The Business of Healthcare Podcast · Center for Healthcare Leadership and Management

The Business of Healthcare Podcast, Episode 123: Medicare Advantage: The Collision of Medicare and Managed Care

·37 min·2 clips

A Medicare Advantage enrollment change delayed a man’s brain-cancer treatment by two months.

1. The Business of Healthcare Podcast episode 123 focuses on Medicare Advantage, which Daniel Carnuta describes as the collision of Medicare and managed care. 2. Daniel Carnuta, director of the UT Dallas Professional Program in Healthcare Management, hosts Lawrence LaDaga and Dale Turner, who work on denied claims and provider disputes. 3. The episode asks why Medicare Part C has become so contentious for hospitals, payers, and beneficiaries. 4. Lawrence LaDaga traces managed care back to post-World War II employer insurance and the mid-1970s creation of HMOs with primary-care gatekeepers. 5. He says insurers and providers later built direct contracts with negotiated rates, but he thinks early attention went to rates more than cost-control clauses. 6. The guests say Medicare was drawn to managed care because CMS wanted to slow healthcare cost growth and reduce per-member spending. 7. They connect that move to capitated payments, where Medicare pays plans a per-member-per-month premium with severity adjustments. 8. Lawrence says Medicare and Medicaid already make up as much as 50% of a hospital’s payer mix, which makes federal payment policy especially important. 9. The discussion turns to early Medicare Advantage problems, especially pre-authorization, pre-certification, notification rules, and medical-necessity review. 10. Lawrence says straight Medicare has no pre-authorization requirement, while Medicare Advantage plans may require prior approval or separate notification. 11. The guests say the rules were unclear on whether Medicare Advantage had to follow Medicare’s inpatient-only list and other coverage rules. 12. Lawrence says that uncertainty produced friction between providers and Medicare Part C payers and helped drive claim denials. 13. He says providers focused on reimbursement rates and often did not account enough for denial provisions in managed-care contracts. 14. He argues that no amount of rate negotiation can offset a contract that allows repeated denials on the back end. 15. Daniel Carnuta says the model can look sensible because a payer reviews each case and pushes back on unnecessary cost. 16. Lawrence says the present market is strained because providers drop Medicare Advantage plans while plans also leave markets. 17. Lawrence says half of Medicare beneficiaries are in Medicare Advantage and half are in straight Medicare. 18. He says a new CMS rule issued this year tries to align medical-necessity denials with Medicare coverage requirements, but he does not know how it will play out in appeals or arbitration. 19. The conversation stays practical and interview-driven, with long answers, legal examples, and repeated comparisons between traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage. 20. Health policy readers, hospital administrators, and claims appeals professionals are the best fit, while listeners wanting a light overview of Medicare may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Business of Healthcare Podcast