Cover Story · New York Magazine

All the Voids

November 29, 2022·35 min·2 clips

Mike gave a woman $590,000 over a few months, called it his 'little change your life plan'—then she ghosted him without a word.

The story has turned against its own source. After more than a year of reporting, the team lands on a blunt problem: Matt, once the center of the narrative, appears to be a con man. Ken has been circling that fact for months. He has shown Matt pieces of evidence, but the prison call is where the larger pattern finally has to be said out loud. The CIA claim sits in the middle of it. Ken tells Matt he tried hard to confirm it and could not, while the evidence he did find points the other way. That makes the confrontation feel heavy and a little queasy. The transcript catches how awkward it is to accuse someone while also remembering that the person is already in prison. There is no clean win here. Even the fifteen-minute call limit makes the reporting feel boxed in, procedural, and oddly intimate. Then the episode changes angles. A conversation about power drifts toward a biblical parable, the master and the servants, and the impossible rules handed down from above. The mood goes dry and unsettled. The point is less theology than the psychology of being the master, the person with all the power. Mary Beth becomes part of that texture. Her dog, keys, car speaker, and spider problem keep barging into the darker material with everyday life turned all the way up. The interruption is funny, but it does more than lighten the room. It shows how the show lets ordinary details sit next to serious questions instead of sealing the investigation off like evidence in a box. Rescue keeps coming back too. Mary Beth talks about handling a spider infestation before visitors arrive, and the conversation bends toward hero complexes and people who rush in to help. That thought loops back to the larger story. The fake spy background, the rescue language, and the evidence Ken cannot support all point to the same uneasy question: why do people need to be seen a certain way?

As heard by us

A patient takedown that feels messy in the right way.

Cover Story follows a prison call as Ken pieces together a biography that does not hold up. Months of reporting give the claims real weight: the fake spy story, the cropped photos, the Syria line, and the plain fact that none of it can be backed.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A prison call that finally puts the evidence on the record.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Cover Story