Constitutional Chats Presented By Constituting America

Ep. 297 | Constitutional Chats Podcast | Hon. Bob Pence | Consent of the Governed at 250: The Principle That Still Defines Us

April 10, 2026·57 min·4 clips
Jefferson's 'long train of abuses and usurpations' comes directly from Locke's right of revolution.
1. Constitutional Chats Presented By Constituting America centers on Bob Pence's essay about the "consent of the governed," John Locke, and the Declaration of Independence. 2. Kathy and Janine host Bob Pence, addressed as Ambassador Pence, because he wrote the study essay and brings a diplomatic and historical lens. 3. Pence treats "consent" as the episode's thesis, arguing that the American founding depends on when people grant, limit, or withdraw authority. 4. He opens with Aristotle's Politics and the line about kings who "relinquished some of their powers," then contrasts that with rulers who take power by force or inheritance. 5. He uses Thomas Hobbes's state of nature to describe a world where everyone has the right to "outgrab everybody else and take what they wanted." 6. He then turns to John Locke, the Glorious Revolution of 1688, and the rise of Parliament under William and Mary as the path away from divine-right monarchy. 7. Pence ties that shift to the American colonies, pointing to the 1765 taxes, quartering soldiers in Boston, the Boston Tea Party of 1773, and the Boston Massacre of 1768. 8. He says Locke's Two Treatises on Government, especially the second treatise from 1690, became a cornerstone of modern democratic theory in England and America. 9. Pence also traces the essay's intellectual background through Cicero's On Duties, George Mason's reading habits, and Jefferson's donation of Cicero volumes to the Library of Congress after the British burned it. 10. The conversation pivots to Ralph Waldo Emerson's "Concord Hymn" and the line about the "shot heard round the world," which Bob uses to show how poetry preserves history. 11. Pence tells the John Morton story in Pennsylvania, where Morton's yes vote gave the delegation's support to the Declaration of Independence. 12. He counts only three uses of the word "consent" in the Declaration and contrasts them with the repeated idea of "assent" in colonial governance. 13. He identifies Locke's influence in six Jeffersonian ideas: natural rights, property as the basis of society, government by consent, social contract, limited power, and the right of revolution. 14. Pence cites Jefferson's "long train of abuses and usurpations" language as Locke's second-treatise logic turned into a declaration of independence. 15. The Q&A moves into free will when Mary asks about Cicero's Tusculan Disputations and Dante's Divine Comedy, and Pence links consent to vows and moral choice. 16. He also recalls George Washington asking his troops to consent to a brief extension of their service so the army could cross the Delaware in winter. 17. The tone is conversational and lecture-like, with Kathy, Janine, Jewel, Mary, and Tova steering Bob Pence through a civics-and-classics seminar. 18. The format mixes prepared remarks, audience questions, Emerson's poem recitation, and a closing patriotism discussion built around teaching history and serving others. 19. Listeners who like the American founding, political philosophy, and classical references will get the most from it. 20. Listeners wanting a fast entertainment segment or a story with a surprise ending may skip it.

As heard by us

John Morton's Pennsylvania vote turns consent of the governed from principle into action.

Consent of the governed comes into focus here through the political choices that made independence possible. Ambassador Bob Pence links John Locke and other philosophers to the American debate before turning to John Morton, whose deciding vote in Pennsylvania's delegation helped…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play when one Pennsylvania vote and the First Amendment can sharpen how you hear consent.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on