Elliman Daily Podcast

Friday Morning Drive | Peter Hernandez with Jennifer Kalish | “How’s the market?” — Do you really know how to answer?

·33 min·3 clips
A Manhattan penthouse sold for its 10-year-old price, showing buyers are smart and sellers are realistic.
The question sounds simple. Peter asks how the market gets read when a broad question has to become a useful answer for a buyer or seller. Jennifer begins with a deal that surprised her. She describes a magnificent penthouse on the Upper West Side with five bedrooms, four and a half baths, and a beautiful roof deck, a lightly lived-in pied-a-terre in an older new development that did not fly off the market. In her view, the property should have sold for close to 20. Instead, Jennifer says the sellers ultimately accepted what they had paid about ten years earlier, while buyers used the moment to choose an existing building and location over a new development down the block that cost 8 million more. That example gives the market question some bite. Jennifer argues that the resale condo market is where the value can show up, especially when a building has already stood the test of time and the competing new-development product may still be something buyers cannot fully judge. She keeps the point grounded. When Peter asks about the signals she studies, Jennifer moves to inventory and explains that she looks for a lack of three-, four-, or five-bedroom homes before contacting an old client or someone she knows who may have the right property. That is where a trend becomes a phone call. The discussion also shows a broker whose business does not follow what she describes as the traditional or typical model, because she says she is out a lot and willing to spend time and energy when she sees a possible opportunity. Peter keeps pressing the question. He asks whether the focus is listings or buyers, then names inventory, pricing, and velocity as the kinds of trends he wants to understand. Jennifer comes back to inventory. Her answer stays practical, connecting a shortage in a specific size category to direct outreach rather than an abstract market forecast. The penthouse story remains the conversation's clearest proof point. It shows how seller realism, a buyer's willingness to do some work, and the relative price of new development can change what a market headline really means. The Friday Morning Drive closes on that working rhythm. Peter thanks Jennifer, asks the group to give her a thumbs up, and Jennifer offers to be a resource for help, advice, and future business.

As heard by us

A recent Upper West Side penthouse sale grounds a focused discussion of resale value, inventory, and seller realism.

A Friday Morning Drive conversation turns market chatter into a grounded look at where value may still be hiding. Jennifer moves from a recent Upper West Side penthouse sale into the signals she watches in everyday brokerage work, using the five-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a sharp Upper West Side resale story that makes "How's the market?" feel concrete?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on