On Trial: The Hand that Rocks the Cradle (1992 vs 2025)

·1 hr 14 min·5 clips

Mark Radulich and Robert Winfrey debate whether a 1992 psychological thriller holds up against its 2025 remake.

The episode begins with Mark Radulich introducing the 'On Trial' format, where he and guests debate movie merits. He is joined by Robert Winfrey and Erica Poe. They start by discussing the 1992 film 'The Hand That Rocks the Cradle,' directed by Curtis Hanson and starring Rebecca De Mornay. Erica shares her childhood impression of the movie, noting it creeped her out and made her avoid gynecologists. Robert reveals he had never seen it before this recording. Mark recalls seeing it in the 1990s and liking it. The plot involves a woman who, after her doctor husband commits suicide following a sexual assault allegation, becomes a nanny to seek revenge. The hosts analyze the film's structure, debating whether revealing the villain early builds tension effectively. Robert cites Alfred Hitchcock's bomb theory to support this approach. They praise the film's competent writing, acting, and mid-budget professionalism, contrasting it with modern cinema. The conversation shifts to the 2025 remake, which went straight to Hulu. Mark notes it was directed by Michelle Garza Cervera in her American debut. Robert and Mark criticize its rushed production, therapy-speak dialogue, and lack of narrative commitment. They highlight inciting incidents like a house fire and molestation allegations that are poorly developed. Robert calls it a dumpster fire, though some critics praised Mary Elizabeth Winstead's performance. The hosts lament the loss of mid-budget films and the infusion of Gen Z values into remakes. They end by reviewing critical reception and previewing upcoming episodes.

As heard by us

A loose remake debate turns into a wider riff on Hulu, Disney, Fox, and movie arguments that wander well.

On Trial puts The Hand that Rocks the Cradle back in the room for the show's familiar kind of movie argument: loose, opinionated, and willing to re-try a film's merits from more than one angle.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For a Hulu remake debate that keeps pulling Disney's Fox purchase into the room, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Radulich in Broadcasting