McGohan Brabender Side Affects: Disrupting Health Care · Employee Benefits | Health Care | Wellness | Leadership | Health Management | Innovation | Human Resources | Employee Engagement | Consumerism | Business | McGohan Brabender | Side Affects | Side Effects

Side Affects Episode 161 | The Compliance Risks Hiding in Your Wellness Program

March 6, 2026·34 min·1 clip
HIPAA says 30% incentive limit, but a Missouri court just ruled differently—and other courts will disagree.
Dave Homan frames the conversation around a question many employers eventually run into: how do you build a wellness program that actually works without stepping into avoidable legal trouble? The answer starts with HIPAA. Jason Rothman walks through how HIPAA once sat at the center of wellness program design, especially around population health, tobacco-related incentives, health risk assessments, and BMI testing. Then ACA changed the table. The hosts talk through how ACA brought premium differential rules and other guardrails into the mix, which pushed employers to look beyond the old habit of checking only one lane. That was not the end of it. The episode then moves into the EEOC and ADA layer, where wellness programs with medical exams or medical inquiries can trigger a different legal analysis altogether. That is where the gray area lives. Rothman explains that some employers had programs that looked normal and compliant from a benefits perspective, yet still drew scrutiny because the ADA and EEOC were asking different questions. The hosts keep it practical. Instead of staying abstract, they keep coming back to the employer decisions that matter most: incentive limits, confidentiality, biometric screenings, and reasonable accommodations. Common features get a hard look. The conversation also makes room for the reality that a wellness plan can have multiple moving parts, and each one may touch a different agency or rule set. No single acronym covers all of it. That is why the episode spends time on how employers should think before launch, not after a complaint forces a redesign. Timing matters here. By the end, the picture is clear: a successful wellness strategy needs both employee appeal and legal discipline, not one without the other. The goal is balance. Dave, Tiffany Cook, and Rothman keep the tone approachable so the discussion feels like a workplace problem-solving session rather than a lecture, which helps the legal concepts land. HR leaders, benefits professionals, and business owners will get the most out of it.

As heard by us

A clear map through the compliance traps inside employee wellness programs.

This Side Effects episode frames employee wellness programs as a compliance problem with real-world consequences, not an abstract policy debate.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Before you launch a wellness program, hear where the compliance traps actually sit.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on