PRESS PLAY
Two Wisconsin lovebirds investigate crime, corruption, and fascinating people of the Midwest to bring you incredible stories happening right in your backyard.
Valleybrook's "Chosen" paper gets the follow-up questions you wish someone had asked sooner.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
Valleybrook's reforms are weighed against the hurt they cannot simply undo.
Chosen's final episode returns Cool and Unusual Punishment to Valleybrook Church in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, using the closing chapter to ask what rebuilding can mean after harm.
A follow-up where emails turn a theology paper into an unsettled crisis of belief.
This bonus installment picks up after Kaylee Evergreen's interview by turning back to the emails behind the Chosen paper. Her questions about predestination, Matthew 22, and a picture of God that jars against what she has been taught give the episode its pressure, with her…
A direct return to chosen theology that turns toward youth-group pressure, an alleged sexual assault, and a troubling church response.
Episode 15 loops back to the series' earlier threads: the chosen paper, a message or sermon, and the unsettling idea that not everyone makes it.
A promised pause from pastoring turns into a Texas church chapter, a fractured family story, and contradictions the hosts keep pulling apart.
Doug's promised pause from pastoring lasts about three months before the Valleybrook Church story opens a Texas chapter. Chosen - Episode 14 tracks Narrow Pathway from its June 26, 2015 start in Grapevine through a woman's account of church work, a move to Texas, and a widening…
A church timeline turns meetings, emails, and retraining assurances into a record of what followed a spiritual abuse report.
Chosen - Episode 13 follows Matt and Jesse Irwin through Valleybrook's 2014-2016 period and the years leading into it, using their experience to trace how concerns at the Eau Claire, Wisconsin church were handled after a report described spiritual abuse.
Wellness talk with real-life static.
Petty conflicts, loud verdicts, real care.
Valleybrook says it added annual financial reviews, member-approved budgets, and certified CPA audits after the crisis.
Kaylee Evergreen keeps pressing the hardest question in the file: did Jesus die for everyone, or only for the chosen?
Kaylee Evergreen says Valleybrook Church in Eau Claire, Wisconsin gave her an early warning sign when a youth leader admitted, "We don't have a curriculum.
["The Narrow Pathway was a Texas nonprofit Doug Lobsack filed on June 26, 2015, and Tyler and Jody trace how its website appeared, vanished, and returned with a hacked-site explanation.", "They read the church\u2019s Matthew 7 \"narrow gate\" copy, its Main Street Grapevine address, and its use of Domains by Proxy to obscure registration details.", "A long public statement from Jessica Lobsack becomes the center of the episode, with claims about Nate\u2019s adoption, Valleybrook resignation day, and Matthew Mitchell\u2019s role around the church.", "The sharpest documentary detail comes at the end, when a 10-page attachment about Jessica\u2019s father shows Doug Lobsack as both author and last modifier."]
Tyler and Jodi walk through a dense February 2015-to-February 2016 timeline for Valleybrook in Eau Claire, Wisconsin, centered on Jesse and Matt Irwin's notes and emails.
The episode explores historical etiquette advice from Emily Post about managing cats as visitors, blending humor and social commentary.
The hosts discuss the tradition of a hope chest and share a personal story about one that was never given to the speaker.
The hosts humorously explore Emily Post's wedding etiquette while joking about their own engagement.
This episode reads from Emily Post's etiquette book about inconsiderate customers, exploring historical social norms and customer behavior.