Jay Jurden Explains How Millennials Made Comedy an Industry

November 6, 2025·1 hr 25 min·5 clips

Jay Jurden explains why he feels a duty to call out bad stand-up, comparing it to knowing basketball.

Jesse David Fox introduces Jay Jurden as one of the strongest joke writers working today and co-host of a biweekly Vulture stand-up show at Brooklyn's Union Hall. Fox opens by comparing Jurden to Kevin Durant, which Jurden embraces while adding SGA to the comparison, explaining that a guaranteed mid-range jumper in basketball is like a reliable, well-crafted joke in stand-up. Jurden explains the Durant parallel in detail: both are master craftsmen obsessed with their discipline and both spend significant time engaging in online discourse defending the integrity of their craft. Jurden describes calling out people who claim stand-up is dead but only watch Dave Chappelle specials, comparing it to someone who only watches Shaq and claims to know basketball. The conversation turns to the current trend of comedians publicly naming each other in disagreements, including Andrew Schultz directly naming Andrew Santino in a dispute, Taylor Swift's song about Charlie XCX, and Hayley Williams openly explaining her lyrics. Jurden connects this to the history of comedy beef, pointing back to 50 Cent's debut strategy of attacking Ja Rule by name. He argues that comedians today want the fun parts of Tough Crowd but not the accountability of being roasted back. The discussion moves to Jurden's late entry into stand-up, starting seriously in 2017 despite moving to New York in 2015 with BFA and MFA degrees in theater. He describes being scared that other comedians would dismiss him as just an actor, and explains that the open mic scene in 2015-2017 was dominated by white men doing variations of Louis CK, John Mulaney, and Mark Normand. He made a conscious decision from his first mic to always talk about being gay, reasoning it would make him stand out in straight rooms and play well in queer ones. Jurden explains his joke-writing metronome targets a laugh every ten to twelve seconds, so that any silence longer than that signals to the audience that something important is coming, allowing him to execute a rug pull. He addresses the Kill Tony phenomenon, arguing that clips of people saying outrageous things at filmed open mics are unusable by TV bookers and major clubs, making it a dead-end strategy for most comedians. He advocates for recording audio at mics, beta-testing material, and building gradually rather than chasing viral moments. Jurden describes the economics of filming a stand-up special: six expensive cameras, a full crew, a theater, free audience tickets, and a total cost of $100,000 to $150,000. He explains why he chose to work with Comedy Dynamics and sell to Hulu rather than self-finance, arguing that telling everyone to be independent really means telling them to be wealthy. He discusses why he still believes traditional Hollywood pathways work, framing himself as a Pollyanna idealist who thinks good craft will be rewarded. Jurden details his approach to Tonight Show appearances, emphasizing that rehearsal with the crew is essential and that the key is getting away with something slightly naughty that makes the live audience feel they are witnessing something real. He explains how he constructs his current hour, opening with political material before reintroducing himself, then moving through animals, trans people, family, history, and race. He describes wanting to get grosser in his second hour and shed the sanitized habits from his first special. The conversation covers his views on Nikki Glaser's rise after the Tom Brady roast, his respect for Kevin Hart's career trajectory from genuine stand-up craft to movie stardom, and his position that comedy is a service industry where the audience deserves their money's worth.

As heard by us

A sharp comedy conversation about craft, crowds, and the work behind staying original.

Jay Jordan treats stand-up as a craft shaped by crowds, platforms, and the pressure to keep turning a joke into a career. Jesse David Fox gives him room to think aloud about what comedy asks of people now, and the best stretches come when Jordan draws a clear line between…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a comedy talk that argues with the algorithm instead of flattering it.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Good One