ATC Discusses: The Investigation of Lucy Letby

February 20, 2026·31 min·2 clips

How does circumstantial evidence form a rope strong enough to convict a nurse of killing seven babies?

The conversation begins with a warning. Michelle Laurie and Matthew Tankett frame this as a discussion episode after watching the Netflix documentary on Lucy Letby. Michelle has seen it twice. She says it made her less doubtful, not more, but the online commentary has still pushed her to check her own certainty. Matthew flags the risk early. This is a case full of medical evidence and public argument, and they are not pretending to be experts. The tone is careful rather than dramatic. They keep coming back to the difference between one suspicious detail and a pattern that becomes harder to wave away. Diary evidence gets treated with caution. Michelle connects it to the Folbig case, where private writing was later understood differently. The point is simple but serious: guilt on a page does not automatically prove intent. Letby's explanation is handled plainly. She said she wrote those things because she was an experienced nurse and felt she should have saved the babies. But Michelle and Matthew do not leave it there. They weigh that against other details, including hospital documents taken home and kept in a box. That part hits harder for them. The notes were described as filed chronologically in a box marked keep, even though Letby said she did not know how to dispose of them. The Folbig comparison helps them question diary evidence without smoothing over everything else. They close by inviting more civilians into future discussion episodes, then give support contacts and acknowledge traditional owners.

As heard by us

A firm, uneasy discussion of Lucy Letby, sharpest when it weighs diary evidence against the messier threads around the hospital paperwork.

Australian True Crime sits with the Lucy Letby case after Michelle Laurie and executive producer Matthew Tankett watched the recent Netflix documentary and found themselves circling the same uneasy question: what does the evidence really add up to?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Australian True Crime