Rabbi Avi Wiesenfeld

Kollel Shiur - Bishul 14 (סימן שיח טז-יז) Mixing Foods

·28 min·2 clips
Pouring hot water over congealed fat from meat gravy is an issah, but dropping it in is mutah.
The shiur is working toward the end of the sugya of Shen Yud Ches. The pace moves quickly because the shiur is trying to finish before moving next week, be'ez Hashem, to Reishon Gimel. The central case is pashti, described as pie, placed near the eish. The concern is the shumon, a congealed liquid that may melt. The shiur connects that melting to the issur called Noilat. The key question is whether the person acted be'dayim. One cited view permits the case when the action was not be'dayim. Other cited positions are stricter, while the Shulchanach is presented as permitting it. The Mogen Avram is then brought into the discussion. Fish gravy gets special treatment. Its gravy is treated as food whether it is solid or liquid. That distinction turns on whether changing its form counts as the prohibited change being discussed. The shiur notes that this point could support a much longer analysis, then leaves it aside. A home example follows from a pitcher designed to hold a frozen water container. The question is whether that sealed frozen insert is treated like melting ice for these purposes. The discussion separates ordinary ice in a drink from an ice cube sealed inside plastic. The practical concern is shaped by what the object is doing and by the person's kavanah. The final case turns to returning a pot when the main intention is for children to have food cooked and hot. The shiur presents that purpose as a reason the return may be permitted, while still noting a stricter position in the Mishnah Berurah. It also raises the chiyuv of hot food on Shabbos Kodesh. The learning ends with a further reference to people who do not eat hot food on Shabbos and a continuation promised for next week.

As heard by us

A brisk Shabbos shiur on melting, fish gravy, and sealed ice, grounded in practical kitchen questions.

This shiur works through a fast Shabbos discussion about melting and the line between food and liquid, moving from congealed fat in a pie near the fire to fish gravy and ice sealed inside a pitcher.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a Shabbos kitchen question to shift shape? Start with melting, pie near the fire, fish gravy, and sealed ice.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on