The Good, The Bad And The Classics - The Movie Review Podcast · The Good, The Bad And The Classics Podcast

Scrooged (1988)

December 2, 2025·1 hr 12 min·5 clips

Elle says Bill Murray plays the same role in most films and calls him not a particularly good actor.

1. The Good, The Bad And The Classics reviews Scrooged (1988) as the start of a Christmas retrospective. 2. John, Elle, and the other host lead the discussion, with John acting as the most film-literate voice and Elle reacting as someone who had not seen A Christmas Carol before. 3. The episode asks whether Scrooged works as a modern Christmas Carol update and whether its comedy lands. 4. The hosts open by describing the film’s 1988 release, Richard Donner’s direction, and the cast list that includes Bill Murray, Carol Kane, Karen Allen, Alfre Woodard, John Forsythe, David Johansson, and Lee Majors. 5. They explain that their podcast normally gives backgrounds first and then moves into spoilers, which shapes the structure of the conversation. 6. John says he first saw the film on VHS, while Elle says she had never seen it and did not know the story of A Christmas Carol. 7. The group reacts to the opening broadcast sequence, with John comparing the model work to A Nightmare Before Christmas and everyone noticing Lee Majors in the fake television setup. 8. They discuss Frank Cross as the president of IBC Television and point out that he fires Elliot Loudermilk after Elliot questions the violent Christmas Eve promotion. 9. The hosts keep returning to Frank’s behavior, including the way he steals a taxi from an old lady and treats his secretary Grace badly. 10. They describe the first ghost visit from Lou Haywood and note the warning that Frank will soon meet three ghosts. 11. The conversation covers the ghost of Christmas past, who appears as a chain-smoking taxi driver and takes Frank back to 1955 and 1968. 12. The hosts mention Frank’s childhood with a neglectful father, his comfort in television, and the family Christmas scenes that show why he is emotionally closed off. 13. They also discuss the 1968 office party and the moments where Frank meets Claire and later starts to turn away from her. 14. John points out cameo-like appearances, including Miles Davis in the street and Robert Goulet singing on the boat. 15. The episode spends time on the restaurant hallucination scene, where Frank sees an eyeball in a glass, a golf ball, and a waiter catching fire. 16. John and Elle argue about whether those moments are meant to be real, dreamlike, or simply played for comedy. 17. The hosts repeatedly comment on the film’s editing and makeup, including Bill Murray’s appearance and a bad makeup look on Claire. 18. The episode has a loose, bantering style with interruptions, side jokes, and back-and-forth disagreements over what the film is doing. 19. Fans of Christmas movies, Richard Donner, and Bill Murray debates would probably enjoy this episode. 20. Viewers looking for a straight, spoiler-free plot summary probably should skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Good, The Bad And The Classics - The Movie Review Podcast