A civil rights photographer, an FBI number, no easy verdict.
Unfinished is a documentary investigation from Witness Docs at Stitcher, told one season at a time and built from archival recordings, interviews and FBI files voiced by an actor. Its Ernie's Secret season looks at Ernest Withers, who photographed the civil rights movement in Memphis while holding FBI informant number ME-338R.
PRESS PLAY
Unfinished is a documentary investigation from Witness Docs at Stitcher, built one season at a time. Casey Holford, a technical director at Stitcher Studios, names two of those seasons in the feed: Deep South and Ernie's Secret. The recent episodes belong to Ernie's Secret. Its subject is Ernest Withers, a Memphis photographer who seemed to be at every movement gathering and who also held FBI informant number ME-338R. Nobody on tape agrees on what that makes him. One account lists the bureau alongside JET, Ebony and the New York Times as just another client that wrote him a check. A voice speaking of him as 'my father' says Withers deliberately stayed out of the meetings where real decisions were made. Others say plainly that it was a choice. Then comes the paper trail. An actor, Corey Landis, voices the FBI documents. The diary of Withers' contact Bill Lawrence has Withers telling a congressional committee that the FBI merely bought his pictures, which contradicted what Lawrence had written in official reports. The setting is Memphis under strain: a Martin Luther King march that ended with shattered windows on Beale Street and newspapers across the country questioning his tactics, and a Mason Temple so packed that people stood in the rain calling for King. Young Black power organizers, Charles Cabbage among them, took Withers' advice and his loans and posed for his camera. The reporting also looks beyond one man. After the riots, Withers became part of an FBI surveillance effort with more than 7,000 informants in cities across the country. Other accounts describe the bureau approaching a pastor with a friendly request to come by now and then to talk, and threatening someone who covered the Black Panthers with a subpoena. The series takes the question of harm seriously. Kathy was targeted in a loyalty investigation and refused to sign a privacy waiver. She lost her job, sued and was reinstated, and she says every day of it was hell. Archival sound, including King accepting the Nobel Prize for peace, runs alongside the interviews. Every Ernie's Secret episode opens with a 'Previously on' recap, so the season plays as a serial. The credits name a fact-checker, Kelvin Bias, and the episodes close with Wesley Lowry's sign-off. The feed also carries a preview of Sounds Gay, another documentary series Holford worked on, about music, sound and queer lives.
Made for: Suits a listener who wants civil rights history told through primary sources and conflicting testimony, and who can live with a moral question that stays open for a whole season.
What sets it apart: Unfinished does not settle Ernest Withers into hero or traitor. It puts his defenders, people the bureau watched and the FBI's own paper trail on tape to contradict each other, and it keeps the cost to real people in view.
Witness Docs presents Unfinished, an investigative anthology series digging into America's unfinished business. Season 1, Deep South, produced in collaboration with Market Road Films, brought us on a journey into the Arkansas Delta to investigate the lynching of Isadore Banks. Season 2, produced with Critical Frequency, takes us to Short Creek, a community on the Utah/Arizona border divided by much more than a state line. Season 3, produced with Scripps, explores dual loyalties and hidden histories via the story of Ernest Withers, one of the most important photographers of the 20th century -- who was both a Civil Rights Movement photographer and a FBI informant. Hear more great stories about…
In a parking lot, Elisa hugs a man blaming her for his loss; your easy verdict gets harder.
Press play if you want
Short reviews from the PlayNext desk, based on the episodes we processed.
A focused queer history of CCM traces how teen music marketing carried evangelical identity.
Sounds Gay turns to the Christian Contemporary Music boom of the 1990s and early 2000s, looking at how a very white industry sold faith-friendly music to teenagers and their parents while reinforcing evangelical Christianity.
Ernest Withers's FBI record is tested against his congressional testimony.
A retired FBI agent's diary turns Ernest Withers into a problem of competing stories. Before Withers's 1978 congressional testimony, Bill Lawrence records repeated failed attempts to reach M.E. 338-R and worries that something very bad might happen.
A tense account of a violent Memphis march, King's public crisis, and the call that drew him back.
Unfinished follows Martin Luther King after a Memphis march meant to be peaceful broke into smashed windows, looted stores, fires, injuries, and a death by police.
A photographer's intimate access becomes evidence in the FBI's surveillance effort around Black organizing in Memphis.
Ernest Withers turns a Memphis photographer's access toward surveillance in "The Invaders," which follows his work as an FBI informant after urban racial violence and into the organizing around Charles Cabbage and Kobe Smith.
A stark, personal account of FBI files and the fear they left behind.
Ernie's Secret follows the path from Ernest's FBI work to Kathy's life, where surveillance became personal and hard to shake. Kathy gives the episode its strongest human center: after refusing a privacy waiver, she was fired, sued in federal court, and eventually reinstated.
Overlooked lives, read from the sources, talked through warmly.
Mike Duncan narrates Rome's full history solo, from Aeneas to Romulus Augustulus's exile in 476.
Sarah Esikoff opens Sounds Gay as a Stitcher Studios documentary series about music, sound, queer lives, and culture, and Casey Holford frames the premiere as a CCM story.
Unfinished's "Ernie's Secret" follows Bill Lawrence, a retired FBI agent in Spruce Pine, North Carolina, and Ernest Withers, the Memphis photographer known in FBI files as M.E.
Unfinished's "Ernie's Secret" follows Martin Luther King Jr.'s final Memphis trip on April 3 and April 4, 1968, after the violent sanitation workers march and the death of 16-year-old Larry Payne.
Ernest Withers sits at the center of Unfinished: Ernie's Secret, which follows the March 28, 1968 Memphis sanitation march and the FBI files around it.
Unfinished's "Ernie's Secret | E7 Harm / No Harm?" asks whether Ernest Withers' FBI work on Memphis activists did direct damage or only reflected a larger COINTELPRO machine.
Unfinished: Ernie's Secret | E6 Informants examines Ernest Withers's relationship with the FBI from 1958 to 1976 and the wider informant network surrounding the civil rights movement.
Unfinished: Ernie's Secret examines Ernest Withers's simultaneous work as a civil rights photographer and FBI informant during the 1960s.
Unfinished: Ernie's Secret | E4 Fayette County examines how Black voter registration in Fayette County, Tennessee, triggered evictions, economic retaliation, and the Tent City encampment in 1960.
Unfinished: Ernie’s Secret | E3 Two Daughters examines how FBI agent Bill Lawrence and photographer Ernest Withers became connected through Memphis’s civil-rights conflicts.
Unfinished: Ernie's Secret | E1 The Perfect Cover introduces Ernest Withers, a Memphis photographer whose images documented Little Rock, Emmett Till's trial, the Montgomery bus boycott, and the 1968 sanitation strike.
Reporter Mark Paraschia investigates whether Memphis photographer Ernest Withers secretly supplied the FBI with information about civil-rights activists.
Unfinished: Short Creek's bonus AMA brings hosts Ash Sanders and Sarah Ventry together with producer Abigail Keel to answer roughly 50 listener questions about Season 2.
Unfinished: Short Creek | E10 Hallelujah follows Donia Jessup, Elisa Wall, Rob Radley, and Roy Jeffs as Short Creek tests whether democratic institutions and personal relationships can move beyond FLDS rule.
Unfinished: Short Creek | E9 Grassroots in the Desert follows Terrell Musser, Shirley Draper, Donia Jessup, and Elisa Wall as ex-FLDS residents organize after the Department of Justice discrimination case.
Unfinished: Short Creek | E8 Can I Get A Witness?
Unfinished: Short Creek | E7 This Land is Our Land follows the conflict between FLDS believers and ex-believers over homes, land, policing, and community identity.
In Unfinished episode “Short Creek | E6 This One’s for You, Gramsy,” Donia and Joe Jessup describe being shunned for marrying without FLDS prophet Rulon Jeffs’s approval.
Unfinished: Short Creek | E5 Answer Them Nothing follows Elisa Wall after leaving the FLDS, learning everyday skills at 18, and reporting that her 12- and 9-year-old sisters had disappeared.
Unfinished: Short Creek | E4 examines how Mormon persecution narratives shaped loyalty to Warren Jeffs and the FLDS community.
Unfinished: Short Creek | E3 Keep Sweet, No Matter What examines how Warren Jeffs turned “keep sweet” from a repeated religious mantra into demands for obedience, school withdrawal, surveillance, and family separation.
Unfinished: Short Creek | E1 The Why Child introduces Short Creek through reporters Ash Sanders and Sarah Ventry and survivor Elisa Wall’s account of FLDS authority.
Unfinished’s “Short Creek | E2 Prophets and Losses” traces how Short Creek shifted from Leroy Johnson’s communal “United Order” toward centralized authority under Rulon Jeffs and Warren Jeffs.
Stephanie Kiryuki moderates a conversation with Taylor Hom, Neil Shea, Ash Sanders, and Sarah Ventry about Unfinished: Deep South and the upcoming season, Short Creek.
Unfinished: Deep South | E10 The Things We Haven’t Seen investigates the 1954 killing of Isidore Banks, a World War I veteran and Arkansas landowner who was found chained to a tree and burned.
Lena Williams meets Vera Simonetti after a delayed 2010 graveside ceremony for her grandfather, Isidore Banks, who was lynched in Marion, Arkansas.
Unfinished: Deep South | E8 follows Taylor Hom and Neil Shea’s search for who lynched Isidore Banks, a 59-year-old Arkansas farmer, World War I veteran, businessman, and former owner of nearly 1,000 acres.
Unfinished Deep South | E7 The Stepdaughter follows journalists Neil Shea and Taylor Hom as they locate Julie, the eight-year-old stepdaughter connected to Andrew Anderson’s 1963 killing in Marion, Arkansas.
Unfinished Deep South: Episode 6, "The House Painter," investigates Sam Burns after Rosalind O'Neill says he drunkenly claimed to have killed Isidore Banks.
Unfinished: Deep South | E5 A Very American Crime examines how lynching was defined, organized, and used to preserve racial and economic hierarchy in the United States.
Unfinished: Deep South | E4 White Memories examines the 1954 lynching of Isidore Banks in Marion, Arkansas, whose body was chained to a tree and burned.
Unfinished: Deep South | E3 Family Ties traces Isidore Banks from his 1895 birth in Rome, Georgia, through his family's move to Crittenden County, Arkansas.
Unfinished: Deep South | E2 The High Sheriff investigates how Sheriff Cecil Goodwin’s power in Crittenden County may have intersected with Isidore Banks’s lynching and land loss.
Unfinished: Deep South | E1 Isadore Banks reconstructs the life of Isidore Banks, a wealthy African-American farmer and business owner in Marion, Arkansas, who was lynched in 1954.