Shortcut: A victim’s perspective of the mental impairment defence re-issue

March 18, 2026·18 min·1 clip

David Camerata heard his friend's name on the radio and saw the chilling vision of him waiting with a samurai sword.

This re-issued episode of Australian True Crime presents a victim's perspective on the mental impairment defense in the legal system. Hosts Meshel Laurie and Emily Webb revisit a case involving the Thomas Embling Hospital, a secure psychiatric facility in Melbourne. The episode contrasts an earlier interview with the hospital's Dr. Danny Sullivan with new testimony from David Camerata, a close friend and victim of a forensic patient. Dr. Sullivan explained that forensic patients are admitted under the Crimes Act due to mental impairment at the time of their offense or an inability to stand trial. These individuals, often convicted of violent crimes, receive treatment under custodial supervision orders rather than fixed prison sentences. The episode cites specific patients like Sean Christian Price, who assaulted a government minister in 2006 and later committed murder, and Ross Conadaris, who re-offended violently while on day release. David Camerata describes his former best friend, Jonathan Dick, who was the best man at his wedding. Camerata recounts noticing Dick's personality darken, with Dick later describing a delusional vision of being attacked by Camerata and his own brother. The central violent event occurred when Dick, armed with a samurai sword, murdered his brother David at a shopping center and later ambushed Camerata at his home. Camerata describes skipping down his front steps carefree before being struck from behind, initially thinking something fell from the roof. He fought off the attack, suffering a severe neck wound that exposed deep tissue, which he discovered after reassuring his crying children. For a year afterward, Camerata and his family lived in constant fear, moving between three different households with their three children while Dick remained at large. Dick was eventually captured after stalking Camerata for nine days, spotted near Hosier Lane in Melbourne's CBD. The court found Dick not guilty by way of mental impairment due to paranoid schizophrenia and ordered him to Thomas Embling Hospital. A striking insight is Camerata's description of the ongoing uncertainty for victims, as they receive no notification when a forensic patient is granted day release. He details his lasting psychological trauma, requiring four daily medications and hypervigilance with routine actions like opening doors or identifying people walking behind him. Camerata argues the system's risk to the community when assessments are wrong, citing past failures with other patients. He acknowledges the hospital's role in treating mental illness but emphasizes the potentially fatal consequences of incorrect evaluations for victims. The episode notes a recent government upgrade added 80 beds to the Thomas Embling facility, bringing its total to approximately 200. The tone is intensely personal and narrative, blending an interview format with vivid, descriptive storytelling. The style is conversational yet investigative, presenting a deeply emotional firsthand account against a backdrop of systemic explanation. Listeners interested in the human impact of forensic psychiatry and the complexities of justice for victims of violent crime would find this episode compelling. Those seeking a purely clinical or legal analysis of the mental impairment defense might find the perspective too singularly focused on one traumatic experience.

As heard by us

A victim-centred look at mental impairment law, an ambush, and the fear that follows release decisions.

Australian True Crime keeps the mental impairment defence close to the people left living with its consequences. It begins at Thomas Embling Hospital in Melbourne, explaining the two legal pathways into the secure psychiatric facility, including cases where a court finds someone…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Australian True Crime