Dollars and Dumbbells - Profit and Wealth Tips for Online Health and Fitness Coaches · Justin Green, CFP®

173 - How to Build a Personal Brand as an Online Coach w/ Ali Gilbert

·50 min·3 clips

Allie says her team pushed her to lean into polarization because 'polarization really sells.'

1. Dollars and Dumbbells episode 173 centers on Justin Green and Allie Gilbert discussing personal branding for online coaches. 2. Justin Green hosts the show as a Certified Financial Planner, and Allie Gilbert is the guest because she built Silverback Coaching and the Silverback Summit. 3. The episode asks how Allie built a recognizable brand as a woman in men's health and why that branding brings clients. 4. Allie says she grew up in Greenwich, Connecticut, a wealthy town with 'nine golf clubs,' and trained golfers at a college gym. 5. She says golfers were type A, paid for coaching, and pushed her to learn golf fitness through the Titleist Performance Institute certification. 6. Allie says that work led to a 99% male clientele and deeper questions about hormones, nutrition, and how men wanted to look in golf shirts. 7. She says her first business with a doctor started in 2012 and involved selling lab panels before people could easily buy blood work online. 8. Allie says she later divested because it was not in her integrity to upcharge labs that were already available for less money elsewhere. 9. She describes building relationships with physicians, attending medical conferences, and trying to bridge fitness and medical professionals who often alienate each other. 10. Allie says her current remote business combines hormones, training, nutrition, mindset, and lifestyle for high-level men who otherwise piece services together. 11. She says men often feel safer opening up to her because a woman asking about 'boner problems' can feel less intimidating than a jacked male coach. 12. Justin says her short hair, mohawk, and muscles make her brand hard to forget, and Allie agrees that her look already polarizes people. 13. Allie says her content team told her that 'polarization really sells,' which pushed her to lean harder into the traits people react to. 14. She says negative comments after a Mark Bell reel sent her into a 'spiral for a couple weeks' before she learned to ignore trolls. 15. Allie says she now claps back less, lets other people argue for her, and even sees troll arguments as engagement for the algorithm. 16. She gives examples like cast-iron-skillet posts, barbell pads, gloves, toe shoes, Crocs, and camo sports bras to show how self-deprecating humor fits her brand. 17. The conversation is loose, blunt, and reflective, with Justin matching Allie's Northeast style and often laughing through the exchanges. 18. The format stays interview-driven and practical, with many examples from gyms, reels, comments, and client conversations. 19. Coaches who want a clearer online brand and better client-facing messaging will get the most from this episode. 20. Coaches chasing only peer approval or polished perfection may skip it.

As heard by us

A candid look at branding, reputation, and public-facing work.

Allie Gilbert treats personal branding as a practical problem: how to stay memorable without sanding off the traits that make the brand work. Justin Green keeps the conversation in coaching-world terms, so it stays tied to reputation, visibility, and the reality of being…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a candid masterclass in personal branding from someone who made a niche memorable?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Dollars and Dumbbells - Profit and Wealth Tips for Online Health and Fitness Coaches