Everyone Hates Marketers | No-BS Marketing & Brand Strategy Podcast · Louis Grenier | Marketing & Branding

How to Have Better Ideas (Lessons From The Onion’s Creator)

·50 min·4 clips

The Onion survived losing 80% of its staff because nobody knew—the brand was the star, not the writers.

Scott Dikkers co-created The Onion and went on to win over 30 Webby Awards and consult for Pixar and NBC before becoming a comedy teacher. The central argument is that great creative work requires controlling context: comedy is most effective when surrounded by seriousness, which is why The Onion presenting itself as a real news outlet makes its headlines funnier than a magazine presenting itself as inherently funny. Dikkers deliberately hid all writers' names, learning from National Lampoon and Spy Magazine that when writers become celebrities, their departures devastate the brand. The Onion survived an 80% staff exodus around 2010 because no one outside knew it had happened. He also discusses starting new projects under pseudonyms to get a pure, uncontaminated creative test, avoiding both the baggage of past work and the addictive dopamine high of early fame, which he compares to crack cocaine. The mechanics of good idea generation he describes: have individuals write ten ideas privately, not in a group brainstorm, then share them without pitching or caveating, and capture the unfiltered first reaction. That reaction mirrors what an audience will feel. The goal is to generate far more failures than successes. At The Onion, the ratio was roughly one publishable headline per thousand generated. Host Louis Gagne connects these principles to his own podcast, noting that contrarian responses to what you hate about a category are often the cleanest path to differentiation. Dikkers also argues that good ideas must be both original and recognizable simultaneously, that the best comedy happens when a serious formal context is established and then violated, and that anti-humor works precisely because it frustrates expectations established by the medium. The tone is practical and energetic. The audience is marketers, entrepreneurs, and creative professionals seeking frameworks for distinctive brand-building.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Everyone Hates Marketers | No-BS Marketing & Brand Strategy Podcast