West Hills Church

Ask the Pastors S8 E9: “What does 1 Timothy 2:12 ‘not permit’ women to do?”

·37 min·3 clips
Pastor Brian reads 1 Timothy 2:12, which says 'I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man,' sparking a deep interpretive debate.
Brian introduces the question after a brief exchange about being tired after Easter. He is joined by Pastor Thad and lead pastor Will for a discussion prompted by Ben's reading of an egalitarian interpretation of 1 Timothy 2:8-15. That interpretation places Paul's instruction in the particular circumstances of the church in Ephesus. It also raises questions about how the word translated as authority in verse 12 should be understood. The pastors focus on the Greek term authenteo. Will describes a Bible Hub Interlinear Bible explanation that connects the word to autos, meaning self, and to language of arms or armor. The discussion uses those associations to think through ideas of self-directed, unilateral, or self-appointed action. Will presents his understanding as a first pass and says he would recant later if he is wrong. That caveat matches the larger tone, which works through the wording aloud rather than treating the lexical issue as settled by one quick gloss. The phrase to teach or to exercise authority gets sustained attention. The conversation asks whether the two expressions should be treated as separate ideas or as closely related, such as teaching authoritatively or exercising authority by teaching. A reference to Bob Yarborough's proposal connects the wording with the chief responsibilities of a congregation's pastor. The argument stays close to the relationship between biblical instruction and pastoral office. The pastors then bring the question into church life. They address the possibility that women may feel less than elders and pastors because those offices are held by men. The response rejects that implication. It points instead toward God's creation, calling, unique gifting, and the responsibilities tied to each person's place. The application asks women to appreciate that calling and play their part as well as they can. The episode closes by inviting listeners to submit questions and announcing a future discussion about cryptids.

As heard by us

A weary church conversation turns a disputed Greek verb into a question of pastoral calling and women's role in church life.

1 Timothy 2:12 is treated here as a question of translation, context, and pastoral office in a weary but focused conversation among Brian, Pastor Thad, and lead pastor Will.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want 1 Timothy 2:12 unpacked without pretending the Greek verb authenteo is a simple footnote.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on