True crime where certainty breaks down.
Cover Up is a reported true-crime series built around cases that refuse to settle into one clean answer. Episodes move from vivid crime-scene detail into the arguments, investigative gaps, and human loyalties that keep each story unsettled.
PRESS PLAY
Cover Up treats true crime as a fight over what can be known. The series focuses on cases where the official version, the family version, and the public version all pull in different directions. In the Kentucky Brothel Murders, two women are killed inside a massage parlor everyone in town understands to be a brothel, and the investigation is tangled by secrets no one wants exposed. The case is not framed as a simple whodunit. It becomes a study in what happens when an unclear crime scene lets blame ricochet from person to person. The Sugar Land Murders bring a different kind of horror. A family gathering becomes the prelude to violence, and the aftermath forces loved ones to sort through denial, circumstantial theories, and the possibility that the answer is inside the family itself. Then The Boys on the Tracks widens the frame again. Two teenage boys are found dead on railroad tracks, the early ruling is accepted quickly, and questions about evidence, law enforcement, and a possible cover-up begin to grow. The show is strongest when it slows down around uncertainty. Jonathan Hirsch and Cooper Maul weigh theories without pretending every theory deserves the same confidence. They talk about tunnel vision, police missteps, public suspicion, coerced or contested narratives, and the way media attention can harden an incomplete story into something people think they know. Their conversation is brisk and analytical, but not detached. Family members matter. Victims matter. So do the reporters whose work keeps these cases from being flattened into folklore. Cover Up suits listeners who want the mechanics of investigation along with the emotional cost of not knowing. It is grim, but it is not empty spectacle. Its focus is the unstable space between a crime, a case file, and the version of events that survives.
Made for: For true-crime listeners who prefer contested evidence, procedural questions, and family secrets over tidy endings. It suits anyone drawn to cases where the aftermath is as revealing as the crime.
What sets it apart: Cover Up stands out by tracking how blame, media narratives, police decisions, and grief distort the search for truth. The episodes keep the uncertainty visible instead of forcing each case into a clean conclusion.
From The Binge, Crime Scene is a weekly show that plunges you into cases you can’t stop thinking about. Join Jonathan Hirsch, host of My Fugitive Dad and Dear Franklin Jones and producer behind shows like The Thing About Pam and Dr. Death, as he teams up with investigative reporter and podcaster Cooper Moll to crack open the cases that deserve a second look. Each episode weaves an intricate true crime story with real photos and videos from the cases-- the kind of reporting you could only get from two experts who spent years in the field. Step inside the Crime Scene office and feed your true crime obsession with The Binge. The Binge is a Sony Music Entertainment Original Production. Find more…
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A brothel murder case becomes a study in conflicting accounts and shaky ground.
Set in 1994 Oak Grove, Kentucky, this episode follows the murders of Candy Belt and Gloria Ross inside a massage parlor everyone knows is a brothel, then widens into a town where secrets and linked stories keep the case unsettled.
A family crime story where the investigation and the secret both deepen the shock.
This episode follows a family gathering in a wealthy Houston suburb as it unravels into a grisly crime story with a hidden core, suspicion, and plenty of uncertainty.
A railroad-death mystery that keeps the official story under pressure.
The episode starts with two Arkansas teenage boys found brutalized on railroad tracks, a mile from where they were last seen, and keeps circling the question of whether this was ever a simple accident.
Masha Gessen narrates her own cousin's murder-for-hire arrest and custody battle.
Ashley Flowers and Britt Prawat revisit unsolved murders and cold cases as new evidence surfaces.
Multi-part true crime narration, from BTK's Wichita letters to Australian cold-case disappearances.
In September 1994, Candy Belt (age 22) and Gloria Ross (age 18) were shot execution-style and had their throats slashed inside the New Life Massage Parlor, an openly illegal brothel in Oak Grove, Kentucky.
Jonathan Hirsch and Cooper Maul recount the 2003 Sugar Land, Texas case in which Bart Whitaker orchestrated a masked gunman attack on his own family — killing his mother Tricia and brother Kevin — and then called 911 pretending to be a victim.
Jonathan Hirsch and Cooper Maul cover the 1987 case of Kevin Ives and Don Henry, two Arkansas teenagers found dead on a Union Pacific railroad track after what was initially ruled an accidental death caused by a marijuana-induced coma.