield and Katie Atkinson break down the week's Hot 100 and 200 charts.

  • Endless ThreadWBUR

    Ben Brock Johnson and Amory Sivertson trace viral internet stories from Reddit threads to courtrooms.

  • How Long GoneChris Black & Jason Stewart / Talkhouse

    Chris Black and Jason Stewart riff on fashion, food, and celebrity culture three times weekly.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Movie Review: "The Greatest Night in Pop"

    ·8m
  2. 2

    Sporcle - Classic Rock Haiku Game

    ·7m
  3. 3

    Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Willy and the Poor Boys"

    ·14m
  4. 4

    Book Review: Tusk, Taupin, Bonnie, Steven

    ·7m
  5. 5

    Christopher Cross's "Christopher Cross"

    ·12m
  6. 6

    Album Cover Password 10

    ·6m
  7. 7

    Stevie Nicks' "24 Karat Gold: Songs From The Vault"

    ·12m
  8. 8

    Rank Em: Podcast Album Years

    ·8m
  9. 9

    Jefferson Starship's "Red Octopus"

    ·13m
  10. 10

    Before and Afters Game 6

    ·6m
  11. 11

    Electric Light Orchestra's "Out of the Blue"

    ·15m
  12. 12

    In Memory: 2025

    ·9m
  13. 13

    Huey Lewis and the News' "Sports"

    ·13m
  14. 14

    Music Scattegories 9

    ·6m
  15. 15

    Synonymous Albums 6

    ·6m
  16. 16

    Jimmy Buffett's "Changes in Latitudes, Changes in Attitudes"

    ·13m
  17. 17

    Movie Review: Bat Out Of Hell: The Musical

    ·8m
  18. 18

    The Beatles' "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band"

    ·17m
  19. 19

    Bruce Springsteen or Meat Loaf Game 8

    ·6m
  20. 20

    Rocky III Soundtrack

    ·13m
  21. 21

    Concert Review: Kansas, Blue Oyster Cult, Bachman-Turner Overdrive

    ·8m
  22. 22

    Van Halen's "Diver Down"

    ·13m
  23. 23

    Rock and Roll Trivia 6

    ·10m
  24. 24

    Golden Earring's "Cut"

    ·12m
  25. 25

    2025 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Inductees

    ·7m
  26. 26

    Buckingham Nicks' "Buckingham Nicks"

    ·14m
  27. 27

    First Words 6

    ·5m
  28. 28

    38 Special's "Special Forces"

    ·12m
  29. 29

    Steve Perry's "Street Talk"

    ·14m
  30. 30

    On This Date: September 29, 1979

    ·5m
  31. 31

    Led Zeppelin's "Led Zeppelin IV"

    ·15m
  32. 32

    Season 8 Trailer

    ·3m
  33. 33

    Season 7 Finale

    ·12m
  34. 34

    Dire Straits' "Brothers in Arms"

    ·24m
  35. 35

    Rock and Roll Trivia 5

    ·8m
  36. 36

    Blondie's "Eat to the Beat"

    ·24m
  37. 37

    Pat Benatar's "Precious Time"

    ·12m
  38. 38

    The Rolling Stones' "Tattoo You"

    ·26m
  39. 39

    Album Millionaire Game 6

    ·8m
  40. 40

    Vision Quest Soundtrack

    ·24m
  41. 41

    Book Review: Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All-Time

    ·8m
  42. 42

    Foreigner's "Foreigner"

    ·24m
  43. 43

    First Words 5

    ·6m
  44. 44

    Warren Zevon's "Excitable Boy"

    ·23m
  45. 45

    Hall of Shame: Boston

    ·8m
  46. 46

    Peter Frampton's "Frampton"

    ·22m
  47. 47

    Synonymous Albums 5

    ·7m
  48. 48

    Bruce Springsteen's "Letter To You"

    ·27m
  49. 49

    Movie Review: "Beatles '64"

    ·7m
  50. 50

    The Police's "Ghost in the Machine"

    ·24m
  51. 51

    Album Cover Password 9

    ·7m
  52. 52

    Pink Floyd's "The Wall"

    ·33m
  53. 53

    In Memory: 2024

    ·7m
  54. 54

    John Cougar Mellencamp's "Scarecrow"

    ·24m
  55. 55

    Elton John or Meat Loaf Game 7

    ·7m
  56. 56

    On This Date: December 23, 1989

    ·7m
  57. 57

    Music Scattegories 8

    ·7m
  58. 58

    Don McLean's "American Pie"

    Host Dorney reviews Don McLean's 'American Pie' album as a wildcard pick for season 7 of his vinyl podcast.

    ·24m
  59. 59

    2024 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Inductees

    ·9m
  60. 60

    Prince and the Revolution's "Purple Rain"

    ·28m
  61. 61

    Before and Afters Game 5

    ·6m
  62. 62

    John Fogerty's "Centerfield"

    ·24m
  63. 63

    Concert Review: Stevie Nicks

    ·7m
  64. 64

    Olivia Newton-John's "Physical"

    ·23m
  65. 65

    Rock and Roll Trivia 4

    ·11m
  66. 66

    The Cars' "The Cars"

    ·13m
  67. 67

    Concert Review: Bruce Springsteen

    ·8m
  68. 68

    Queen's "A Day At The Races"

    ·25m
  69. 69

    First Words 4

    ·7m
  70. 70

    Fleetwood Mac's "Fleetwood Mac"

    ·29m
  71. 71

    Season 7 Trailer

    ·6m
  72. 72

    Season 6 Finale

    ·11m
  73. 73

    Quiet Riot's "Metal Health"

    ·23m
  74. 74

    Synonymous Albums 4

    ·7m
  75. 75

    Heart's "Heart"

    ·24m
  76. 76

    Rank Em: Jim Steinman Songs

    ·10m
  77. 77

    Boston's "Don't Look Back"

    ·23m
  78. 78

    Rock and Roll Trivia 3

    ·9m
  79. 79

    Flashdance Soundtrack

    ·24m
  80. 80

    Book Review: Beatles, Rumours, Daltrey, Blondie

    ·8m
  81. 81

    Aerosmith's "Toys in the Attic"

    ·25m
  82. 82

    Before and Afters Game 4

    ·7m
  83. 83

    Jackson Browne's "The Pretender"

    ·24m
  84. 84

    Hall of Shame: Foreigner

    ·8m
  85. 85

    The Mamas and the Papas' "The Mamas and the Papas"

    ·24m
  86. 86

    Album Cover Password 8

    ·8m
  87. 87

    Bonnie Tyler's "The Best Is Yet To Come"

    ·26m
  88. 88

    On This Date: February 12, 1977

    ·6m
  89. 89

    The Moody Blues' "Days of Future Passed"

    ·24m
  90. 90

    Music Scattegories 7

    ·6m
  91. 91

    The Who's "Tommy"

    ·29m
  92. 92

    In Memory: 2023

    ·8m
  93. 93

    Styx's "The Grand Illusion"

    ·23m
  94. 94

    Fleetwood Mac or Meat Loaf Game 6

    ·8m
  95. 95

    The Hooters' "Nervous Night"

    ·27m
  96. 96

    A Philly Special Christmas Review

    ·7m
  97. 97

    Jeff Beck's "Truth"

    ·26m
  98. 98

    First Words 3

    ·7m
  99. 99

    The Monkees' "The Monkees"

    A podcast episode reviewing The Monkees' self-titled debut album, discussing the artist, album details, personnel, track listing, and providing song rankings and an album score.

    ·22m
  100. 100

    Rocky II Soundtrack

    Dorney reviews the Rocky II soundtrack album, discussing its tracks and significance in the Rocky franchise.

    ·23m
  101. 101

    Hall of Shame: Phil Collins

    Dorney introduces his podcast format and teases a Hall of Shame segment about Phil Collins.

    Apr 13, 2026·8m
  102. 102

    Pat Benatar's "Precious Time"

    A podcast host introduces his weekly vinyl album review show and previews a review of Pat Benatar's 'Precious Time'.

    Apr 6, 2026·12m
  103. 103

    Sporcle - Classic Rock Haiku Game

    The host introduces a Sporcle classic rock haiku game as a new format for an even-numbered episode of Dorney's Vinyl.

    Mar 30, 2026·7m
  104. 104

    Creedence Clearwater Revival's "Willy and the Poor Boys"

    Hidden gem

    A podcast host introduces his show and teases an upcoming album review of Creedence Clearwater Revival's 'Willy and the Poor Boys'.

    Mar 23, 2026·14m
  105. 105

    Book Review: Tusk, Taupin, Bonnie, Steven

    Host reviews four music-related books: Get Tusked, Bernie Taupin's autobiography, Bonnie Raitt's biography, and Steven Tyler's memoir.

    Mar 16, 2026·7m
  106. 106

    Christopher Cross's "Christopher Cross"

    Mar 9, 2026·12m
  107. 107

    Album Cover Password 10

    Mar 2, 2026·6m
  108. 108

    Stevie Nicks' "24 Karat Gold: Songs From The Vault"

    Feb 23, 2026·12m
  109. 109

    Rank Em: Podcast Album Years

    Feb 16, 2026·8m
  110. 110

    Jefferson Starship's "Red Octopus"

    Feb 9, 2026·13m
  111. 111

    Before and Afters Game 6

    Feb 2, 2026·6m
  112. 112

    Electric Light Orchestra's "Out of the Blue"

    Dorney's Vinyl reviews Electric Light Orchestra's 1977 double album Out of the Blue, which peaked at number four in the U.S.

    Jan 26, 2026·15m·1 clip
  113. 113

    In Memory: 2025

    Jan 19, 2026·9m
  114. 114

    Huey Lewis and the News' "Sports"

    Jan 12, 2026·13m
  115. 115

    Music Scattegories 9

    Jan 5, 2026·6m
  116. 116

    Jimmy Buffett's "Changes in Latitudes, Changes in Attitudes"

    Dec 29, 2025·13m
  117. 117

    Movie Review: Bat Out Of Hell: The Musical

    Dec 22, 2025·8m
  118. 118

    The Beatles' "Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band"

    Dec 15, 2025·17m
  119. 119

    Bruce Springsteen or Meat Loaf Game 8

    Dec 8, 2025·6m
  120. 120

    Rocky III Soundtrack

    Dec 1, 2025·13m
  121. 121

    Concert Review: Kansas, Blue Oyster Cult, Bachman-Turner Overdrive

    Nov 24, 2025·8m
  122. 122

    Van Halen's "Diver Down"

    Nov 17, 2025·13m
  123. 123

    Rock and Roll Trivia 6

    Nov 10, 2025·10m
  124. 124

    Golden Earring's "Cut"

    Nov 3, 2025·12m
  125. 125

    2025 Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Inductees

    Oct 27, 2025·7m
  126. 126

    Buckingham Nicks' "Buckingham Nicks"

    Oct 20, 2025·14m
  127. 127

    First Words 6

    Oct 13, 2025·5m
  128. 128

    38 Special's "Special Forces"

    Oct 6, 2025·12m
  129. 129

    Steve Perry's "Street Talk"

    Sep 22, 2025·14m
  130. 130

    On This Date: September 29, 1979

    Sep 22, 2025·5m
  131. 131

    Synonymous Albums 6

    Sep 15, 2025·6m
  132. 132

    Led Zeppelin's "Led Zeppelin IV"

    Sep 8, 2025·15m
  133. 133

    Season 8 Trailer

    Sep 1, 2025·3m
  134. 134

    Season 7 Finale

    Jun 9, 2025·12m
  135. 135

    Dire Straits' "Brothers in Arms"

    Dorney's Vinyl episode 39 reviews Dire Straits' 1985 album "Brothers in Arms," which the host says was recorded at AIR Studios in the Caribbean and later at the Power Station in New York.

    Jun 2, 2025·24m·1 clip
  136. 136

    Rock and Roll Trivia 5

    May 26, 2025·8m
  137. 137

    Blondie's "Eat to the Beat"

    May 19, 2025·24m
  138. 138

    Movie Review: "The Greatest Night in Pop"

    May 12, 2025·8m
  139. 139

    The Rolling Stones' "Tattoo You"

    Hidden gem

    Keith Richards says Tattoo You came together because there was “no time to make a whole new album.”

    May 5, 2025·26m·1 clip
  140. 140

    Album Millionaire Game 6

    Apr 28, 2025·8m
  141. 141

    Vision Quest Soundtrack

    Hidden gem

    Dorney's Vinyl covers Vision Quest, the 1985 Harold Becker film released February 15 and its soundtrack released February 12, 1985.

    Apr 21, 2025·24m·1 clip
  142. 142

    Book Review: Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All-Time

    Apr 14, 2025·8m
  143. 143

    Foreigner's "Foreigner"

    Dorney’s Vinyl reviews Foreigner’s self-titled debut, released March 8, 1977, and frames it as a New York City album built from six months of rehearsals, 40 singer auditions, and a Trigger-to-Foreigner name change.

    Apr 7, 2025·24m·1 clip
  144. 144

    First Words 5

    Mar 31, 2025·6m
  145. 145

    Warren Zevon's "Excitable Boy"

    Mar 24, 2025·23m
  146. 146

    Hall of Shame: Boston

    Mar 17, 2025·8m
  147. 147

    Peter Frampton's "Frampton"

    Host Dorney reviews Peter Frampton's album 'Frampton' on his vinyl podcast, discussing the artist, album details, and his personal rankings.

    Mar 10, 2025·22m
  148. 148

    Synonymous Albums 5

    Mar 3, 2025·7m
  149. 149

    Bruce Springsteen's "Letter To You"

    Dorney's Vinyl podcast episode 25 of season 7 reviews Bruce Springsteen's album 'Letter To You' as part of the old-school album series.

    Feb 24, 2025·27m
  150. 150

    Movie Review: "Beatles '64"

    Feb 17, 2025·7m