Chatty true crime with sharp case reactions.
Which Murderer? is a conversational true-crime show built around two-case episodes, messy real-time reactions, and darkly practical moral debates. The tone can swing from lockdown grumbling and snack talk to murder trials, family grief, and strange forensic twists in a matter of minutes.
PRESS PLAY
Which Murderer? is built for true-crime listeners who like their cases told by people, not by a sealed-off narrator. The show has structure, but it does not pretend to be tidy. A typical episode opens with everyday chatter, social media mentions, listener suggestions, or the kind of housekeeping that makes the room feel occupied before the case begins. Then the tone shifts. The hosts move through murders, attacks, trials, confessions, letters, family statements, and strange investigative details in plain chronological chunks. The episodes show cases involving chainsaw murders, ax murderers, paranormal claims, children who kill, murdered-without-a-trace stories, and murders by proxy. Some details are grim and painful. Others are so strange that the hosts stop to laugh at the logic, the names, the excuses, or the sheer weirdness of a historical moment. That mix is the show’s signature. It can discuss victim impact and family devastation with care, then veer into a side comment about cookies, lockdown, television, a productivity shot, or Tom Hardy. The result feels closer to two people telling each other researched murder stories than to a studio-built documentary. Evidence matters here, but so does reaction. The show notices when a suspect’s story changes, when a letter becomes damning, when a community responds in a bizarre way, or when a detail feels almost too absurd to be real. It is opinionated without becoming clinical. It is casual without losing sight of the harm. Listeners looking for strict minimalism may find the pre-case banter too loose. Listeners who enjoy conversational true crime will likely find that looseness familiar and appealing. Which Murderer? works best when the odd human texture around the case becomes part of the experience.
Made for: For true-crime listeners who like researched murder stories delivered with banter, blunt reactions, and a conversational pace. It suits people who do not mind tangents before and between grim details.
What sets it apart: The show stands out by letting the case discussion stay messy, reactive, and social rather than polished into distance. Listener shout-outs, side comments, and moral gut checks sit right beside trial evidence and victim impact.
Which Murderer brings together two hosts who talk about the methods, motives and background to murderers and their victims, covering two crimes per episode and debating from the victim's perspective which murderer they would pick to kill them if they HAD to choose. Hosted by Holly (the Canadian) and Garry (the Scot) from Scotland. Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/whichmurderer/) Twitter (https://twitter.com/whichmurderer) Explicit content and subject matter.
Based on 6 episodes we listened to · September 2026
Which Murderer? makes case histories approachable through themed storytelling, active questioning, and a host dynamic that keeps uncertainty visible.
Which Murderer? builds episodes around sharply defined themes, moving from children who murder and ax murderers to office-party killings, unexplained disappearances, and cases involving paranormal claims.
A jazz party to dodge the Axeman: your true crime curiosity gets an exceptionally odd survival tip.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A conversational murder case that keeps the sentence close to the family's grief.
This conversational true-crime episode traces Jonathan's path from the killing and his call to police minutes later to a manslaughter plea the hosts say does not appear to have been accepted, then to his guilty plea to murder and a 25-year sentence.
The Axeman tale turns eerie when New Orleans answers murder with jazz.
That blend of banter and folklore gives Witch Murderer a lively frame for the Axeman of New Orleans, and the episode does a good job tracing how fear spread across the city.
Grace's letters and Chester's changing story give this true crime case its sharpest edge.
The episode stays with a true crime case where Grace's letters, Chester's shifting stories, and the physical details around the boat trip do most of the work.
A late-19th-century murder case turns uncanny when ghost testimony enters the courtroom story.
The oddest hook in this Which Murderer? episode is not forensic evidence or a clean confession, but the idea of ghost testimony making its way into court.
A story about children who murder, carried by candid banter and rough, human edges.
The episode settles into a story about children who murder, and its clearest stretch arrives when the hosts work through Amarjeet Sada and Mashahar, Bihar, India while admitting what they do not know in the moment.
A false start, a difficult search, and a case that stays stubbornly unresolved.
Witch Murderer keeps its office-party setting in uneasy, very human territory, and the hosts are candid about how punishing the research became after Kirsty, one of the murder twins, raised the case.
Sleepy, loose, and carried by easy host chemistry.
The episode settles into sleepy morning banter and keeps that conversational feel throughout, moving from bad sleep and a new pillow to a chiropractor booking and a sideways turn toward The Krays.
Two friends narrate true crime cases, listener stories, and archived live-tour shows.
Multi-part true crime narration, from BTK's Wichita letters to Australian cold-case disappearances.
ABC Audio's Theranos fraud series that also introduces its other true-crime podcasts.
LA Times reporter Christopher Goffard traces con man John Meehan's fraud, abuse, and its Bravo TV adaptation.
Hosts Holly and Garry discuss two murder cases in their signature debate format.
Hosts Holly and Garry tackle the listener-suggested theme 'office party murders', starting with the 2015 San Bernardino shooting by Syed Rizwan Farooq and Tashfeen Malik.
Two hosts debate which murderer they would choose to kill them, analyzing methods and motives.
The hosts discuss a near-miss car accident and a sheep encounter before starting their crime analysis.
The hosts introduce a new episode about hitmen, discussing spelling differences and their excitement for the topic.
Hosts Holly and Gemma of the Which Murderer podcast cover two real chainsaw murder cases in this flashback episode.
Hosts Holly and Gemma of Which Murderer cover two axe murder cases: the unsolved Axeman of New Orleans serial killings from 1918 to 1919, and the 2015 attack in which Henri van Breda killed his parents and brother with an axe in their South African home and was sentenced to three life sentences in 2018.
Grace May Brown's 1906 death at Big Moose Lake and Simon Ng's 2005 apartment attack both leave records that point straight at the men involved.
Witch Murderer's paranormal-murders episode pairs the Hammersmith ghost panic in London with the West Virginia case of Elva Zona Heaster Shue.
Which Murderer?
The episode begins with advertisements for Instagram teen accounts and Moto Casino before transitioning into the show's introduction.