Turning Point

September 8, 2023·25 min·2 clips

Praveen Varghese's mother took a six-hour train ride to address the Carbondale city council and ask why police sent her newspaper clippings instead of police reports.

The case narrows to Mike Carr. In the cold open, his early position sounds shut tight: Gage did nothing wrong, and Praveen simply froze. That explanation does not sit right. Lovely's taped reaction gives the episode its charge, especially when she pushes back on comfortable death, a phrase that feels cruelly out of place. Carr's statement then goes under the hosts' microscope. They read it less like neutral prosecutorial reasoning and more like a decision looking for cover. One omission keeps nagging at them. Praveen's toxicology report was negative, which would have cut against Carr's repeated focus on intoxication. The wording does real work here. Monica Zoukas calls the 18-page statement a public defense of Gage, and the hosts hear that same stance in Carr's own language. The bigger problem is his lack of any opening for reconsideration if new evidence appeared. To them, that sounds like a prosecutor protecting a call instead of testing it. Once the cold open notes that a later jury convicted Gage, Carr's earlier certainty starts to look shaky. The episode lingers over legal language, prosecutorial independence, and the tiny phrases that show whether an official mind is still open. Zoukas sharpens the criticism by describing the statement as an attack on Praveen's character, not a dry explanation for declining charges. The ending turns to the police records, teased as the next pressure point in the investigation.

As heard by us

A prosecutor's certainty becomes the episode's sharpest point.

Criminal Conduct stays with the gap between Lovely's grief and a prosecutor who appears settled before the case is fully weighed. Its best moments come through Mike Carr's words, especially the condescending way he describes Praveen Verghese's death and the hurt that lands on…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the prosecutor's reasoning tested against the record.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Criminal Conduct