Flashback Friday - Jeff Rosenstock

·1 hr 9 min·5 clips

Jeff Rosenstock explains why his new album dropped secretly on New Year's Day.

The basement of A-Bar is where the hosts and Jeff Rosenstock land for this conversation. Jeff comes in as a friend of the podcast and Benny's bandmate, so the episode has the loose feel of a hang already in motion. Sports get the first whistle. The New York Knickerbockers come up, along with a long back-and-forth over whether the show's sports talk also counts as social and political commentary. The hosts joke that they did not chest-bump over sports. They also kick around the fake title "Dunk the Basketball Industry" while making clear that Jeff's sports-averse fans do not need to panic. Jeff then gets into the strange lightness of a year when things have been getting bigger. He says it feels like all gravy, and that the most fun thing starts to look like the obvious thing to do, while joking that the house-money metaphor is not literal. The question of guilt keeps hanging around. Jeff says he carries guilt about almost everything, then says that if he feels any guilt, it is because some of the band's success is tied to the country being in such a bad place. His political writing sits inside that discomfort. He describes it as acknowledging a situation that many other people are not acknowledging, while wondering what it means to do well on the coattails of the worst era in modern American history. The hosts see another angle. They point to the environment Jeff had already built, where talking about issues was part of the band's established identity. Gaslight becomes the useful comparison. The hosts suggest that a band cannot suddenly decide to make a political record and ignore its history, while Jeff's history had already made space for that conversation. Bomb gets cited as something political and obstructionist in its very nature. The talk keeps circling that tension, with the guest sharpening his point while the hosts interrupt just enough to keep the serious parts from going stiff. By the end, the hosts are passing around Patreon, Venmo, reviews, coffee, drinks, tacos, and the suggestion that somebody buy Jeff's new record. They thank Jeff and sign off, having wandered through sports, success, and politics before looping back to the music.

As heard by us

Jeff Rosenstock links sports, political writing, and the uneasy feeling of succeeding in a bleak moment.

Going Off Track starts with sports as the way into a broader Jeff Rosenstock conversation, with his New York Knickerbockers fandom giving the hosts an easy opening before the episode widens out.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get Knickerbockers talk, political unease, and Jeff Rosenstock thinking through music, success, art, and commerce in a messy American moment.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Going Off Track