Cover Story

New York Magazine

19 episodes listed below

Listen to the show on

Power, belief, and the stories that break.

The gist

Cover Story follows complicated accusations through interviews, records, court fights, and the uneasy process of checking a source’s story. It is serious without sounding sealed off, letting contradictions, bad judgment, and human messiness stay visible.

PRESS PLAY

Find your next episode

All episodes

About Cover Story

Cover Story is investigative audio about what happens when persuasive people, vulnerable people, money, sex, status, and belief systems collide. It does not move like a police blotter. It moves like a long conversation that keeps finding new documents on the table. The show follows phone calls, court records, texts, memories, expert context, and the awkward moments where a reporter has to admit that an earlier theory no longer holds. That uncertainty is part of the point. In the Seed Money episodes, the story circles around Mike, Amber, and Matt, whose supposed intelligence background becomes a major fault line. The reporters try to verify CIA claims, trace old stories, test accounts against people who would know, and sit with the discomfort of confronting someone who may have shaped the investigation from the inside. It gets ugly. It also gets strangely mundane, with legal arguments and disturbing allegations sitting beside family errands, dogs, cars, and the small sounds of real life. The Power Trip episodes take a different but related path, looking at psychedelic therapy, underground training, clinical trials, and people trying to describe harm after entering spaces they thought would heal them. Susan’s story shows how pressure can be framed as destiny, resistance, training, or care. Mel’s story shows the long aftermath, where even beauty and solitude may not touch what has changed. Cover Story is strongest when it refuses both cynicism and blind trust. It does not treat institutions, charismatic guides, wealthy men, spiritual language, or legal victories as proof of moral clarity. It keeps asking what was said, who benefited, who was believed, and what evidence can actually bear. The sound is intimate, sometimes wry, and often heavy. It suits listeners who want true-crime reporting with process left in, not just plot.

Made for: For listeners who like investigative true crime with interviews, records, legal texture, and unresolved moral pressure. It suits people comfortable with ambiguity and difficult testimony.

What sets it apart: Cover Story lets the reporting process stay visible, including doubts, revisions, contaminated leads, and uncomfortable confrontations. Its investigations feel less like tidy case files than living arguments with evidence.

In their own words

What can a billionaire get away with these days? A secret bat cave? A harem of women? An international spy operation? Stealing the soul of a small town in Montana? A Silicon Valley venture capitalist was accused of running a massive sex-trafficking operation by his best bro friend. And we unravel the truth about both of them - their business, their break-up, their lies, and their embarrassing text messages. The story of a billionaire with a hero complex, the ex-spy who turned his life inside out, and us, the reporters who got caught up in their macho drama.Cover Story i...

As heard by us

Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026

Cover Story tests stories about wealth, therapy and alleged abuse against testimony, records and the contradictions its sources leave behind.

Cover Story follows contested allegations past their first clean telling, using serialized investigations to examine how power, credibility and self-mythology shape accounts of harm.

Read our full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A supposed ex-spy's biography collapses, and your trust issues finally look like sound editorial policy.

Press play if you want

  • to have your faith in psychedelic healers checked against coercion, clinical fallout, and survivor testimony
  • to follow reporters as a supposed ex-spy's heroic biography crumbles under calls to people who should know him
Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
sexual misconduct allegationspsychedelic therapy harmcourt records and legal disputeswealth and powerfalse or contested identitiesclinical trialsunderground training programssource credibility

Talks about

Best episodes of Cover Story

Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.

All the VoidsNov 29, 2022

A patient takedown that feels messy in the right way.

Cover Story follows a prison call as Ken pieces together a biography that does not hold up. Months of reporting give the claims real weight: the fake spy story, the cropped photos, the Syria line, and the plain fact that none of it can be backed.

I Am the VictimNov 22, 2022

An investigative story that keeps pressure on its own claims until the confidence starts to wobble.

The episode starts with the invisible gorilla experiment and uses it to set up the clues in Mike's story as the reporting moves from Matt to John, Amber, Vanessa Doe, and Jane Doe.

Baby, You’re Fine With MeNov 15, 2022

A court fight gets stranger when the private story keeps undercutting the public one.

Baby, You're Fine With Me follows a legal fight backward and sideways, letting court questions, statements, and memory rub against each other until the private relationship and the public dispute stop looking separate.

The Complainers GroupMar 22, 2022

A careful look at psychedelic therapy, trauma, and the limits of clinical certainty.

This episode opens with a sexual assault warning and settles into a hard, careful conversation about psychedelic therapy, trauma, and clinical trials.

I Am the WolfDec 14, 2021

A coercive mentorship story where confusion becomes the clue.

The piece follows a woman called Susan as she is drawn toward an underground psychedelic therapy training program, with a mentor who keeps turning hesitation into supposed resistance.

Podcasts like Cover Story

  • ChameleonAudiochuck | Campside Media

    True stories of scams, aliases, frauds, and lives built on lies.

  • Atlanta MonsteriHeartPodcasts and Tenderfoot TV

    Payne Lindsey and Tenderfoot TV revisit the Atlanta Child Murders and the wider Monster franchise.

  • DisgracelandDouble Elvis Productions

    Host Jake Brennan traces the crimes and scandals behind musicians from Elvis to Taylor Swift.

  • You Must Remember MansonKarina Longworth

    Karina Longworth narrates the Manson murders as a story about Hollywood's collapsing 1960s dream.

  • The Ballad of Billy BallsiHeartPodcasts

    iO Tillett Wright investigates her mother's boyfriend's unsolved 1982 East Village murder.

  • Wild BoysCampside Media / Sony Music Entertainment

    A wilderness hoax, a trusting BC town, and the brothers who fooled it.

Episodes

  1. 1

    Presenting Deep Cover: Never Seen Again

    Feb 7, 2023·4m
  2. 2

    All the Voids

    Ken finally puts the evidence in front of Matt.

    Nov 29, 2022·35m·2 clips
  3. 3

    I Am the Victim

    Cover Story opens with the invisible gorilla experiment.

    Nov 22, 2022·48m·3 clips
  4. 4

    Baby, You’re Fine With Me

    Testing, then a phone cord gets sorted out.

    Nov 15, 2022·53m·5 clips
  5. 5

    Mission Creep

    Nov 8, 2022·38m
  6. 6

    They Were Relationships... Nothing Yucky

    Nov 1, 2022·44m
  7. 7

    Mind Your Own Business

    Oct 25, 2022·43m
  8. 8

    Introducing Cover Story: Seed Money

    Oct 18, 2022·2m
  9. 9

    The Complainers Group

    A warning comes first.

    Mar 22, 2022·53m·4 clips
  10. 10

    Who Am I Fooling?

    Mar 15, 2022·51m
  11. 11

    Political Science

    Mar 8, 2022·1h 3m
  12. 12

    Open Heart Surgery

    Mar 1, 2022·59m
  13. 13

    Cover Story: Power Trip, Part II

    Feb 23, 2022·2m
  14. 14

    House Full of Sh*t

    Dec 28, 2021·53m
  15. 15

    Bad Hug

    Dec 21, 2021·37m
  16. 16

    I Am the Wolf

    Susan hears there is one spot left.

    Dec 14, 2021·52m·2 clips
  17. 17

    That's an Old Story

    Dec 7, 2021·39m
  18. 18

    I See a Sh*tshow

    Nov 30, 2021·32m
  19. 19

    Introducing Cover Story: Power Trip

    Nov 10, 2021·2m