Criminal Conduct

Creative Babble

65 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Case files that refuse to close cleanly.

The gist

Criminal Conduct follows long-form true-crime cases through documents, interviews, and careful argument. Its strongest episodes linger on the gaps: missing cars, omitted reports, reluctant witnesses, and official explanations that do not settle the matter.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Criminal Conduct

Criminal Conduct is a true-crime series that approaches each season as a stubborn file, not a solved story being retold for effect. Its center of gravity is doubt. The show spends time with deaths that have been explained officially but remain contested by families, witnesses, or the people who kept digging after the first answer was written down. In the Buffalo Jim Barrier episodes, the terrain is Las Vegas: motel rooms, harassment, the Rizzolos, cocaine residue, a Rolls-Royce, and a daughter convinced the story around her father was staged. The material is messy. The show lets it stay messy long enough for the contradictions to matter. In the Pravin Varughese season, the focus shifts to prosecutors, toxicology, a jury verdict, and the language used to describe a young man's death in the woods. Small wording choices become evidence of attitude. A report is not just summarized; it is tested for what it leaves out. That habit gives Criminal Conduct its texture. It is not built on constant revelation, but on accumulation. Witnesses and guests often carry long stretches of the episode, from Karma describing what she believed Buffalo Jim would or would not have done, to Oscar Goodman talking through old Las Vegas defense work, to Major Garrett explaining how Robert Hansen exploited the FBI's self-image. The hosts frame theories, challenge them, and mark speculation when the record cannot carry a firmer claim. The result is grave, skeptical, and conversational. It can be blunt about violence, addiction, sex work, corruption, and institutional failure, but it does not need lurid emphasis to make those subjects land. Criminal Conduct is best for listeners who like procedural detail, unresolved questions, and true crime that notices when the official version sounds too neat.

Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer patient investigation, witness interviews, legal context, and disputed evidence over quick twists. It fits anyone willing to sit with ambiguity across a full season.

What sets it apart: Criminal Conduct stands out for its document-by-document skepticism and its willingness to let guests, family members, and legal figures complicate the hosts' own theories. The show treats uncertainty as part of the evidence, not a flaw to edit away.

In their own words

Criminal Conduct is an investigative true-crime podcast series hosted by John Taylor and Javier Leiva.Season 1: The hosts look into the death of Michelle O'Connell, picking up the investigation where the murdered sleuth, Eli Washtock, left off.Season 2: The investigation of a rogue constable in Kentucky who is accused of planting drugs, stealing money, and shaking people down.Season 3: An American Serial Killer in Paradise: The story of serial killer William Holbert, aka "Wild Bill," and his victims.Season 4: Getting Away with Murder: The Death Investigation of Pravin VarugheseSeason 5: The Life and Death of Buffalo Jim Barrier

As heard by us

Based on 4 episodes we listened to · September 2026

It makes disputed cases legible by testing official conclusions against records, witness accounts, forensic gaps, and later legal developments.

Criminal Conduct follows contested deaths and criminal cases through evidence, official decisions, and the people challenging them. John Taylor and Javier Leiva give serialized true crime a questioning, methodical shape.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

An overturned murder verdict becomes your cue to start cross-examining everyone.

Press play if you want

  • contradictory witness accounts weighed carefully instead of tidied away
  • police and prosecutor decisions tested against the evidence they had
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
contested death investigationsLas Vegas crime historymissing or mishandled evidenceprosecutorial decisionswitness credibilitymob-adjacent storiestoxicology and drug evidencecourtroom strategy

Talks about

Best episodes of Criminal Conduct

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

The Final ChapterFeb 21, 2025

A measured closing chapter built on contradictions, unresolved leads, and the weight of what never got properly checked.

The Final Chapter lingers on James "Buffalo Jim" Barrier's death by tracking the pressure around it: the daily harassment he endured, the money it drained from him, the missing Rolls-Royce, and police work that never quite seemed to land in the right place.

The Missing WitnessFeb 14, 2025

A careful true-crime episode that keeps testing the overdose story against witness memory and motel-room details.

Criminal Conduct presents Buffalo Jim's death as a slow, unsettled inquiry, with Javier Leyva and John Taylor weighing witness memory, motel-room details, and the question of whether the overdose account holds.

Robert Hanssen: The Spy Within - An Interview with Major GarrettNov 17, 2023

A dry, careful spy story about how an ordinary-looking man stayed invisible.

Criminal Conduct uses a bonus interview with Major Garrett to revisit Robert Hansen, the FBI agent who passed secrets to Russia while, as the show frames it, hiding in plain sight.

Turning PointSep 8, 2023

A prosecutor's certainty becomes the episode's sharpest point.

Criminal Conduct stays with the gap between Lovely's grief and a prosecutor who appears settled before the case is fully weighed. Its best moments come through Mike Carr's words, especially the condescending way he describes Praveen Verghese's death and the hurt that lands on…

Podcasts like Criminal Conduct

  • The DropoutABC News

    ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.

  • Dr. DeathAudible

    Laura Beil investigates a fake doctor's $600 million HIV and cancer fraud.

  • Wind of ChangePineapple Street Studios / Crooked Media / Spotify

    Patrick Radden Keefe investigates whether the CIA secretly wrote a Scorpions hit.

  • Deep CoverPushkin Industries

    Jake Halpern and the Snowball team track a con artist who defrauded a family.

  • CrimetownGimlet

    A city-by-city true-crime documentary, from Detroit's Kwame Kilpatrick scandal to mob confessions.

  • S-TownSerial Productions

    A murder rumor in rural Alabama unravels into a clockmaker's suicide and estate feud.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Listen Now: The Rise & Fall of Diddy: The Federal Trial

    This episode is a promotional preview for Law & Crime's podcast 'The Rise and Fall of Diddy: The Federal Trial,' hosted by Jesse Weber, covering Sean Combs's federal trial on sex trafficking and racketeering charges.

    Jun 17, 2025·10m
  2. 2

    The Final Chapter

    Buffalo Jim kept the shop open.

    Feb 21, 2025·34m·2 clips
  3. 3

    The Missing Witness

    Hidden gem

    Javier Leyva and John Taylor dig into Buffalo Jim's death by moving through the claims around GHB, cocaine, motel rooms, and the people who knew him best.

    Feb 14, 2025·32m·2 clips
  4. 4

    Nothing to See Here

    Feb 7, 2025·24m
  5. 5

    Motel 6

    Jan 31, 2025·22m
  6. 6

    The Feud

    Jan 24, 2025·28m
  7. 7

    Sin City

    Jan 17, 2025·31m
  8. 8

    CRIMINAL CONDUCT Season 5 The Life and Death of Buffalo Jim Barrier

    Jan 14, 2025·3m
  9. 9

    The Amish Wife

    Jan 19, 2024·40m
  10. 10

    Is Alex Murdaugh a Red Collar Criminal? (bonus)

    Jan 18, 2024·15m
  11. 11

    Oscar Goodman: From Mob Attorney to Vegas Mayor | Criminal Conduct Exclusive Interview

    Las Vegas comes first.

    Nov 17, 2023·27m·2 clips
  12. 12

    Miranda's Victim (bonus)

    Nov 17, 2023·20m
  13. 13

    Robert Hanssen: The Spy Within - An Interview with Major Garrett

    Hidden gem

    Major Garrett brings Robert Hansen back into focus.

    Nov 17, 2023·45m·4 clips
  14. 14

    Listen Now: New Podcast “Ghost Story”

    Oct 25, 2023·10m
  15. 15

    Fear God

    Oct 13, 2023·26m
  16. 16

    Your Own Worst Enemy

    Oct 6, 2023·22m
  17. 17

    Route 13

    Sep 29, 2023·24m
  18. 18

    Dead Weight

    Sep 22, 2023·20m
  19. 19

    Sep 15, 2023·22m
  20. 20

    Turning Point

    A verdict can still wobble.

    Sep 8, 2023·25m·2 clips
  21. 21

    No One Will Listen

    Sep 1, 2023·28m
  22. 22

    The Search for Answers

    Aug 25, 2023·28m
  23. 23

    Gone

    Aug 18, 2023·25m
  24. 24

    Criminal Conduct Season 4 Preview

    Aug 11, 2023·8m
  25. 25

    George Santos & The Harbor City Capital Ponzi Scheme (THE PONZI PLAYBOOK)

    May 23, 2023·40m
  26. 26

    TWISTED: The Death of Rebekah Barsotti

    May 16, 2023·31m
  27. 27

    Wondery Presents: Frozen Head

    Jan 23, 2023·4m
  28. 28

    Introducing Suspect: Vanished in the Snow

    Jan 9, 2023·8m
  29. 29

    Suspect: Vanished in the Snow

    Nov 11, 2022·7m
  30. 30

    Bonus: Retracing Lee Harvey Oswald's Escape

    Oct 31, 2022·16m
  31. 31

    Bonus: "How to create a cult following" LIVE from the TCPF in Dallas

    Oct 18, 2022·39m
  32. 32

    Introducing: The Generation Why Podcast

    Oct 3, 2022·9m
  33. 33

    Wondery Presents: The Execution of Bonny Lee Bakley

    Jun 20, 2022·6m
  34. 34

    INTRODUCING Persona: The French Deception

    Jun 12, 2022·5m
  35. 35

    INTRODUCING Witnessed: Friendly Fire

    Jun 6, 2022·8m
  36. 36

    Salvaje Bill

    May 13, 2022·46m
  37. 37

    My Best Friend Wild Bill

    Apr 29, 2022·42m
  38. 38

    In Between a Rock and Hard Place

    Apr 15, 2022·46m
  39. 39

    The Dark Prophet

    Apr 1, 2022·44m
  40. 40

    An interview with a serial killer

    Mar 18, 2022·37m
  41. 41

    Introducing American Hostage

    Mar 9, 2022·5m
  42. 42

    The Many Faces of Wild Bill

    Mar 4, 2022·33m
  43. 43

    Only 90% Survive

    Feb 18, 2022·29m
  44. 44

    Criminal Conduct Season 3 Trailer: An American Serial Killer in Paradise

    Feb 12, 2022·3m
  45. 45

    Families Who Kill: The Donut Shop Murders

    Jan 4, 2022·5m
  46. 46

    The Day of Reckoning

    Nov 3, 2021·22m
  47. 47

    The Verdict

    Jul 2, 2021·22m
  48. 48

    Constables on Patrol

    Jun 11, 2021·34m
  49. 49

    No-knock

    May 28, 2021·28m
  50. 50

    The Good Constable

    May 14, 2021·43m
  51. 51

    The Prey

    Apr 30, 2021·31m
  52. 52

    The Rogue Constable

    Apr 16, 2021·41m
  53. 53

    Criminal Conduct Season 2 Trailer

    Mar 23, 2021·4m
  54. 54

    Who was Eli Washtock? Part 2

    Jun 8, 2020·53m
  55. 55

    Who was Eli Washtock? Part 1

    Jun 1, 2020·49m
  56. 56

    Exhumed

    May 25, 2020·31m
  57. 57

    A New Sheriff

    May 18, 2020·36m
  58. 58

    The Case for Suicide

    May 11, 2020·42m
  59. 59

    Four Months Too Late

    May 4, 2020·44m
  60. 60

    What Went Wrong

    Apr 20, 2020·44m
  61. 61

    When Love Turns Violent

    Apr 13, 2020·36m
  62. 62

    The Death Scene

    Apr 6, 2020·34m
  63. 63

    The Murder of Eli Washtock

    Mar 30, 2020·34m
  64. 64

    The Death of Michelle O'Connell

    Mar 23, 2020·30m
  65. 65

    Season 1: The Trailer

    Jan 28, 2020·3m