The Big Steal · Fresh Air Production

The Man in the Cage

March 17, 2020·20 min·1 clip

Bill Browder explains how Khodorkovsky's cage on live television forced every other oligarch to personally visit Putin and offer him 50%.

The episode opens with the framing of The Big Steal as both a story of economic theft and a broader strategy of subverting democracy worldwide. Episode four focuses on the aftermath of Khodorkovsky's October 2003 arrest, when he was brought from his private plane in Siberia to Moscow, charged with fraud and tax evasion, and placed in a cage in a Moscow courtroom in a deliberate echo of Stalin-era show trials. Vladimir Karamurza describes the arrest as a Kennedy moment for Russia—a signal to the entire business community to stay out of politics. Bill Browder contextualizes the cage: with a 99.8% conviction rate, defendants in Russia are treated as already guilty, and the decision to broadcast Khodorkovsky in a cage was calculated to intimidate every other wealthy Russian watching on television. Browder imagines an oligarch on a yacht off Antibes watching CNN, realizing that if the richest man in Russia could be humiliated this way, so could he. The result, Browder says, was that oligarchs lined up to visit Putin and ask what compliance required—Putin's answer was 50% of their wealth, personally for him, making him the world's richest man. Russia expert Anders Aslund recounts a specific deal in which Putin allegedly received $200 million from the sale of a northern oil company, Severneft, to Rosneft—a transaction involving Igor Sechin, who later became Rosneft's CEO. Khodorkovsky confirms Browder's interpretation, saying the Yukos case damaged faith in courts across all of Russian society and made judges understand they had to comply with government dictates. The episode then turns to Khodorkovsky's prison experience. He describes the dynamics of being the oldest and most educated person in a cell with an average age of 23, how his calm helped others manage hysteria. Most dramatically, he recounts staging a dry hunger strike to force authorities to move his colleague Platon Lebedev out of a punishment isolation cell, after the prison director publicly declared Lebedev would never leave it. On day five of the no-water strike, Khodorkovsky's blood pressure reached 220, confirming the strike was genuine; twelve cellmates refused to sign a false document claiming he was drinking water. Garry Kasparov reframes the official corruption narrative: Khodorkovsky was guilty of wanting to pay taxes to the Russian state rather than into private pockets, and of wanting to integrate Yukos into the global financial system as a transparent multinational—both threats to the existing extraction network. Kasparov notes that with rising oil prices, opacity was more profitable than legitimacy. Anders Aslund maps the sequential targeting: Gusinsky first for media control, Berezovsky next for ORT, Khodorkovsky last for business success, each time under financial pretexts with Putin publicly denying political motives. Foreign investors held Yukos stock on the New York Stock Exchange until the end of 2004, losing an estimated $12 billion when it collapsed. The episode closes with a preview of the next installment covering Yukos employees who died or were jailed on trumped-up charges.

As heard by us

A grave account of how state power, money, and fear fused into one system.

The episode follows Russia's move from communism to kleptocracy through the seizure of Yukos and Mikhail Khodorkovsky's imprisonment. It treats the theft as a system of power, not a one-off scandal, and makes that case through Putin's warning to the oligarchs, courts taking…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a clear account of how Kremlin power turned oil, courts, and fear into leverage.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Big Steal